A Storm of Swords

How does Martin’s vision of a dishonorable world conflict with the high fantasy ideals that he is writing against?

The wildlings and the Brotherhood Without Banners claim to have higher morals than the legal systems that consider them outlaws. Where do their principles fall short? What is the difference between morality and legality?

Does the War of the Five Kings have a victor? Consider the impact on Westeros. How has war changed the continent?

Discuss Martin’s decision to make Jaime, one of the first novel’s antagonists, a point-of-view protagonist. How does the choice redefine Jaime’s identity and perspective? What does it say about the idea of protagonists and antagonists in fantasy literature?

How does the relative powerlessness of Sansa Stark, Catelyn Stark, Bran Stark, and Tyrion Lannister affect their narratives? How does it comment on the social structures of their world?

Songs like “The Rains of Castamere” and “The Dornishman’s Wife” play a prominent role throughout the novel, reflecting key character motivations and influencing the collective imagination. What does this suggest about the role that culture plays in shaping society?

Are all instances of Jon Snow’s breaking his Night’s Watch vows during his time among the wildlings morally the same? What does this say about adherence to an oath?

Arya’s relationship with Sandor Clegane teaches her a more complex view of human behavior. Who else on her list of those deserving death would she reconsider if she spent time with them?