33 pages 1-hour read

Dog Man: Grime and Punishment

Fiction | Graphic Novel/Book | Middle Grade | Published in 2020

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Fore-Foreword, Foreword, and Chapters 1-4Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Fore-Foreword Summary: “George and Harold: Celebrities at Large”

Police are called to a mall where George and Harold have set up a stall to sell their comic books; instead of arresting them or moving them on for selling goods illegally, the police read the comics and find them hilarious. They tell members of the public about the comics; crowds flood to the mall to buy and read them.

Foreword Summary: “Our Story Thus Far”

Everything from here on is from George and Harold’s Dog Man comic:


A policeman and his police dog are involved in an explosion that severely injures the policeman’s head and the dog’s body. A surgery is performed where the dog’s head is attached to the man’s body; he became known as Dog Man. Dog Man fought crime; in particular, one of his main nemeses was Petey the evil cat. Fortunately, Petey found love and became good. A panel depicts Petey being hugged by many people; it is suggested that Petey “may need a little help from his friends” to remain on the side of good (14).

Chapter 1 Summary: “Chief’s Big Day”

A splash panel depicts the Police Chief receiving an award from Mayor as his colleagues applaud enthusiastically. Mayor calls Dog Man to the stage to present the award to Chief. However, Dog Man does not appear. Someone suggests that he might be digging up flower beds. A speech bubble indicates Mayor worriedly declaring, “My roses!” Confirming Mayor’s fears, a panel illustration over the page shows Dog Man joyously and furiously digging up roses. He hears his name being called by Chief and runs to join him on stage. Mayor sees Dog Man covered in dirt and roses and wonders aloud whether things can get any worse.


A flip-e-rama section of the chapter depicts Dog Man jumping on and licking Mayor and Chief. Mayor is angry that Dog Man got dirt on his suit, slobbered on his glasses, and dug up his roses. Mayor threatens to take Dog Man’s badge away if he continues to misbehave. Chief assures him that Dog Man will be good, but the men notice that Dog Man has taken Mayor’s hat. In Chief’s efforts to pull it out of Dog Man’s mouth, he and Mayor are knocked backwards into a support beam. City Hall collapses dramatically. From the rubble, Dog Man leaps up and grabs the Mayor’s hat, running away with it.

Chapter 2 Summary: “The Saddest Chapter Ever Written”

That night, Chief and Dog Man go to Mayor’s house with flowers to apologize for Dog Man’s behavior. Mayor is unmoved and insists that Dog Man hand his badges over. Mayor tells his teddy bear, Mr. Snookums, about how powerful he is.


Chief and Dog Man go back to the station. Chief helps Dog Man to pack up his desk. Chief vows not to cry, but he sobs dramatically. Some other cops also cry, but others suggest that Dog Man is a bad cop; he chews up phones and poops in filing cabinets. They suggest that Dog Man is making Chief cry and that he should leave. Dog Man leaves the station. He howls sadly.

Chapter 3 Summary: “The Chapter That’s Totally Not as Sad as the Last One”

Dog Man returns home. He is greeted by Li’l Petey, who correctly interprets Dog Man’s howling to mean that he has been fired from his job. Li’l Petey comforts Dog Man by reading him a bedtime story that he and 80-HD (a robot) have written and illustrated about Dog Man. Dog Man falls asleep.


In Cat Jail, Grampa is working on an invention. He is irritated by Big Jim, his grandson, who is singing itsy-bitsy spider beside him; Grampa yells at him to shut up and admonishes him for constantly annoying him. Big Jim starts to cry. He tells Grampa, “I thought you liked me!” and Grampa clarifies, “I said I NEEDED you!” (55). Big Jim is mollified and flattered by this.


Grampa places his Motor Brain invention on Big Jim; it is designed to amplify the personality of the person wearing it. Big Jim grows in size and says that he is now called Snug. In a flip-e-rama, Snug is depicted kissing and cuddling a reluctant Grampa. While running away from Snug, Grampa discovers a secret escape room.

Chapter 4 Summary: “The Dog in the Hat”

Li’l Petey and 80-HD complete their new invention: a cat mask that meows and hisses when they toggle the ears. They put it on Dog Man. The doorbell rings; it is Petey. Dog Man rushes to the door barking and licks Petey. Li’l Petey explains to Petey that Dog Man got fired; the police aren’t allowed to hire dogs anymore, so they are disguising him as a cat. Petey advises Dog Man to stop sticking his tongue out and to stop rolling in dead things. Petey takes Li’l Petey for ice cream.

Fore-Foreword, Foreword, and Chapters 1-4 Analysis

George and Harold’s creation of their wildly successful comic, Dog Man, frames the story. The boys’ success introduces the theme of The Value of Creativity and Silliness; George and Harold’s sense of humor and creative prowess bring them acclaim and a significant income and entertain their readers.


Pilkey characterizes George and Harold as likable rogues and admirable entrepreneurs with their comic book creations. Pilkey aims to make Dog Man feel like the authentic creation of the elementary-school-aged George and Harold; he does this through simplistic illustrations; imperfect, messy panel lines; and the characters’ comic, colloquial language. For example, in the hospital, the doctor says, “Sorry cop Dude—but your head is dying! […] And your BODY is dying, Doggy dude” (10-11). The comic also reflects ideas that elementary-aged minds might come up with; Dog Man is created when the head of a dog is sewed onto the body of a man, producing a cop with humorously inconvenient, dog-like tendencies. Through his illustrations, language, and ideas, Pilkey aims to make readers feel as if they are actually flicking through George and Harold’s comic.


Pilkey further explores The Value of Creativity and Silliness through his characters’ creative inventions. In Cat Jail, Grampa works on his Motor Brain. Meanwhile, Li’l Petey and 80-HD work on a cat mask to help Dog Man disguise himself as a cat and thereby return to his work in the police force. In both of these instances, creativity is aligned with humor and plot development; this illustrates how Pilkey values creative skills and portrays them as highly important.


Pilkey evokes humor through outlandish and ridiculous situations. Chief’s award ceremony is ruined when Dog Man digs up Mayor’s rose bushes and tries to grab Mayor’s hat in his mouth. Dog Man is invited to the ceremony because of his role as a policeman but invariably acts too much like a dog and creates mayhem. The flip-e-rama in Chapter 1 depicts Dog Man leaping, muddy from the rose bushes, onto the furious Mayor, illustrating the mayhem that Dog Man’s canine tendencies create in situations where he is required to act in a human manner.


In these opening chapters, Dog Man is depicted as a likable, though chaotic, character. His irrepressible joy at the award ceremony is clear in his happy expression. In contrast, Mayor is depicted as an angry antagonist, or villain, due to his decision to fire Dog Man: “That dog-headed cop is a NUISANCE! And if you don’t fire him, I will! Gimme your badges!!” (33). The narrative positions the reader to feel sympathy for Dog Man, who howls pitifully at the moon after being fired from his beloved job.


Grampa is characterized as a harsh and antagonistic character. Through Grampa, Pilkey explores the theme, The Corrosive Impact of Hatred and Resentment. Grampa’s life centers around wreaking havoc and getting revenge on those who have wronged him. Even with his own grandchild, Grampa is unkind and unloving. Big Jim, who is characterized as kind but stupid, cries when Grampa yells at him that he is annoying. When Grampa clarifies to Big Jim that he doesn’t like, but needs him, Big Jim is humorously mollified. The reader is meant to understand the implicit insult and to recognize that Grampa is a selfish and unkind character who only forms relationships to benefit himself.


Li’l Petey is a foil to his grandfather, Grampa; a foil is a character who brings out another character’s traits through contrasting qualities. Whereas Grampa is harsh and self-centered, Li’l Petey is kind and selfless. Li’l Petey reads a story to soothe Dog Man after Dog Man comes home from having been fired, illustrating his kindness. Li’l Petey’s selfless nature is also illustrated in his decision to help Dog Man get his job back: “I got an idea!! We’ll help ya get your job back! Don’t worry about a thing” (46).

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 33 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs