A Ruin of Roses

K.F. Breene

47 pages 1-hour read

K.F. Breene

A Ruin of Roses

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 9-13Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of sexual content, bullying, emotional abuse, and cursing.

Chapter 9 Summary

Nyfain carries Finley back to her tower room and changes back to his human form, where the two fight for the key to the door. They end up sprawled on the bed, bodies pressed together. Though Finley wants him, she refuses to give in and shoves him away, handing over the key. Nyfain leaves and locks her in. That night, Finley dreams she’s having sex with Nyfain, only to wake and realize it was a dream powered by an incubus who’s right outside her door. The sound of a scuffle comes from outside, and Nyfain arrives, having killed the incubus.


Nyfain will escort Finley to the garden to tend the everlass. Contrary to his earlier surliness, Nyfain now makes jokes about Finley needing to wear real clothes so he doesn’t kill everyone in the castle for looking at her the wrong way. He also insists she keep her animal under control so he doesn’t want to have sex with her. Finley tells him to take responsibility for his own animal, which makes Nyfain surly again. Much as the discussion and Nyfain’s attitude irritate her, Finley is glad he’s back to his usual, disagreeable self because it would be dangerous for her to be attracted to him.


In the hallway, the dead incubus has returned to its true form—a green, scaly creature with a barbed tail. The demon king left his sex demons at the castle and took most of his battle demons to war. Even so, with the castle and villages weak from the curse, it would be simple for the demon king to destroy them, and Nyfain waits for the destruction with no plan to stop it. Finley becomes angry, telling him to stop wallowing and start leading because his people need him. Before Nyfain can respond, a demon arrives. Nyfain shoves Finley behind him protectively as the demon questions Nyfain about why he kept this prisoner alive instead of killing her immediately like he has all the others. The demon promises Finley sweet escape if she comes to him, and remembering Hadriel’s warning about the importance of not standing out, Finley says nothing.

Chapter 10 Summary

With a possessive, protective hand to her hip, Nyfain guides Finley away from the demon and out to the everlass garden. Finley hates that she played coward in front of the demon, but Nyfain assures her it’s the best way to deal with them because they feed off high emotions. At the garden, Nyfain is eager to help her. He misses working on the plants with his mother, which was the one thing they did together. As Nyfain and Finley harvest the leaves, Nyfain tells her about his past—how his father taunted him for Nyfain’s enjoyment of “women’s work” with the plants and how Nyfain was always taught to fight for dominance among his brothers. Despite herself, Finley finds herself feeling for him and enjoying the time together. When they finish with the everlass, Nyfain escorts her back toward the castle, but Finley wishes they could stay outside because, in the garden, it feels like they could get to a place “of being friends instead of enemies” (226).


Before they can get inside, Nyfain picks up the scent of demons on the night air. He pushes Finley against a tree, making it look like he’s sexually assaulting her so the demons won’t suspect that there’s more to her presence in the castle than a way to satisfy Nyfain’s needs. He refuses to have sex with her, but he uses his hands to pleasure her until they are interrupted by the demon they encountered inside.

Chapter 11 Summary

Nyfain jerks away from Finley and fixes her clothes. The demon again offers to pleasure Finley, and Nyfain tells the demon he’ll kill it if it touches her. Nyfain escorts Finley back to her room, where he knows he should leave but doesn’t. Instead, he picks up where they left off outside, using his hands and mouth to bring Finley to orgasm. Afterwards, he leaves in a huff, clearly battling his arousal. Finley crawls into bed and has an inner dialogue with her animal, who tells her that Nyfain’s beast carries guilt and feels like he needs to be saved. Neither Finley nor her animal agree, both deciding “Nyfain needed to save himself” (249).

Chapter 12 Summary

The next morning, Hadriel brings Finley to get fitted for clothes, and then the two head outside to choose a garden for her to tend. Finley chooses the one visible from her tower window, hopping a wall to explore against Hadriel’s protests that the garden belonged to Nyfain’s mother. As she picks her way through overgrown plants and weeds, Finley finds a patio with doors leading into an immaculately cleaned sitting room with a rose bush somehow growing straight out of the floor. Suddenly, the room’s door opens, revealing Nyfain, and with a jolt, Finley realizes he’s the prince.


Nyfain rushes to stand over the rose bush protectively. The demons implanted it in the floor, and each year, it dies a little more as a reminder of the part Nyfain played in the heartbreak that killed his mother. Nyfain reveals he’s been watching Finley’s village because it has the only healthy rosebush left in the kingdom and that he let her escape the night nine years ago because of her skill with the everlass. He crowds into her space, telling her how much he wants her. Finley is incredibly aroused, but she refuses to give in to it. Her family and all the people in the villages need her to stop the demons and cure the curse.

Chapter 13 Summary

After the encounter, Finley decides to leave the castle. Despite always having a keen sense of direction in the Forbidden Wood before, now Finley can’t find the way back to her village. Finley’s animal tries to talk her out of leaving: Together, Finley and Nyfain could be strong enough to fight the demon king. Still, Finley refuses to go back, and as the sky grows darker, she hears the creatures of the forest waking around her. With her animal’s help, Finley fights them off as best she can, but it isn’t enough. At the edge of the woods near her village, they surround her, and she expects to die.

Chapters 9-13 Analysis

Finley and Nyfain grow closer in these chapters as each starts to work through their preconceived notions of the other. Nyfain realizes Finley’s resilience arises from her experience Escaping Restrictive Gender Norms. Because she is different, she stands out, and that has made her willing to try where others give up. He doesn’t yet understand the importance of her perspective, which leads to an unexpected clash between his hopelessness and her determination. By contrast, Finley starts to see how Nyfain’s life as evidence of The Harm that Comes from Shirking Responsibility. Where Nyfain expects Finley to take responsibility for his attraction to her, this shirking of responsibility does not translate to the rest of who Nyfain is. When it comes to protecting the kingdom and dealing with the demons, Nyfain shows a level of responsibility he does not show in his personal life. Both Finley and Nyfain put the wellbeing of others before themselves. While they exercise control in different ways, they put their control toward the same goals, bringing out each’s sense of competition and foreshadowing how they will have to put their competitive natures aside to work together and save the kingdom.


Chapter 10 delves deeper into Nyfain’s past and his own struggles with Escaping Restrictive Gender Norms. Like Finley, Nyfain experienced the pressure of what society has dictated a man should be, which often directly contradicted who Nyfain is. Nyfain’s father believed in adherence to traditional gender roles and reinforced that adherence among his children. As a result, Nyfain was forced to pride himself on strength and dominance when his true nature was caring, and this internal conflict resulted in Nyfain feeling conflicted about who he should be—all the way up until the present. His inability to reconcile his father’s demands with his mother’s kindness makes him a victim of his own desires. He does not trust his emotions around Finley because he has been taught that his feelings will lead him astray. Since Finley is unaware of this, she sees his back-and-forth toward her as surliness, which triggers her own anger because it reminds her of her ex-boyfriend and how he lied about his feelings. This also shows how Finley’s internal motivations counter one another. She is willing to do whatever it takes to save lives, but she is unwilling to take responsibility for Nyfain’s emotional life, recognizing that this responsibility is his alone.


Chapters 12 and 13 borrow heavily from the Disney adaptations of Beauty and the Beast. Finley’s exploration of the garden and queen’s chambers in Chapter 12 alludes to Belle’s visiting the forbidden West Wing in the movie. The decay of the queen’s chambers coupled with details like a mirror are further similarities between these two versions of the story, and the rosebush in the floor alludes to the movie’s enchanted rose. Nyfain’s arrival mimics Belle being discovered by the Beast, as does his defense of the rosebush. Breene expands upon the movie version by making the roses a symbol of Nyfain’s relationship with his mother, deepening the emotional significance of this symbol. As in the movie, Nyfain refuses to explain to Finley the true significance of the roses, instead displaying an inappropriate emotional response to finding Finley in his mother’s quarters. Finley’s battle to escape the Forbidden Wood in Chapter 13 calls to Belle’s encounter with the wolves and sets up for how Finley and Nyfain grow closer, only for him to pull away.


The encounter between Nyfain and Finley in the queen’s chambers highlights The Importance of Resilience. Since his mother’s death, Nyfain has suffered under the weight of feeling responsible for what happened. The pain this causes him shows that emotional trauma can do as much damage as the physical trauma brought by the curse. Nyfain’s suffering also shows how unresolved emotional trauma affects all those around him. Hadriel and the other shifters within the castle are afraid of Nyfain, but this fear is also backed by years of serving him as their superior. Thus, the effect of emotional suffering comes through in Finley’s response to Nyfain’s attitude and behavior. While Finley recognizes there is trauma informing Nyfain’s actions, she cannot understand the full effect of the trauma because Nyfain refuses to explain his past. As a result, Finley only grows annoyed that he seems to desire her aid but will not trust her with the truth to help him. Finley’s decision to leave the castle is partly motivated by Nyfain’s attitude, matching Belle’s motivation in the movie. However, Finley also leaves because she does not trust herself to maintain healthy boundaries around someone she is beginning to care for but who obviously is not willing to let her in.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 47 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs