Dinner for Vampires: Life on a Cult TV Show (While also in an Actual Cult!)

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of emotional abuse and sexual violence and/or harassment

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Joy describes her experience of being a member of a cult while simultaneously acting in a popular TV show as a uniquely challenging dual existence. How did this juxtaposition affect your understanding of both worlds? Did this memoir remind you of other books exploring compartmentalized lives, such as Tara Westover’s Educated or The Glass Castle by Jeanette Walls?

2. The title Dinner for Vampires references Joy’s realization that she’d “been dining with vampires” and then realized she was “the dinner” (272). How effective did you find this metaphor as a framework for understanding her experience in the Family? What other imagery in the memoir effectively captured the nature of cult influence?

3. How did Joy’s voice and storytelling style affect your engagement with her difficult experiences? Did her approach to narrating traumatic events with moments of humor and self-reflection enhance your understanding of her journey?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Joy frames her vulnerability to cult influence through her lifelong search for community and belonging. What experiences in your own life have intensified your need for community? Have you ever found yourself changing aspects of your personality or appearance to fit into a group?

2. Throughout the memoir, Joy struggles with balancing her authentic faith and the distorted religious teachings of the Family. Have you ever experienced a disconnect between your personal beliefs and the way those beliefs are expressed or practiced by a larger group? How did you navigate that tension?

3. Joy describes how her isolation in Wilmington while filming made her more vulnerable to cult influence. Have you ever experienced geographic isolation from your support system? How did it affect your decision-making or relationships?

4. The memoir explores how Joy’s childhood experiences, including her parents’ divorce and frequent moves, contributed to her search for stability. What experiences from your own formative years have influenced how you seek connection and security as an adult?

5. Joy portrays her journey of reclaiming her independence and religious faith after leaving the cult. Have you ever had to rebuild or redefine an important aspect of your identity? What challenges did you face in that process?

6. Joy talks about missing signs of manipulation and control in her relationship with QB and the Family. Have you ever looked back on a relationship or situation and recognized red flags that weren’t apparent to you at the time? What helped you gain that perspective?

Explore broader implications and cultural relevance.

1. Joy challenges common misconceptions about cults, noting that most are not the sensationalized groups portrayed in media but smaller, more insidious communities. How does her portrayal of the Family change or reinforce your understanding of high-control groups in contemporary society?

2. The memoir explores the intersection of evangelical Christianity and cult-like behavior. How does Joy’s experience illuminate the potential vulnerabilities within religious communities, while still affirming the positive aspects of faith?

3. Joy’s experiences on One Tree Hill occurred against the backdrop of early 2000s television when young female actors were often hyper-sexualized and given limited agency. How does Joy’s account reflect broader issues of gender and power in the entertainment industry during that era?

Examine technical and thematic elements.

1. Joy employs several symbolic elements throughout her memoir, including the Sopranos-inspired Family photo and the recurring “Shh, it’s okay” phrase (259). Which symbol did you find most powerful, and how did it enhance your understanding of the psychological mechanisms at work in the cult?

2. The memoir moves between Joy’s experiences on One Tree Hill and her involvement with the Family. How does this structural choice create meaningful contrasts or parallels? What insights emerge from this dual-narrative approach?

3. Joy’s narrative arc follows her journey from seeking belonging to reclaiming independence. How do the specific events she chooses to highlight build toward this transformation? What turning points were most significant in her development?

4. The memoir features several important maternal figures, including Joy’s own mother, Pamela Van Hewitt, and eventually Joy herself as mother to Rosie. How does the theme of motherhood function throughout the narrative, and how does it relate to the cult’s patriarchal structure?

5. Joy frequently mentions her spiritual encounters with God as moments of authentic connection that contrast with the Family’s religious manipulation. How do these moments function in the narrative, and what do they reveal about Joy’s internal struggle?

6. The author uses different names and identifiers for characters throughout the memoir (e.g., Les, QB, Blue Eyes). How does this naming convention affect your reading experience, and what might it reveal about Joy’s relationship to these individuals?

Encourage imaginative interaction with the text.

1. If you were to adapt Joy’s memoir into a different format, such as a documentary, dramatic film, or podcast series, which format would you choose and why? What aspects of her story would you emphasize, and which might be challenging to translate?

2. Joy describes how her character Haley James Scott on One Tree Hill had a stable, loving relationship that contrasted sharply with her own marriage. Imagine an alternate storyline where Joy’s character on the show had experiences that more closely paralleled her real life. How might this have affected both the show and Joy’s own experience?

3. Joy mentions several instances when her parents tried to protect her from the Family’s influence but were unsuccessful. Imagine you could write a letter to Joy at a critical moment in her journey. What would you say, and which moment would you choose?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources