Broken Country

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death and child death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. How did the setting, both time and place, affect your reading experience? What elements of the setting did you find most powerful in establishing the emotional landscape of the novel?

2. Which relationship in Broken Country affected you most profoundly, and what specific interactions made it compelling?

3. How does Broken Country compare to Thomas Hardy’s works like Tess of the d’Urbervilles, which similarly explore rural tragedies and the unforgiving grip of fate? What unique perspective does Hall contribute to this tradition?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Beth finds unexpected fulfillment in farm life despite initially aspiring to an academic career. Have you ever discovered satisfaction in a life path that you hadn’t originally envisioned for yourself?

2. Frank processes grief through silence and physical labor, while Beth needs to share stories about Bobby. Which character’s approach to loss resonates more with your own experiences?

3. The oak tree represents both life-affirming permanence and devastating loss throughout the novel. Do you have any objects or places in your life that hold contradictory meanings?

4. Have you ever reconnected with someone from your past and found yourself slipping back into old patterns or roles, similar to Beth and Gabriel’s reunion?

5. Frank takes responsibility for Jimmy’s death as an extraordinary act of protection and atonement. Have you ever experienced or witnessed such profound sacrifice? What motivates it, in your experience?

6. In what ways have you observed secrets functioning in family or community dynamics?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. Broken Country takes place in rural England during the 1950s and 1960s. How do this time and place raise cultural and social issues that might feel foreign to contemporary readers? Are there any aspects that struck you as still relevant in today’s society?

2. Beth’s educational opportunities and life choices reflect the limitations that many women faced during this era. In what ways would her story unfold differently if it were set in contemporary times?

3. The village of Hemston transforms Beth and Gabriel’s private affair into a public spectacle through gossip and judgment. What does this reveal about community dynamics during this historical period? How does this representation still feel relevant today?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. What effect does the dual-timeline structure create for readers experiencing the story?

2. Animals appear throughout the novel as both literal characters and symbolic figures. What purpose do they serve in developing the book’s themes?

3. Discuss the character development of Beth, who transforms from a romantic 16-year-old into a resilient woman who endures multiple tragedies. Which moments mark her most significant development? How does her character arc contribute to the themes of the novel?

4. Secrets shape every major relationship in the novel, from Bobby’s paternity to Jimmy’s death. How do these deceptions contribute to the story’s moral complexity?

5. The lake at Meadowlands serves as a recurring setting for pivotal moments between Beth and Gabriel. What does this location represent symbolically?

6. Does the novel’s conclusion with Frank’s return offer genuine hope for healing or merely suggest the possibility of living meaningfully despite permanent wounds?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine writing an additional chapter that is set five years after the novel’s conclusion. What would life be like for Beth, Frank, and Grace at Blakely Farm?

2. Choose a character from the novel and write a letter to Bobby from them. Who would your letter be from, and what would it contain?

3. Choose a pivotal scene from the novel that affected you deeply. What artistic medium would best capture this scene? What elements would you emphasize in your adaptation?

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.