Blood Moon

John wakes Beth up. John feels sappy but reminds himself that a relationship will not work with Beth because she lives a thousand miles away. The epiphany of his feelings for Beth leaves him feeling depressed. John asks Beth if she’s going back to New York, but she tells him that she’s staying until they’ve solved the mystery. John tells her about his conversation with Dr. Wallace the previous night and the numerology. John also shares his theory that the perpetrators—plural—share a trait rather than the victims. John suggests that there may be a club on the dark web where the perpetrators are members.

Beth considers his theory. John wonders if the killers committed abductions and murders as an initiation so that the other members of the chat room would trust them. John calls the other detectives on the case while Beth calls New York.

Barker answers his phone, and Gray tells him that there is no sign of Beth or John and that Mitch slipped the person tailing him. Barker tells Gray to call Mitch again and threaten him, but Gray says that Mitch doesn’t answer and that his office has asked him to stop calling.