61 pages 2-hour read

Fall of Ruin and Wrath

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 12-21Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of substance use, graphic violence, sexual content, sexual violence, and death.

Chapter 12 Summary

For the next several days, things continue as normal. No one speaks of the ni’mere attack. Lis struggles to shake a new feeling of unbelonging. She is convinced that she will see Thorne again.


In the middle of the night, Claude calls for Lis. She finds him in an antechamber with several of his advisors. She can tell that he has been using Midnight Oil, one of the most popular drugs in the realm, as well as drinking alcohol. He tells her that four members of the Royal Court are visiting. He is nervous that they will question him about being late paying his tithes to the crown. Although Lis wants to scold him for spending so lavishly lately, she resists the urge. Instead, she asks what she can do for him and learns that Claude wants Lis to go to the bed of one of the men. He needs information about why they are visiting to prepare for their meeting in the morning. She wants to say no, but she knows that she needs to be useful to him, so she agrees.


Lis therefore goes with Grady to see Maven. She is an older woman whom no one knows anything about, although there are rumors that she is Claude’s grandmother. She is responsible for bathing, prepping, and dressing women for sexual encounters with Claude and his guests.


Lis assumes that Claude told the visitors to expect her, and she finds the outer door unlocked, as well as the one leading to the bedroom. As she stands waiting in darkness, she feels herself grabbed from behind. Thorne demands that she tell him why she is there.

Chapter 13 Summary

Lis struggles to explain who she is, but Thorne insists that he already knows her, calling her na’laa. She then explains that Claude sent her. Thorne, who had no idea that she was coming, lowers Lis to the floor but continues to hold her. She asks him to let her go, but he tells her that he is enjoying being this close. When she points out that she is supposed to “service” him, he jokes that she is already doing so by pressing against him.


Lis tries to use her intuition on Thorne again but sees and hears nothing. This bothers her, as she will have nothing to report to Claude, but she is also relieved that she can continue to touch him without being overwhelmed. At last, however, Thorne releases her. He warns her that he likes and trusts her but that he does not trust Claude; if she tries to harm Thorne, he will “retaliate.”

Chapter 14 Summary

After Thorne releases Lis, he lights the candles in the chamber with his magic and then unstraps several weapons from his body as he undresses. Lis asks why he carries so many weapons when he can use magic. Thorne explains that as he uses his power, it needs replenishing. It also will not work on a foe as strong as he is, so weapons are often necessary.


Thorne asks Lis if she is sure that she wants to “service” him. She insists that she is, knowing that she needs to find a way to use her intuition on Thorne or at least get information from him so that she can make Claude happy. She also considers how attracted to him she is. With her affirmation, Thorne requests that Lis draw a bath for him so that she can bathe him as she did last time.


Once Thorne is in the tub, he instructs Lis to talk about herself to distract him from thinking about sex. She tells him her real name, Calista, which only Grady knows, and says that she is from a region near the Lowlands. She asks where he is from, and Thorne tells her that he is from Vytrus. All Lis knows about Vytrus is that it is the Hyhborn Court located in the Highlands. The prince of Vytrus is one of the few Deminyens that the lowborn know of by name, as he is “unpredictable and volatile […] and the hand of the king’s wrath” (157). Lis hesitates and then asks Thorne the name of the prince. He responds that she already knows it.

Chapter 15 Summary

When Lis reacts with shock, Thorne asks her if she is finally afraid of him. She considers, realizing that she is afraid of his reputation but still has no fear of Thorne himself. She tries to probe Thorne’s senses but is met by a white wall each time, which is different than anything she has seen before. She wonders if it is some kind of shield.


Thorne asks Lis further questions about herself. She tells him that she has never truly considered her future. However, since she likes the garden, she has always wanted to be a botanist.


Thorne then asks Lis to take off her clothes and get into the bathtub with him. Realizing that he asked when he could have just demanded or forced her, she chooses to join him. Thorne and Lis then begin to touch each other. She explores his entire body with her hands while he pleasures her with his fingers. As she is overwhelmed, Thorne asks her how she came to be a “favorite” choice for the baron to send to pleasure his guests. When she responds that she has been “servicing others” for a long time, he accuses her of lying.

Chapter 16 Summary

The accusation alarms Lis, but she does her best to ignore it. Instead, she plays coy, insisting that she can be experienced or a “virgin” depending on what Thorne wants. They continue to pleasure each other with their hands until they both orgasm. After, she lies against his body in the tub. She thinks of how strange it feels not to be afraid of a prince but instead to feel like she belongs in his arms. After several moments, Thorne asks Lis why she was truly sent to him, warning her not to lie.

Chapter 17 Summary

Lis contemplates whether to tell Thorne the truth. She reasons that she truly has no choice, so she admits that she was sent to get information. Thorne considers this and then instructs Lis to tell Claude that he is there to talk about the Iron Knights. He promises not to tell Claude that Lis told him the truth, which shocks her. She thanks him.


As Lis starts to go, Thorne asks her to stay. She considers how much she truly wants to be with him but decides that she needs to return to Grady. Back in her room, Lis tells Grady about what happened. They discuss the Iron Knights and how serious the rebellion must be for the prince to get involved.


Grady then changes the subject. He suggests to Lis that they move somewhere else. The conversation annoys her, as they have had it several times before. Grady asks about moving to Cold Springs, but Lis immediately dismisses the idea, as it has become a rebel stronghold. However, Grady explains that he will not be happy anywhere while the Hyhborn have control, so he would rather risk change.

Chapter 18 Summary

The next day, Lis goes to speak with Claude and Hymel. She tells them who Prince Thorne is, which genuinely surprises Claude. She then explains that Thorne is there to talk about the Iron Knights and the border. When she finishes, Claude dismisses Hymel, which angers him.


When Lis is alone with Claude, he asks her what else she saw. She reveals that Thorne is looking for information about something. Claude then questions her about what she did with Thorne. She realizes that he is just trying to make sure that she was satisfied, as he does not want to lose her. She assures him that she enjoyed her time with Thorne and that he is not the “brute” that everyone thinks he is.


After Claude leaves, Hymel returns. He asks Lis what Claude talked about, but she refuses to tell him. He angrily grabs her wrist and twists it. When he goes to strike her, she stops his arm. She warns him not to touch her and then threatens to reveal how he will die. When Hymel hesitates, she brushes past him.


Back in her chambers, Lis contemplates how to use her gifts during dinner with Thorne to get more information. Eventually, Lis falls asleep thinking about Thorne. It surprises her that she is not thinking about anything sexual but instead of the moments that he held her. When she wakes up a few hours later, Thorne is in her chambers.

Chapter 19 Summary

Lis tries to act annoyed that Thorne is in her bedchambers. However, he can see that she is excited and aroused by his presence. He flirts with her, moving closer to her bed as she does so. He tells her that he was wondering what happened with Claude, and she describes Claude’s relief that Thorne’s visit is not about taxes, as well as his curiosity about a prince’s presence in Archwood. Thorne interrupts her when he spots the bruising on her arm from her encounter with Hymel. Lis refuses to tell him who did it but assures him that it wasn’t Claude. Thorne kisses her arm, making the bruising disappear.


Lis asks why Thorne is truly in her room. He admits that it is strange that he is there, as he should not care about Lis. He explains that Hyhborn—specifically the ruling class of princes and princesses—do not have the ability to show compassion. She argues with him, insisting that he spared her life and was relieved not to have to destroy Archwood. She also points out that he is against making Rae by stealing mortals’ souls, something he told her earlier. Thorne hesitates and thinks for several moments. He then simply responds that she’s “right” and leaves, making Lis wonder why he would show such “obvious unease” at being compassionate.


Later that night, Lis gets ready to go to supper. When she looks in the mirror, she is shocked to see that her eyes, instead of being the usual brown, have hints of blue around the pupils. She closes her eyes, convincing herself that it was just a trick of the light. When she reopens them, to her relief, they are all brown.

Chapter 20 Summary

While waiting for Thorne to arrive for dinner, Lis is annoyed to see that Claude is already intoxicated. He complains about the prince’s late arrival. Thorne eventually arrives with two other lords, whom he introduces as Rhaziel and Bastian.


During dinner, the men mostly make small talk. Lis tries using her gift on Rhaziel and Bastian. She finds the same white wall but, to her surprise, can cut through it and hears both mentally complain about Claude and his drunkenness. She tries to do the same with Thorne but cannot break the wall. She realizes that Claude must have known this was possible, making her wonder again what experience he has with gifts like hers.


Thorne interrupts Lis’s thoughts by asking why she isn’t eating. She lies, telling him that she ate earlier. When Claude mentions that she has been spending a lot of time in her garden, Lis tries to dismiss it. However, Thorne asks her about the plants, and she explains the different species of sedum. When she realizes that she is rambling, she stops and looks around. The men all looked confused or bored except for Thorne, who seems genuinely interested.

Chapter 21 Summary

Thorne explains that the Iron Knights have begun working with the princess of Visalia and the Westlands. They are planning to invade and capture Archwood, which will give them access to the Midlands and Primvera, as well as Archwood’s valuable trading ports along the canal.


Lis questions why the Iron Knights, who want a lowborn in power, would work with the Westlands. Thorne tells her that the princess of Visalia believes that a queen should rule Caelum. To Lis’s surprise, Thorne asks her how she would feel about a queen ruling. Lis explains that gender is irrelevant; what matters is their ability to rule. He then asks what she would think of a lowborn as king. She hesitates, but Rhaziel assures her that she will not be judged for her response. She points out that there are more lowborn than Hyhborn, so a lowborn in power could bring positive change. However, once that person becomes king, they would effectively no longer be a lowborn due to the wealth and power that come with the position.


Thorne goes on to explain to Claude that Archwood will be protected. To Lis’s horror, Claude questions how three Hyhborn will stand up against the Iron Knights and the Westlands. Even after Thorne explains that an army of over 1,000 will be joining them, Claude still seems disbelieving. Ignoring him, Thorne tells him to prepare every man in Archwood to fight—including Claude himself. Thorne concludes by warning Claude that, if Archwood falls, it will be of no more use to the Hyhborns. Although Claude doesn’t understand, Lis grows concerned. She asks what will happen to Archwood in that event, and Thorne tells her that it will be destroyed.

Chapters 12-21 Analysis

Names are an important motif throughout the novel, often representing power, reputation, and connection between characters. In this section, Lis and Thorne both share their real names with each other, signifying the growing connection between the two as they learn to know each other in both a literal and emotional sense. It is particularly significant that Lis reveals her real name, Calista, to Thorne, as she has only done this with a few people in her life. However, the revelations also create new challenges for the couple. As the prince of Vytrus, Thorne has a reputation for brutality and ruthlessness. Learning his identity thus creates further feelings of conflict within Lis, as she struggles to reconcile what his name supposedly represents with the person that she has come to know. 


The internal conflict that Lis faces over going to Thorne’s room encapsulates her position in Archwood. She recognizes the danger of going to a lord’s bedroom, as well as the questionable ethics of using sex to gain information and power over someone, but defends her actions when Grady questions her, saying, “You understand that I don’t have to do this. That I’m choosing to do this. […] I could’ve said no. Claude wouldn’t have made me do it” (138). While this may be true, Lis also acknowledges to herself that her service to Claude’s visitors is one of her few sources of value to Claude. If she refuses to use her intuition and her body in this way, she risks losing access to a relatively comfortable way. In this way, her conflict emphasizes themes of both The Clash Between Survival and Rebellion and The Struggle for Autonomy, with Lis rationalizing acts of self-preservation as voluntarily chosen. Although this is something that Lis has done in the past, she is beginning to question how much autonomy she truly has when she is forced to use sex in ways that she considers unethical. As she notes to herself, “I knew how messed up that was. Deep down, I knew I still shared some of that guilt” (139). The quote highlights the untenability of her position: Admitting that she is not truly free would make that position intolerable, but framing her actions as voluntary implicates her morally.  


This section of the text explores Lis’s relationships with two key secondary characters: Claude and Hymel. Throughout much of the text, Claude plays an antagonistic role, as he uses Lis for her intuition and directly and indirectly forces her into compromising positions. That he risks his position as baron by overindulging in alcohol and spending lavishly also establishes him as a figure Lis may not be able to rely on. However, he also shows empathy toward Lis, repeatedly ensuring that she is alright and apologizing for putting her in a precarious position by sending her to Thorne. Conversely, Hymel emerges as the primary antagonist, serving as a foil to Claude. While Claude takes advantage of Lis’s intuition and uses her as a tool, he is clear about his intentions, provides Lis with a choice, and ensures her protection within his kingdom. Hymel, on the other hand, is a one-dimensional villain. He is disrespectful and abrasive toward Lis, repeatedly threatening and degrading her. In this section of the text, he also gets physically violent with her, nearly breaking her arm in his jealousy over his exclusion from Claude’s plans.


As the conflict between the Iron Knights and Archwood grows, the theme of the clash between survival and rebellion begins to resonate beyond Lis’s personal circumstances. When Grady implores her to travel with him to a rebel stronghold so that they can be a part of the rebellion and help the lowborn, Lis’s reflections summarize the basic tension: “He was right about a lot of stuff when it came to the Hyhborn and how the realm was ruled. […] He was suggesting that we leave to join the rebellion, which would likely put us in a worse position than we’d ever experienced before” (192). Grady provides Lis with a different perspective of the rebellion, but she remains reluctant to risk her life for something bigger than herself—an internal conflict encapsulated by the choice she must make either to stay safe in Archwood or fight in Cold Springs.


As the novel builds toward its climax, implied to be the confrontation between Archwood and the Iron Knights, Armentrout foreshadows Lis’s true identity with her changing eye color. This moment panics Lis but lasts only briefly, allowing her to convince herself that she is imagining things. However, for the reader, it hints that she has a secret history, the mirrored reflection she stands in front of symbolically representing another version of herself. 


Similarly, Armentrout foreshadows a hidden truth about Thorne during his conversation with Lis about compassion. Their conversation further develops the theme of Compassion as Vulnerability and Strength. Although Lis does not fully understand it, she notes how he “pale[s] a little” at the idea that he shows compassion toward her and Archwood (220)—a response that suggests he sees showing compassion as dangerous. Through this foreshadowing, the novel builds toward the revelation of the connection between Lis and Thorne, building mystery and suspense.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 61 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs