60 pages • 2-hour read
Dear Reader
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Chapters 9-17Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of sexual content, sexual harassment, physical abuse, emotional abuse, bullying, death by suicide, and death.
Chapter 9 Summary
Later at the party, Ashley steps away from the crowd and overhears Nate, Heath, Carter, and Royce discussing DBS business, including plans for the upcoming initiation at Cat’s Peak and the list of potential recruits. She realizes that Heath allowed the false story about paying her for sex to circulate, reinforcing Nate’s hostility as he declares she will never be considered for the society.
When Ashley accidentally snaps a twig, Royce goes to investigate. He finds her hiding but tells the others that he saw nothing. Once they leave, Royce warns Ashley to forget what she overheard and walks her out of the woods before sending her back toward campus.
Chapter 10 Summary
The next morning, Ashley checks that the hidden diary is still secure. Carly updates her on new campus gossip that claims Ashley was seen making out with Royce. Seeking space, Ashley takes the diary to a nearby café. Heath appears, buys her coffee, and suggests the rumors would stop if she had a boyfriend.
When Heath is distracted, Ashley reads enough to learn that the diarist is Abigail Monstera, a former student who documented DBS activity. When Heath returns unexpectedly, Ashley drops the diary, and he picks it up before she quickly retrieves it. Nate arrives and tells Heath he is needed at an Elders meeting about “the problem,” which Nate pointedly implies is Ashley.
Chapter 11 Summary
On Sunday, Ashley spends the day reading Abigail’s diary. Later, she returns from a shower to find Nate waiting in her room. He insults her, invades her space, and warns her to stay away from his friends. Ashley punches him in the groin and forces him out, only to realize moments later that the diary has been stolen. She calls Nate, who convincingly denies taking it.
Distressed, Ashley searches for information about Abigail Monstera in the library and finds an obituary stating that she drowned, and her death was ruled death by suicide. Believing the DBS may have been involved, she is startled when Heath arrives carrying coffee. On impulse, she suggests they fake date to counter the rumors spreading about her, and he agrees.
Chapter 12 Summary
That evening, Heath walks Ashley to her dorm and kisses her while Jade watches from a window. Alone, Ashley researches other suspicious student deaths mentioned in the diary, including that of Sarah Black at Cat’s Peak.
Later that night, a masked and robed figure, whom Ashley believes to be Nate, breaks into her locked room, restrains her, and takes her to Cat’s Peak for a DBS initiation. She lines up on a narrow ledge with other recruits. Heath is present and argues she should not participate because she is injured. Nate announces that all initiates must jump. After Royce gives a countdown, an unknown figure kicks Ashley from behind. She drops a short distance onto a platform below and realizes the jump is a psychological test rather than a lethal fall.
Chapter 13 Summary
Still shaken, Ashley refuses to join the DBS celebration. Royce drives her to campus to have her injuries cleaned, and Heath, Nate, and Carter join them there. Ashley insists she was pushed and accuses Nate, who firmly denies it. Royce shows her a video of the initiation that proves Nate was standing several feet away during the countdown.
When Ashley replays the footage, she notices a different robed figure step forward and kick her. With no clear explanation, the group decides the Elders will determine whether she is officially inducted. As Heath walks her back to her dorm, he is tense and withdrawn, leaving Ashley confused about his sudden change in demeanor.
Chapter 14 Summary
On Monday, Ashley meets Carly for coffee and realizes from Carly’s reaction and comments that she is also a member of the DBS and had been present at the initiation. Their conversation is interrupted when Heath arrives and publicly plays the role of Ashley’s boyfriend. Later, when Ashley tries to end their fake arrangement, Heath refuses.
Nate appears and summons Heath to another Elders meeting about “the problem” of Ashley’s potential membership. Ashley returns to the library and begins researching Clara Devine, another student death mentioned in Abigail’s diary. That evening, Heath finds her, kisses her, and deflects her questions about what the Elders decided.
Chapter 15 Summary
Over the next week, Heath performs as the devoted boyfriend, and campus rumors about her fade. On Friday, he suggests that they go out to Prosper for dinner, but Carter interrupts them. Carter reveals that he knows their relationship is fake and announces that Ashley will be his date to the Founding Families Gala that night. When Ashley reacts angrily, Carter abruptly pins her by the throat against a tree in a display of control before releasing her and confirming he will collect her at seven.
Heath later explains that members of the DBS must attend the gala with another member for the Society Challenge, and his assigned partner is Jade. That evening, Carter sends a red satin gown, gloves, and heels to Ashley’s dorm for the event.
Chapter 16 Summary
At the gala, Nate confronts Carter and Ashley. Ashley and Nate’s parents, Max and Carina, appear, forcing them to act civilly. Carter explains his strategy: Bringing Ashley is meant to agitate Nate and Heath and give him an advantage in the Society Challenge.
Heath arrives with Jade, who insults Ashley. Royce appears, followed by Nate and his long-term girlfriend, Paige. Nate publicly accuses Ashley of sleeping with Royce, who plays along. Carter pulls Ashley away, telling her that the challenge is starting.
Chapter 17 Summary
As the gala continues, Heath pulls Ashley aside and admits he is jealous that she arrived with Carter. Carly interrupts and leads Ashley upstairs, where she vents about Paige and Jade and pushes Ashley to acknowledge her feelings for Heath.
After Carly leaves with her own partner, Ashley runs into Nate, who hurls more insults at her. Royce appears looking disheveled, and when Nate accuses him of being with Ashley, Royce casually plays along. Carter arrives and pulls Ashley away, saying the Society Challenge is starting.
While searching for a hiding place, they accidentally walk in on Paige partially undressed and realize she has just been with Royce. Carter ushers Ashley out and follows her suggestion to hide in a sauna. Inside, he explains the rules of the challenge: Each team must plant rubber ducks in risky locations and photograph them without being caught. Their planning is cut short when another couple enters the bathroom and turns on the sauna, trapping them inside.
Chapters 9-17 Analysis
The narrative structure of these chapters mirrors Ashley’s psychological disorientation, immersing the reader in a landscape where information is a weapon and objective truth is perpetually out of reach. This design is central to the theme of Navigating a World of Secrets and Lies. Initially, Abigail Monstera’s diary functions as a key to a hidden reality. However, the diary’s theft is a pivotal event, removing this source of clarity and forcing Ashley to rely on fragmented memories and unreliable external sources. The narrative then shifts to a series of controlled disclosures and manipulations, most notably the fake-dating plot with Heath. This arrangement is a microcosm of the larger social environment: a manufactured reality designed to control perception. Carter’s ironic declaration, “I don’t believe in secrets, Spark. They only serve as ammunition for those who want to hurt you” (121), highlights the characters’ sophisticated understanding of narrative control. The fake-dating arrangement itself reflects this system of informational control, functioning as a curated narrative designed to manage reputation within Nevaeh’s rigid social hierarchy. They actively construct realities to serve their goals, leaving Ashley in a constant state of uncertainty.
The theme of The Corrupting Influence of Power and Privilege finds expression in the characters’ unchecked use of physical intimidation. The abduction of Ashley from her locked dorm room is an assertion of absolute power; Nate operates with the understanding that his status grants him the right to violate her security without consequence. This sense of impunity is amplified when Carter slams Ashley against a tree, his warning to “[not] speak to [him] like that again” a stark reminder of the violent enforcement of the social hierarchy (111). In this section, power operates through the normalization of coercion, showing how violence becomes an accepted mechanism for maintaining hierarchy. These acts are not treated as transgressions but as entitled exercises of will. The initiation at Cat’s Peak serves as the ultimate institutional expression of this dynamic. The ritualistic threat of death is framed as a test of worthiness whose stakes are trivialized by the perpetrators. The psychological trauma inflicted is dismissed, demonstrating that for the privileged, the suffering of others is a negligible cost for maintaining their traditions and social dominance.
The chapters also develop the theme of The Fragility of Trust in a World of Betrayal, highlighting how shifting loyalties and emotional duplicity create a different kind of danger than the secrecy that governs campus life. Ashley’s interactions with the central male characters unfold in a cycle of tentative connection repeatedly undermined by their self-interest. Heath presents himself as a protector yet uses their arrangement to serve his own social standing, as he wavers between genuine affection and strategic distance. Royce embodies a similar instability: He shields Ashley in the woods, only to later reinforce a damaging lie that bolsters his standing within the group. Carter’s volatility is even more pronounced as he moves from physical aggression to calculated partnership with disorienting suddenness. These oscillations prevent Ashley from forming any stable relational foothold. Even alliances within the boys’ inner circle show the same erosion, as the revelation of Paige and Royce’s involvement exposes fractures beneath their façade of unity. These shifting alliances reveal a social world where trust is always provisional, and self-interest is the real currency of survival.
The ritualistic performance of the DBS suspends individual responsibility and reinforces collective power. The masks and robes worn during Ashley’s abduction and initiation operate as tools of anonymity, allowing members to commit acts of violence without personal accountability. The unidentified figure who pushes Ashley from the ledge exemplifies how this concealment transforms an individual assault into a collective act. Cat’s Peak itself functions as an extension of this symbolism, a liminal site where manufactured danger intersects with the genuine risk evidenced in Sarah Black’s death. Its history imbues the location with a gravity that contrasts with the boys’ casual treatment of the ritual. This dissonance emphasizes the divide between privileged members, who treat the tradition as sport, and vulnerable initiates, for whom the threat of harm is substantive and immediate.
The Society Challenge at the Founding Families Gala juxtaposes the outward frivolity of a game with the underlying seriousness of the society’s power dynamics. The rubber ducks, objects associated with childish play, become instruments in a contest centered on stealth, risk-taking, and disregard for boundaries. This framing allows members to pursue transgressive behavior under the guise of harmless competition, reinforcing a culture that minimizes consequences for those with privilege. The challenge becomes a condensed representation of the DBS worldview: Power is exercised through daring acts that are excused or glamorized because of status. Carter’s strategic goal of unsettling his rivals before the challenge further demonstrates how even personal relationships are folded into this competitive structure. The interplay between playfulness and danger illustrates how easily the group blurs entertainment with real harm, reflecting the broader moral detachment that characterizes the society.
Unlock all 60 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.
- Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
- Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
- Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs