63 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of physical and emotional domestic abuse, sexual content, illness, cursing, violence, and death. The novel also features an offensive depiction of a person with bipolar disorder.
The narrative point of view shifts to Rob. Rob gets home from his work as a plumber. He sees that Claudia isn’t home but then wonders if he even cares. Lately, they have fought a lot, and Rob finds it exhausting. He assumes that Claudia is out looking for Quinn. He thinks it’s strange that Claudia is so worried about Quinn when she spends so much time complaining about her. She seems particularly jealous of Quinn and Derek’s lifestyle.
After showering, Rob starts to do the laundry. He picks up a pile of shirts and a phone falls out that he doesn’t recognize. There are several missed calls and messages from the same number. The most recent ones talk about Rob being out of the house and how the sender “can’t wait to get you naked” (274). Rob isn’t surprised but he’s extremely angry, thinking how they could’ve worked through their problems, but instead Claudia chose to cheat on him. As he squeezes the phone to the point where it almost cracks, it rings.
Rob answers the phone. Scott Dwyer is on the other end. Scott tells him that he is calling from the phone they found in Derek’s home, with calls and messages from this number. He asks where Rob got the phone, and Rob admits that he found it in Claudia’s things.
Scott comes over to talk to Rob. He asks where Claudia is, and Rob admits that he doesn’t know. He then asks if Scott thinks Claudia is capable of hurting Derek. Rob thinks for a minute, rubbing a scar on his forehead from a fight a few years ago where Claudia threw a paperweight at him. He admits that he does think Claudia could harm someone.
The narrative point of view shifts to Claudia. Claudia admits that she has been sleeping with Derek for the last six months. She thinks back to how her relationship with Derek started. She went over to Quinn’s house to water her plants and decided to take some of her nice clothing to wear or sell. As she was trying on a jacket, Derek walked in and found her. He asked for a massage, then the two had sex.
Claudia admits that she was initially sleeping with Derek because of the physical attraction and to get back at Quinn because of her jealousy. She has always been angry that she had to drop out of college to help Quinn after their parents died. In return, Quinn complains about her nice life and her husband, never even offering to help Claudia and Rob.
After sleeping with Derek a few times, she began to truly like him. They would lie in bed for hours and talk, promising to leave their spouses to be together. The night Derek died, she called Quinn and found out that Quinn wasn’t home. She went over to have sex with Derek but instead found him dead. She plans to make Quinn “pay” for killing the person she loved.
When Claudia first arrived at the hotel, she saw Quinn leaving with her bags. She stopped her in the parking lot, demanding to know how she could kill Derek. Quinn tried to defend herself, saying that Derek attacked her, but Claudia didn’t believe her. She stabbed Quinn, then dragged her into her trunk. She then saw the light in Rosalie’s room and realized that she had to kill her, too.
Claudia goes into Rosalie’s room and finds her sitting in front of the window with her binoculars. Claudia talks about her sister, and Rosalie insists that she doesn’t know what happened and didn’t see anything. However, Claudia doesn’t believe her. She pulls out Nick’s phone, showing that she stole it and that he won’t be coming to rescue her.
Rosalie continues to try to plead with Claudia, but Claudia advances toward her with the knife. Rosalie thinks of how hopeless her situation is, while also being afraid for what happened to Nick. She knows that, if he’s still alive, he’ll likely go to jail for her murder anyway.
When Rosalie coughs, Claudia pauses. Rosalie realizes that Claudia doesn’t know what’s wrong with her or if she’s contagious. She coughs repeatedly, causing Claudia to retreat. At the last moment, she uses all her strength to lunge at Claudia. Rosalie manages to knock her to the ground, then uses her nails to scratch her face.
Nick appears in the doorway. Rosalie realizes that Claudia is knocked out beneath her. Nick tells her that he saw Claudia coming into the house with a knife and rushed over. Rosalie starts to laugh but then begins to cry.
Claudia wakes up on the floor of Rosalie’s room. Nick is standing over her with a knife. She pleads with him, warning him that the police will believe her story and think that Nick and Rosalie attacked her. However, Nick is undeterred, threatening to stab her if she moves. He tells her that he saw what she did to Greta.
When the police arrive, Claudia thinks how they must know everything already. They immediately arrest her and take her outside. On the way to the police car, Claudia sees Scott looking in the trunk of her car.
Claudia realizes that she needs to know whether Quinn survived. She runs toward the car, but Scott intercepts her. She taunts him, saying that he “missed [his] chance with [Quinn]” (278). She can tell Scott wants to hit her, but he doesn’t. She asks if Quinn is still breathing. No one answers her as they drag her to the police car. She thinks how Quinn will survive because she was always “the lucky one” (278).
Rosalie doesn’t fully understand what happened. However, she knows that Quinn was taken to the hospital, still barely alive. She also knows that Claudia stabbed Greta. When the police found her, she was still alive, but they’re not optimistic she’ll survive.
Nick tells Rosalie that he still wants to be with her. Rosalie is relieved, realizing how much she still loves him. She suggests that they make the dining room into a downstairs bedroom for her. Relieved, Nick and Rosalie spend the rest of the night “making plans for the future” (281).
Quinn sits on her front porch drinking lemonade. She thinks about how much nicer her small house is, having sold her and Derek’s home. She spent a little time in prison, but thanks to Nick speaking in her defense about the bruises on her neck, she got leniency for self-defense.
Claudia was convicted and will spend a long time in prison. Quinn tried to give her money for her legal defense, but Claudia wouldn’t take it; she now refuses to let Quinn visit her in prison. Quinn is still surprised at how much Claudia grew to “resent” her and still can’t believe that Claudia fell in love with Derek. She discovered after her arrest that Claudia had stopped taking her bipolar medication months before. Her lawyer was unsuccessful at arguing her innocence based on her mental health.
Scott comes home. He became good friends with Quinn, helping her during and after her trial. A few months ago, they went on a real date together, then started a romantic relationship. Scott asks her if she is ready to go to the restaurant, opening her car door for her.
The narrative then shits to Rosalie’s perspective.
At the diner, Rosalie works in the kitchen. They modified the restaurant so that she can check over all the plates and run the kitchen, even though she can’t cook anymore. She is also pregnant, feeling more in love with Nick than she has in years.
Nick comes into the kitchen and tells Rosalie that she should go say goodbye to Greta. She is leaving to travel the world the next morning.
As Rosalie goes through the restaurant, she sees Quinn eating with Scott. Rosalie and Nick learned most of the details of what happened from the newspaper. After it all ended, Rob came to their hotel to apologize for what Claudia did. He also fixed the leak in room 201, and they managed to fix the ceiling that had been stained red from the rust in the water. However, Nick still does not rent the room out.
Rosalie says goodbye to Greta. She jokes about how Greta was right about her happy future, but Greta admits that she could never tell the future. However, she tells Rosalie that she had a hand in making Rosalie’s future. She saw what was happening between Nick and Christina, so she decided to kill Christina to save Rosalie’s marriage. She also saw Quinn getting close with Nick, so she told her she was in danger and wrote in her Bible to scare her off. Greta then shows Rosalie the “Do Not Disturb” sign which she took off the door of 201, insisting that Nick should start renting the room out again.
Rosalie is shocked by the information. She decides that she has to call the police. However, before she can do anything, her water breaks. Greta leaves her to get Nick.
When Nick arrives, Rosalie asks where her phone is, but Nick insists that they have to go to the hospital. Rosalie starts to tell him about Greta, but Nick tells her that she already left—she got a flight to leave that very night.
As they leave the hotel, Rosalie realizes that Greta was right. If it weren’t for her, Rosalie would not be with Nick or be having a child and would likely be dead. She decides that, if they have a girl, they will name her Greta.
Claudia’s point of view chapters in this section of the text stand in stark contrast to her previous section, invoking Appearance Versus Reality as she exposes her true motivations. Now, she is openly angry and bitter toward Quinn, revealing her true feelings about Derek’s death and her culpability. This tonal shift is emphasized by McFadden’s diction, as Claudia swears, emphasizes the “hate” she holds for her sister, and belittles Scott after her arrest. Instead of the concerned, doting sister that Quinn believes she is, she was secretly having an affair with Derek behind her back. The real version of Claudia that she desperately tried to keep secret comes out when she finally finds Quinn.
The revelation that Greta is Christina’s murderer brings the mystery murder plot full circle, exposing another aspect of the deceptive nature of appearances. McFadden uses a red herring trope, typical in thriller novels, where the author intentionally misdirects the reader to suspect an innocent person. Here, that person is Nick, whom Rosalie assumes killed Christina. This misdirection builds suspense throughout the novel while subverting the reader’s possible expectations, allowing for a surprise ending.
Nick’s innocence also adds another layer to the complexity of appearance versus reality. Several characters in the novel are varying shades of grey instead of outright “good” or “evil.” As Rosalie contemplates in the final lines of the text, “it was wrong that [Greta] murdered that woman. She should never have done it. But I can’t say I’m sorry” (323). This tension between right and wrong is prevalent throughout the novel: Greta commits murder, but does so to protect Rosalie’s marriage; Quinn kills Derek, but does so out of self-defense; and several characters commit adulterous acts, including Nick, Quinn, Derek, and even Quinn (at least in her mind) when she kisses Nick. In doing so, Do Not Disturb comments on the fluidity of the ideas of right and wrong. They are not clearcut, instead dependent upon both the guilt of the person committing the acts and the public perception of those acts. In this way, they heavily rely on the idea of appearance versus reality, as even a good person can commit an act that some may perceive as wrong.
In the climax of the novel, Rosalie completes her change in the text by standing up to Claudia and knocking her unconscious—an important moment that begins her emotional healing, bringing a resolution to The Psychological Impact of Trauma and Abuse. Throughout her point of view sections, Rosalie is portrayed as a sympathetic character. She is a victim of both her illness and her own choices, spending her time trapped in her room and contemplating her own death. However, when faced with the decision to die or resist, she fights back, knocking out Claudia and saving her own life. In the novel’s resolution, this change is evidenced by the progress that Rosalie has made. She acknowledges that anti-depressants have given her a new view on her life, while she continues to accept Nick’s help—but in a way that also gives her the ability to help herself.
As one of the protagonists in the text, Quinn also changes throughout her character arc, learning to take back control of her life and moving in a more positive direction. In her past with Derek, she was enamored by his money and his popularity, choosing to marry him because of the material kindness that he showed her. However, throughout the text, she repeatedly compares her unhappy marriage to her previous relationship with Scott, noting how she “wonder[s] what [her] life would have been like” (10) if she hadn’t broken up with him. In the novel’s resolution, she finds happiness with Scott, taking another chance on a relationship with him. In her final scene, she is seen “sitting on [her] front porch, in a rocking chair, having a delicious glass of lemonade with lots of ice in it,” noting how “some days, it’s just nice to be alive” (309). Quinn thus undergoes a journey of survival throughout the text—overcoming Derek’s abuse, empowering herself, and finding happiness in the love that Scott offers her.
Conversely, as the antagonist, Claudia is punished in the novel’s conclusion. It is important to note that Claudia has “bipolar disorder” (309)—a fact that is only revealed after Claudia’s arrest and conviction. McFadden relies on the trope of attributing mental illness to a dangerous character, thereby directly linking Claudia’s actions to her bipolar disorder. This trope is problematic, as it stigmatizes bipolar disorder and potentially encourages the erroneous conclusion that bipolar disorder is inherently dangerous.
Despite this, it is also important to note that Claudia’s primary motivation in the text is her jealousy and resentment. In this way, Claudia embodies the theme of The Dangers of Jealousy. While she has bipolar disorder, it is her years of anger, hate, and resentment toward Quinn that lead to her actions in the text. The death of Derek is the catalyst for her revenge, ultimately leading to her punishment and imprisonment. Claudia’s envious fixation on Quinn’s supposedly ideal life led her to undermine her own marriage to Rob, ruined her feelings towards her sister, and left her ignorant of the abusive, manipulative man Derek really was. Claudia thus represents the dangers of jealousy by revealing how ultimately self-destructive such emotions can be.



Unlock all 63 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.