On Sunday, October 18, Hank can’t stop thinking about Aubrey’s presence at the Rosary and her connection to Camille. He calls Camille to check on her, and he tells her about the police searching Aubrey’s house. Camille gasps upon hearing Aubrey’s name, and Hank tells her that she must be honest with him. She asks him to pick her up in Corbeau so they can talk, and he agrees to meet her after lunch.

Hank goes to Angola to talk to Paul. Angola hosts a yearly rodeo in which the inmates can compete and host booths to sell their crafts. Hank finds Paul selling his leatherwares and asks him about his relationship with Foster and Aubrey. Paul admits that Foster was the man who told him about the evidence, and Hank informs Paul that Foster died. Hank asks Paul about the jewelry box and the typed letter, and Paul says he never sent that to Aubrey, as they can only mail things that fit in envelopes. Paul did give a jewelry box to Foster when he visited, so Foster must’ve sent the box and the letter to Aubrey.

Paul asks if the evidence was in the box, but Hank found it empty. Paul tells Hank that the box has a secret compartment in the bottom, and Hank promises to check it out.

Aubrey wakes up in Deacon’s arms for the second day in a row. They have grilled cheeses and coffee before they start cleaning Aubrey’s room after the police made a mess of it. Deacon goes out to get them food, and Hank calls Aubrey and tells her that Frank sent the jewelry box and about the jewelry box’s secret compartment.

Serenity’s boyfriend Frank watches as Aubrey discovers the USB drive hidden in the box. Aubrey asks Frank to borrow his laptop to see what’s on the drive, and Frank agrees. He gets his laptop and Aubrey hands him the USB, but the laptop is a Mac and requires a converter to read the USB. He goes to his truck to get the converter.

Deacon comes back, and Aubrey fills him in. He offers his laptop to Aubrey, but she says Frank is getting his converter. Deacon tells her that he passed Frank driving away on the road, and Aubrey sees that Frank’s truck is missing, meaning he’s left with the USB drive.

Camille slips back into her old family life, attending church with her family and the family lunch afterward. Camille tells her parents she’s meeting Hank later for dinner, and Randall throws Ben’s death in her face by telling her it would be a bad look for her to be seen at dinner a week after her husband’s death. Camille stands her ground, and her mother Marie offers to give her some food to give Hank. Camille privately decides to stay at a hotel, never come home again, and to tell Hank the whole truth.

After lunch, Silas asks Camille to talk privately in the shop across the driveway. Silas tells her that he has the USB drive with the evidence, as Frank is the man Silas hired to look after Aubrey. Frank steps outside while Silas and Camille open the drive and locate the video among the evidence. They watch it and see the cars crash, and Margaret climbs out of the driver’s seat of Paul’s truck. Silas realizes he didn’t remember anything from the accident before climbing through Ben’s window, and he assumed that he was the one driving, and Margaret let him believe it.

Silas opens a letter on the drive from Foster about Paul’s case that states that Foster found the video footage after Randall had already framed Paul and believed Silas was driving, so Foster didn’t interfere. Camille tells Silas she plans to tell Hank the truth, and Silas plans to handle Margaret himself.

Camille takes a moment before walking back through the shop. Margaret intercepts her after hiding behind some shelves. Margaret knows that she and Silas saw the video after she saw Frank lurking. Camille feels intense anger looking at Margaret, as all the tragedies of the past decade trace back to her bad decision. Margaret attacks Camille, shouting that Camille doesn’t get to return after years and pretend to care about Silas. Camille tries to defend herself, but Margaret knocks her out with something from the shelf.

Hank arrives early to pick up Camille after Aubrey told him about Frank stealing the drive. Hank isn’t sure who Frank works for, but he knows he’s a plant.

Hank parks near the shop, and the wind blows the shop door open. Hank sees Camille on the floor with blood pouring from her head. He sprints over to her and checks her pulse. She’s alive. Silas enters to find the scene. He gathers towels for Hank to use to staunch Camille’s bleeding. Frank appears, and Hank recognizes him as Serenity’s boyfriend. Frank calls ahead to a doctor in Baton Rouge as Silas and Hank put Camille in a car.

Hank paces and Silas sits still as they wait for news on Camille’s condition. The doctor tells them that Camille is okay but badly concussed, so they’ll keep her for 24-hour observation. Silas and Hank see her in her hospital room, and Camille tells them that Margaret hit her. Silas leaves to deal with Margaret, and Camille tells Hank the full truth.

Silas returns after a few hours, claiming that Margaret’s disappeared. Hank offers to take Camille home to stay with him and promises to visit Silas to review a few things the next day. Hank opens his phone to review the list of names of people who were at Paul’s house that fateful night, and one name sticks out.

The narrative jumps back to 10 years prior. All of Corbeau talks about the dead couple and their orphaned child. Ben visits the police station with his mother to give his statement corroborating Silas’s alibi. Foster has his nephew with him to shadow him, and he introduces himself as Nathan Sullivan, or Sully.

On Monday, October 19, Aubrey tries to return to “normal” at home alone, as the rest of her housemates have work. Sully shows up and claims to have more questions about the case.

Aubrey thinks it feels strange, and Sully’s questioning turns violent as he pressures Aubrey to tell him what she knows. He reveals that Margaret was the one who killed her parents, and Aubrey realizes that Sully killed Ben because Ben wouldn’t stop searching for the evidence, and he planted the knife in her house. Sully strangles her until Deacon arrives and fights him off. Sully’s gun discharges, shooting and killing Sully. Deacon tells Aubrey that Frank and Silas are on their way, and they were the ones who warned Deacon about Sully.

Frank and Silas arrive, and Deacon doesn’t attack Frank because he helped save Aubrey. Silas explains everything: Once Hank saw Sully’s name on the list of people from Paul’s party, he realized that Sully helped Foster do all of Randall’s dirty work, and Foster’s desire to confess threatened Sully’s reputation and career. Ben’s desire for the evidence stemmed from his attempts to free himself from Randall’s influence, and Sully killed him to keep everything quiet.

Shane and Eddie show up and almost attack Frank before the group tell them what happened. Aubrey thinks she can’t call the police and doesn’t want to risk Deacon going to jail for killing Sully. Silas calls a police officer loyal to him and assures Aubrey that she can protect Deacon if they spin a story that Sully was the one driving Paul’s truck that night, that he killed Ben, and then tried to kill Aubrey to cover his tracks. Hank will corroborate to protect Ben’s reputation and the firm’s reputation, as it looks better for Bayliss and Landry if Ben died trying to uncover a crooked cop. Aubrey will have to tell the police that Foster told her the driver was Sully. Aubrey agrees to protect Deacon.

Silas visits Camille and Hank at Hank’s house. He tells them about what happened at Aubrey’s and about their plan to frame Sully for driving Paul’s truck. Hank can represent Deacon and prevent him from imprisonment and close the case, making Ben look like a good man in search of justice. Silas will take over the Everett business and try to straighten everything up.

Camille asks Hank for a moment alone with Silas. She tells Silas she wants to buy Aubrey’s rental house and gift it to Aubrey. Silas wants to pay for the repairs to fix up the house, as they both feel guilty for their roles in harming Aubrey.

Camille asks Silas what he plans to do about Margaret, who’s still missing, and Silas tells her that she doesn’t want to know. Silas feels endless regret, and Camille realizes he’s become the man their father molded him into.

On Thursday, October 22, Silas visits Doug’s Tavern while Aubrey’s working. She’s so shocked to see him that she drops a bottle of vodka. Doug cleans up while Aubrey tends to Silas. Deacon sits nearby, and Silas drinks a beer as he cryptically discusses how Margaret has been struggling with something from 10 years ago and has been drinking. He receives a phone call from the Corbeau Police and tells Aubrey that Margaret has been in a fatal car accident. He then leaves.

Aubrey realizes that Silas meted out justice himself, and Aubrey isn’t sure that Margaret’s death is justice for her parents. Aubrey and Silas remain linked, as if anyone questions where Silas was when his wife died, he can point them to Doug’s Tavern, and Aubrey and Deacon.