All the Dangerous Things

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of mental illness, death, and emotional abuse.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. What aspects of Willingham’s unreliable narrator technique did you find most effective in All the Dangerous Things? When did you find yourself questioning Isabelle’s perception of events throughout the novel?

2. Willingham weaves together three timelines in this novel. In what ways did the structure enhance or challenge your reading experience? How does this approach compare to other psychological thrillers like Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl, which also employs multiple perspectives and timelines?

3. The book opens with Isabelle giving a keynote speech at TrueCrimeCon to keep Mason’s case active. What did you think about the portrayal of the true crime community in the novel?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Isabelle experiences devastating insomnia after Mason’s disappearance. Have you ever gone through periods of significant sleeplessness? How did it impact your daily life as compared to Isabelle’s experience?

2. The novel explores the darker side of motherhood through Isabelle’s conflicted feelings about Mason as an infant and her mother’s postpartum psychosis. Were there aspects of these maternal struggles that resonated with your own experiences or observations of others?

3. Truth and storytelling are central themes in the novel, with characters creating narratives to help them cope with trauma. Think about a time when you’ve reframed a difficult experience for yourself or others.

4. Isabelle finds herself isolated in her grief and determination to find Mason, while Ben finds himself able to move on. Have you ever felt alone in your grieving process while others around you appeared to heal faster? What strategies did you develop to navigate that disconnect?

5. When Isabelle discovers the parallels between her intrusive thoughts during Mason’s infancy and her mother’s postpartum psychosis, she begins to forgive both herself and her mother. Can you recall a situation where understanding someone else’s struggle helped you extend compassion to yourself?

6. The novel portrays several toxic relationships built on manipulation and control. What warning signs of manipulation does Willingham highlight that might be relevant to real-life relationships?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. What ethical questions does Willingham raise about the true crime community through Isabelle’s reluctant engagement with them? Where should we draw the line between raising awareness about missing persons and exploiting victims’ stories for entertainment?

2. Isabelle’s father conceals her mother’s postpartum psychosis partly to protect his political career. How has society’s approach to maternal mental health changed since the time of Isabelle’s childhood, and what improvements still need to be made?

3. The Rhett family’s historical home serves as a metaphor for appearances versus reality. In what ways does our society similarly maintain pleasant exteriors while concealing troubling truths?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. What significance does the marsh hold throughout the novel as both a physical setting and a symbolic element? How does Willingham use this landscape to reflect the characters’ emotional states?

2. Isabelle’s clue wall represents her obsession with finding Mason while also, ironically, revealing her blind spots. What does this physical manifestation of her investigation tell us about her character?

3. How does Willingham use the motifs of sleep and sleeplessness to develop the novel’s themes? What do Isabelle’s insomnia and sleepwalking reveal about her psychological state?

4. The physical resemblance between the women in Ben’s life creates a disturbing pattern that Isabelle eventually recognizes. What commentary does this provide about Ben’s character, and how does it contribute to the novel’s exploration of identity?

5. Isabelle’s misplaced guilt about both Margaret and Mason drives much of the narrative. What does this aspect of her character reveal about the lasting impact of childhood trauma, and how does it shape her actions throughout the story?

6. Willingham’s use of multiple flashbacks gradually reveals the truth about both Margaret’s death and Mason’s disappearance. How effective was this technique in building suspense? What does it suggest about memory and how we process traumatic events?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine a conversation between Isabelle and her mother 10 years after the events of the novel. What healing might have occurred between them, and what unresolved issues might still exist?

2. The Epilogue shows Isabelle reunited with Mason but provides limited details about his time with Abigail Fisher. Write a description of how Mason might process these events as he grows older.

3. If you were to write a sequel to All the Dangerous Things, what would be your focus? Would you explore Isabelle and Mason rebuilding their relationship, Waylon’s journey after helping solve both cases, or perhaps the consequences of Ben’s imprisonment?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources