Brain On Fire

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of illness or death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Cahalan structures her memoir as a detective story, piecing together a month she can’t remember through medical records, interviews, and video footage. What impact did this approach have on your reading experience? Did it make her story more compelling or more challenging to follow?

2. What elements of Cahalan’s transformation from journalist to patient to advocate did you find most powerful? Which moments in her journey resonated with you most deeply?

3. Brain on Fire joins other medical memoirs that explore mysterious neurological conditions. How does it compare to books like Oliver Sacks’s The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat or Calahan’s later work, The Great Pretender? What makes her perspective unique?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Have you ever experienced a moment that felt like a dividing line between your “before” and “after” selves? How did you navigate that transition?

2. Cahalan’s family and boyfriend Stephen remained devoted despite her often hostile behavior during her illness. What inner resources would you draw upon to support someone through a similar situation?

3. The lucky ring serves as a symbol connecting Cahalan to her former self. What objects in your life act as touchstones for important parts of your identity?

4. When have you found yourself avoiding difficult truths about your health or well-being, similar to Cahalan’s initial denial of her symptoms?

5. Music helps Cahalan reconnect with her pre-illness identity during recovery, especially when she spontaneously sings “California Dreamin’” with Stephen. What songs have been meaningful anchors during difficult periods in your life?

6. Cahalan notes that she wouldn’t take back her illness experience if given the chance. Which challenging experiences in your life have led to valuable insights or personal growth despite their difficulty?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. Cahalan’s story reveals serious flaws in the medical system, particularly regarding the diagnosis of “invisible” or complex conditions. What systemic issues does her experience highlight? Have you witnessed similar problems in healthcare settings?

2. People often treated Cahalan condescendingly after her illness, as seen in the shoe store and salon incidents. What social attitudes contribute to this behavior toward those with visible disabilities or differences?

3. The memoir contrasts medical professionals who champion patients (like Dr. Najjar) with those who dismiss them (like early doctors). To what extent do you think contemporary medical education addresses the human aspects of patient care?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The collage-like structure of this memoir incorporates medical reports, journal entries, and video transcriptions. In what ways does this fragmented approach mirror Cahalan’s own fractured experience and memory?

2. Writing serves as a form of memory preservation throughout the text, with Cahalan, her father, and her mother all keeping journals. What different purposes does this writing serve for each character?

3. The reliability of memory becomes both a central theme and a structural element in Cahalan’s narrative. What effect does this create for you as a reader trying to understand her experience?

4. Cahalan applies her journalistic skills to investigating her own medical mystery. Where do you see evidence of her professional background in how she constructs her story?

5. Beyond the lucky ring, what other symbols or motifs in the memoir mark important transitions or revelations in Cahalan’s journey?

6. Why might Cahalan have chosen to include Dr. Najjar’s personal story of overcoming adversity within her memoir? How does his background enhance the themes of her narrative?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Write a journal entry from the perspective of Stephen, Cahalan’s boyfriend, during her hospitalization. What would your entry focus on and what emotions might you express or suppress?

2. If you were adapting Brain on Fire as a documentary rather than the Netflix drama that was produced, which aspects of Cahalan’s experience would you emphasize? What techniques would you use to portray her “lost month”?

3. Cahalan’s article about her illness helped other patients receive correct diagnoses. Design a public awareness campaign for autoimmune encephalitis. What information would you prioritize and how would you reach both medical professionals and the public?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources