By a Thread

Lucy Score

54 pages 1-hour read

Lucy Score

By a Thread

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Important Quotes

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes cursing, sexual content, and references to sexual harassment.


“The woman straightened away from the table closest to the door, stuffing the cash tip into her flour-sprinkled apron. Her eyes locked on mine, and I felt something…interesting. Like the ghost of recognition. Like she was the one I was here to meet. But we were strangers.”


(Chapter 1, Page 3)

Dominic Russo’s immediate response to Ally Morales foreshadows their romantic relationship. This is the meet-cute of Score’s romantic comedy—recapitulating the trope where the primary love interests encounter each other in a surprising coincidence. Ally’s body language and appearance make Dominic feel something “interesting” but unnamable toward her. He tries to dismiss the feeling because they’re “strangers” at this juncture of the novel, but the sense of familiarity that passes between them portends their heated dynamic in coming chapters.

“Let’s just say life had been a shit show lately. And messing with a grumpy guy […] who looked like he’d waltzed right off the pages of some men’s magazine was definitely a highlight. Which said a lot about my current situation. I didn’t have time to worry about the consequences of being stretched too thin. This was the kind of life crisis that you muscled through.”


(Chapter 2, Page 10)

Ally’s internal monologue during her serving shift introduces the novel’s theme of Balancing Personal and Professional Responsibilities. Her energizing heated exchange with Dominic—the “grumpy guy”—represents her desire, while her reference to being “stretched too thin” represents her professional stressors. She is trying to navigate the complexities of maintaining her job amidst the “shit show” of her life—a conflict that becomes the driving force of her storyline.

“Another day, another terrified employee. I’d assumed they’d all get used to me. Apparently I’d assumed incorrectly. I was the beast to my mother’s beauty. The monster to the heroine. When they looked at me, they saw my father.”


(Chapter 4, Page 24)

Dominic’s fraught relationship with his father complicates how he sees himself. He likens himself to a “beast” and a “monster” because he is terrified of repeating his father’s sexual misdeeds. Dominic’s internal monologue captures his inability to be himself in the workplace while trying to maintain a professional reputation and to atone for his father’s sins. These dynamics become the central conflicts of Dominic’s storyline.

“So much damage could have been avoided. But the past is in the past. It has no bearing on the present and future. I brought my son on to take his father’s place and tasked him—perhaps unfairly—with cleaning up his father’s mess. As you saw last week, the strain is getting to him.”


(Chapter 6, Page 44)

Dalessandra Russo’s reflections on the state of her company foreshadow the workplace conflicts the characters will have to confront over the course of the novel. Dalessandra wants to believe that the past “has no bearing on the present and future” because she’s just as afraid as Dominic is of confronting what her husband did to their employees. Her avoidance keeps Label from righting its wrongs.

“I wasn’t interested. Not in that way. I didn’t sleep with people who pissed me off and pushed my buttons. I was, however, curious about her.”


(Chapter 12, Page 81)

Dominic is caught between his attraction to Ally and his frustration with her. His internal conflict reinforces the protagonists’ enemies-to-lovers dynamic. Ally “pisses him off” and “pushes his buttons”—qualities Dominic tells himself are repellant rather than endearing. However, he also feels “curious about her”—an admission which foreshadows how their relationship will develop.

“My weekend had been a mess. I squeezed in hospital visits between bar shifts, dance classes, and a sorry-for-flaking-on-you last-minute catering gig my boss had offered up. I hadn’t so much as lifted a broom or watched a ‘How to Hang Drywall Yourself’ YouTube tutorial. I was so far behind on my plan that it made me want to hyperventilate into a paper bag just thinking about it.”


(Chapter 16, Page 108)

Ally’s exhausting schedule illustrates the challenges of Balancing Personal and Professional Responsibilities. Ally is only one person, but her familial and economic circumstances force her to divide her time between “hospital visits,” “bar shifts,” and “dance classes,” leaving no time for self-care. Her taxing schedule captures the difficulties of maintaining personal stability while trying to pursue one’s dreams and find happiness.

“The pay from the studio wasn’t great, but I loved dance enough that I allowed myself two classes a week instead of taking better paying shifts. I loved moving and sweating and feeling the music in my bones. It felt like a celebration of being alive. The kinds of classes I taught were less about technique and more about moving in ways that made you feel strong and sexy.”


(Chapter 19, Page 129)

Dance offers Ally a retreat from reality. Ally spends most of her time working or caring for her dad. Dance is the only reprieve she has from these financial and familial duties. The pastime is symbolic of escape and self-expression, as it allows Ally to celebrate “being alive” and to “feel strong and sexy” in ways her other occupations don’t.

“You’re damn right nothing is going to happen, you cocky, imbecilic ass. You think I’m so desperate that I’d say yes to a quick hate fuck? That my self-respect is so low I’d throw myself at someone who doesn’t deserve me?”


(Chapter 21, Page 146)

Ally’s use of cutting language and expletives affects a volatile mood and combative tone. Ally is refusing to let Dominic control her. She is confronting him for being arrogant and self-involved, while simultaneously standing up for herself. Her dialogue thus conveys her self-possession, while heightening the heat between her and Dominic.

“I wanted to be offended by the idea that getting to know me would be a major turnoff to him. However, I was damn certain the more I knew about Dominic Russo, the less my lady parts would lust after him. What could possibly go wrong?”


(Chapter 23, Page 163)

Ally deludes herself into believing that the feelings she and Dominic have for each other will go away. She wants to temper her “lust” and believes that “getting to know” each other might puncture their mutual curiosity. The ending question foreshadows coming conflicts between the protagonists—it implies that the more they get to know each other the more they’ll want to be together. The passage thus contributes to the novel’s theme of Communication and Vulnerability in Relationships: Once Ally and Dominic start sharing vulnerable facets of their lives, they grow closer.

“I wanted to say that things changed after our talk and emails. That with the air cleared and her moving back downstairs to the admin pool, I was finally free to concentrate on work. And in a way, things had changed. I’d shown her my cards. Admitted my sins. Confessed my fears. But none of that stopped me from seeking her out. It didn’t stop me from thinking about her. And it sure as fuck didn’t stop me from wanting her.”


(Chapter 25, Page 170)

Dominic’s internal monologue underscores his internal conflict. Dominic wants to believe that talking and emailing with Ally has tempered his sexual desire for and romantic interest in her. However, he knows that these forms of communication have only increased his attraction to Ally. The passage shows Dominic’s struggle to reconcile his desires with his sense of responsibility and decorum.

“There was officially no way in hell that I was going to (a) throw myself at any man too dumb or stubborn to enjoy it or (b) become some sexual harassing subordinate. I needed this job. I needed this paycheck. I did not need my boss lusting after me and then making me feel like a fool. I was going to buckle down, earn my paycheck, and dig my way out of the massive debt I’d managed to accumulate.”


(Chapter 30, Page 208)

Ally speaks directly to herself to refocus on her personal and professional responsibilities. She is coaching herself to stave off her sexual desire to maintain her job and achieve her goals. She tells herself “to buckle down”—an idiom that evokes notions of control and restraint. At this juncture of the novel, Ally thinks that if she denies herself what she wants, she can maintain a more respectable lifestyle. She is still immersed in the complexities of Balancing Personal and Professional Responsibilities.

“You’re fighting this mutual attraction really hard without giving me a real reason. And if you can’t trust me with your why, then I can’t trust you with mine.”


(Chapter 35, Page 247)

Ally believes in the importance of Communication and Vulnerability in Relationships. She wants to be open, honest, and authentic with Dominic. However, she doesn’t want to share her story with him if he isn’t going to do the same with her. Ally is thus reminding Dominic that trust, communication, and reciprocity are key to creating healthy relationships.

“Sometimes good things happened to pretty okay people. My father was safe for another month. And with a raise, maybe I could take a few weeknights and weekends off to fix up the house. My eyes were swimming in unshed tears. This anonymous executive had just saved everything that was important to me in this life. I was going to do this. I was going to make it through.”


(Chapter 36, Page 255)

Ally’s positive tone affects a hopeful narrative mood as her outlook on life changes. After getting the PA job and paying her late fees at the nursing home, she feels in control and fulfilled as her responsibilities seem within reach. She uses the imperative mood in the final lines, telling herself that she will accomplish her goals and will get through her troubles—a rhetorical device that reiterates her determination.

“And it wasn’t just the clothes. Or the sleek, smoky eyes. Or the bold lips and sex-tousled hair. I was remembering who I was underneath it all. Beneath the stress and the broken fingernails, the cheap clothes, and the just starting to catch up on sleep again. I was Ally Morales, and I had a value that went way deeper than what one man accepted or rejected.”


(Chapter 39, Page 271)

Looking at herself in the mirror helps Ally to see how she’s emotionally grown. She is literally observing her new “clothes,” her “sleek, smoky eyes,” her “bold lips,” and “sex-tousled hair,” but more figuratively, what she sees is a strong, empowered woman. Her external makeover is evidence of her internal transformation. She is seizing control of her narrative and claiming autonomy over her body and identity.

“You’re nothing like your father. You never have been, and you never will be. You’re a good man. You take care of people who need it. You protect them and build them up. You’re going to make some woman very lucky someday.”


(Chapter 44, Page 308)

Ally’s encouraging, insistent tone conveys her growing care for Dominic. She uses anaphora, repeatedly starting each line with “you” or you’re”—a formal choice that affects a declarative tone. She wants Dominic to see in himself what she sees in him. He has just opened up to her, and she’s receiving his vulnerability with care and sensitivity, reiterating the importance of Communication and Vulnerability in Relationships.

“I missed my old life. Missed the comfort of believing my father was happy and healthy. Missed being able to breathe, to be selfish. I missed being able to go out for drinks on a Wednesday or take a friend out to dinner. I missed cooking for a cute date who I was excited about. God, I missed sex. I missed not having to know my checking account balance down to the penny.”


(Chapter 47, Page 330)

Ally’s private reverie conveys the challenge of Overcoming Past Demons. In the present, Ally tries to maintain a cool, collected exterior. In this internal monologue, however, she allows herself to meditate on her own longing. Her mind is drifting into memory and thus reflecting on everything she left behind in Colorado. The passage creates a nostalgic, vulnerable mood and shows Ally’s heart.

“Her laugh untied knots in my chest that I didn’t know I had. And I knew I wasn’t going back to before. Before tonight. Before I saw the bruises on her face. Before I knew what Ally felt like from the inside out. Before she could laugh naked under me. I wasn’t physically capable of it.”


(Chapter 51, Page 367)

Having sex for the first time transforms Ally and Dominic’s combative dynamic into a loving one. Their sexual encounter particularly “unties knots” inside Dominic’s “chest”—a metaphor that conveys how physical intimacy can soften emotional roadblocks. The experience is already changing his outlook on life, himself, and their relationship.

“I was busy scanning my document for the pertinent information. Graphics. I was being transferred to the graphics department. I was going to work for one of the premier publications in the world as a graphic designer, and I got to keep my hot boyfriend.”


(Chapter 55, Page 401)

Ally’s response to her new Label assignment suggests that Balancing Personal and Professional Responsibilities is possible. Ally is working together with her colleagues so that she can fulfill her duties and “keep her hot boyfriend.” Because she’s embraced honesty and openness, she’s secured a dream job and a healthier dynamic with her new lover.

“I think it was the life that went on inside it. There were kids who lived here who were a few years older than me. They had a mom and a dad and each other. A basketball hoop in the driveway. Lemonade stands in the summer. It just always looked idyllic. Still does.”


(Chapter 58, Page 423)

Ally is showing Dominic her vulnerability when she brings him to the dream house and tells him why she’s always loved it. She is describing the intricacies of her childhood fantasies, and thus letting Dominic see a tender part of her. This moment fosters increased intimacy between the characters as they develop their romantic dynamic. The passage also foreshadows the life that Ally and Dominic will make in this house at the end of the novel.

“After all, we hadn’t talked future. Not really. All easy just trying to survive the next few months. Things would be different when the house was sold. When her father’s situation was secure. When she had choices and the resources to make them. Would she choose me when she didn’t have to rely on me for a roof? For good cheeses and nights out and clothing and not previously owned by half the city? Did I want her, or did I want to be needed?”


(Chapter 59, Page 432)

Dominic’s internal monologue reveals his continued insecurities. He uses a series of questions to show that he doubts the stability of his and Ally’s romance. His personal demons continue to cloud his perception of reality, as his negative experiences with Elena and Paul overshadow his positive relationship with Ally. The anxious, uncertain tone of the passage shows that Dominic still has to process his past before he can establish a future with Ally.

“Thank you. I don’t know if there’s a way to say a big enough, loud enough thank-you. This is everything. And I’m totally mad at you. And a whole lot of other things. I never expected anything like this, Dom.”


(Chapter 62, Page 457)

Ally’s effusive response to the house renovation conveys her appreciation for Dominic’s displays of affection. Ally has grown accustomed to shouldering life’s responsibilities on her own. She’s not used to having people step in and help her—which is why she’s unsure how to thank Dominic “big enough” and “loud enough.” The passage shows Ally’s insecurity, too—she’s historically feared asking for or accepting help from others because she doesn’t know if she can repay them and feels weak if she doesn’t do things on her own.

“You get a nice warm place to stay that doesn’t require you to get up at the ass crack of dawn for a commute. Is that why you were finally willing to introduce me to your father? Were you hoping I’d walk in there and magnanimously decided to pay off his debt?”


(Chapter 66, Page 486)

Dominic’s accusatory harangue destabilizes his and Ally’s relationship and underscores his need to grow and change. Dominic has deceived himself into believing that Ally is using him because he hasn’t yet reconciled with how Elena and Paul used him. Because he’s putting his wounds onto Ally in an unfair way, he pushes her away—a separation that will challenge him to reevaluate himself and transcend his demons.

“Look, the point of a relationship isn’t hiding your stupid wounds and flaws. It’s about showing them to someone and letting them still love you. You were able to hurt her because she let you in.”


(Chapter 69, Page 503)

Harry stresses the importance of Communication and Vulnerability in Relationships to Dominic. Because Harry is Dominic’s best friend, he doesn’t soften the truth. Instead, he directly confronts Dominic for “hiding” his “wounds and flaws” instead of “showing them” and letting Ally love him in spite of them. His honest, loving speech ushers Dominic toward confrontation, remorse, and healing in the subsequent chapters.

“It was a pattern. A consistent one. Dominic recognizing a need and quietly filling it. I was not a lucky person. I didn’t win on scratch-offs. It was more fun for me to set dollars on fire than to put them in slot machines that never paid off. And I sure as hell didn’t win grants that I didn’t know about.”


(Chapter 72, Page 522)

Ally’s moment of reflection helps her to understand the role Dominic has been playing in her life all along. Throughout the novel, she wanted to believe that she could fulfill her responsibilities and overcome her challenges on her own. In this scene, she’s realizing that Dominic is the one who’s helped her stay afloat and that his help isn’t a sign of her weakness but is evidence of his love.

“‘I love you,’ I said. Sometimes the words bubbled up and couldn’t be contained. And Dominic’s face did what it always did when I felt compelled to tell him. It softened as if he too couldn’t believe this was his life. ‘I love hearing you say that,’ he said smugly.”


(
Epilogue
, Page 534)

Ally and Dominic’s intimate exchange in the first epilogue signals their happily-ever-after ending. Score uses diction like “bubbled,” “compelled,” and “softened” to describe her protagonists’ feelings for one another now that they’re together again. This language captures the simultaneous passion and empathy they have for each other. Their mutual professions of love also reiterate how their relationship has evolved from enmity into affection.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock every key quote and its meaning

Get 25 quotes with page numbers and clear analysis to help you reference, write, and discuss with confidence.

  • Cite quotes accurately with exact page numbers
  • Understand what each quote really means
  • Strengthen your analysis in essays or discussions