48 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child abuse, bullying, ableism, and mental illness.
Sera, a witch who was born with much greater talent and power than most witches have, is the novel’s dynamic protagonist. When Sera was a young girl, her parents tired of caring for her and for the inn they had purchased, so they left to pursue adventure. Sera’s aunt Jasmine took over as her guardian and ran the Batty Hole Inn. When Sera reached school age, the British Guild of Sorcery made a cursory offer to educate her at their estate, but because Sera’s mother is from Iceland and her father is from India, her magical “pedigree” was frowned upon. Only when she cast a spell on the Batty Hole Inn, hiding it from everyone except those who are kind and in need of something that it can provide, did the Guild finally pay attention to her. Ultimately, the Chancellor and Albert Grey (the only witch whose magical ability matches Sera’s) insisted that she live at the estate and train as Albert’s apprentice. However, Albert was always more interested in undermining Sera than in maximizing her abilities, as he was reluctant to share the spotlight with her.
When Jasmine dies, a 15-year-old Sera casts a resurrection spell to bring her aunt back to life, but Sera loses almost all her magic in the process. By the time she is 30, Sera has only a little magic left, and she mainly uses it to keep Matilda’s vegetable garden growing and the inn standing. She has also battled depression because when she lost most of her magic, she also lost her sense of identity.
Now, Sera feels that her fully magical self was more valuable and useful than her current self, and she doesn’t believe that she is worthy of love. She often refers to herself as the “gargoyle” of the Batty Hole, and she is hard on herself even though she treats others with love and compassion. However, she begins to change when Luke and his sister, Posy, arrive. Luke shows kindness when a ghostly, magical manifestation of Sera’s past self appears. His unconditional acceptance of who she was and who she has become helps Sera view her past selves with empathy rather than judgment. She also begins to value the contributions that the past versions of herself made to her current life, acknowledging that those old selves had to perish and be reborn in order for her to have the life that she now loves so deeply. In the end, she willingly sacrifices her magical power to protect her loved ones from the vengeful Albert, recognizing that love itself is a kind of magic that is even more valuable than the magic she once wielded as a witch.
Luke is Sera’s love interest, but he is also a dynamic character. He is the primary caregiver of his nine-year-old sister, Posy, who has autism, and he also exhibits many qualities that are often associated with autism, such as intense sensory sensitivities and discomfort with crowded spaces. As one of Verity Walter’s apprentices, he was ridiculed by his peers, who called him the “Tin Man” (from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz) in order to suggest that he has no “heart.” In truth, Luke has learned to protect himself by making himself “smaller” to fit in with his family and his peers. He also thinks of himself as an unwelcome burden. As a result, he pushes people away and abandons friendly spaces before people can tire of him or reject him, and this protective habit sabotages his chances of forming meaningful relationships. When he first saw Posy receiving the same mistreatment that he once experienced, he relocated her to the Guild’s estate in the hopes that she would be more accepted there, but she was rejected once again—this time for failing to follow the Guild’s rules.
When Luke and Posy arrive at Batty Hole Inn, indirectly sent there by Verity, Posy immediately develops a sense of belonging, but Luke doesn’t think he fits. Like Sera, Luke treats others with compassion but has little for himself. Until his friends make him aware of his own habits, he doesn’t realize that he always anticipates becoming unwelcome and leaves before others can abandon him. Like Sera, Luke eventually develops a more accurate view of himself when he learns to value himself as others do.
Albert is the novel’s static antagonist. Until Sera is born, Albert is the most powerful witch in England; he hates the fact that her magic rivals his. He is one of 12 ministers comprising the British Guild of Sorcery, and he has a magical contract that gives him the power of veto on any decision, no matter how many other Guild members support it. When the young Sera became his apprentice, she hoped that he would be a nurturing father figure, but he never fulfilled this role for her or for his own daughter, Francesca. (In fact, even when Francesca becomes the Chancellor of the Guild, she bitterly declares herself to be her father’s “puppet.”)
Cruel and selfish, Albert prioritizes power over everything else. By insisting on rewarding only the witch children from families with rich, magical pedigrees, Albert initiates a reign of terror that spreads the poison of xenophobia and prejudice throughout the world of the novel. Rather than training the young Sera to wield her power to do good or to help others, he regularly challenged her to duels so that he could overpower her and make her feel small. Then, when she uses the resurrection spell to bring her aunt back to life, Albert gleefully exiles her from the witches’ community and makes her a pariah—someone whom other witches are forbidden from aiding.
Albert’s merciless and volatile nature is symbolized by the form his magic takes: a lightning bolt. Just as lightning is powerful, destructive, and unfeeling, so is Albert. He lords his power over anyone and everyone, publicly humiliating those less powerful than himself and manipulating the Guild to do his bidding. Once Sera completes the restoration spell and regains her substantial power, she breaks his magical contract with the Guild, and they oust him from his position. When Albert later confronts Sera at the inn, she realizes that he will persecute and punish the people she loves rather than battling her fairly. She therefore tricks him into a duel and steals his power, sacrificing her own magic in the process. He never suspects that she would be willing to use such a mutually harmful spell because he himself would never sacrifice his own power to protect other people.
Clemmie spends most of the novel in the form of a fox. Her predicament is the result of a curse that she tried to put on Albert Grey that backfired. She initially seeks Sera out because before Sera lost her magic, she was the only witch who might be able to reverse the spell. However, when Sera resurrects Jasmine and loses almost all her power, she can no longer help Clemmie. Even so, Clemmie stays on at the Batty Hole, inadvertently growing to love the people there, though it irks her to realize this. She comes from a famous and powerful witch family, the Bennets, but when she attacked the illustrious Albert, they all but disowned her, erasing her from the family tree. For most of her 15 years with Sera and Jasmine, Clemmie is characterized by her selfishness and her single-minded focus on regaining her human form. On the night of the masquerade, Albert claims to be able to restore her, so at his urging, she betrays Sera and Luke and tells Albert that they are stealing the essence of sunlight for Sera’s restoration spell.
Despite her flaws, Clemmie’s dynamism is highlighted when she follows Albert to the Batty Hole Inn after he is ousted from the Guild. Now human, she tackles him and punches him in the face when he threatens Luke, and she professes her love for the inn’s inhabitants. Even when she is elected to be the new Chancellor of the Guild, she continues to return to the inn for routine visits, enjoying The Value of Found Family, and she ultimately learns to value their love and acceptance more than her own power.



Unlock analysis of every major character
Get a detailed breakdown of each character’s role, motivations, and development.