Finding Margaret Fuller: A Novel

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Pataki portrays Margaret Fuller as caught between her intellectual ambitions and her desire for domestic happiness. How effectively did the novel capture this tension, and how did it impact your overall impression of her character?

2. Margaret Fuller’s life was filled with remarkable achievements, yet her story remains relatively unknown compared to her male contemporaries like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau. How did reading this fictionalized account change your perception of her historical significance? Did it remind you of other historical fiction that highlights overlooked figures, such as Paula McLain’s The Paris Wife (about Ernest Hemingway’s first wife, Hadley Richardson)?

3. The novel uses water imagery throughout—from Walden Pond to the Tiber River to the final tragic shipwreck. How did this recurring motif affect the emotional tone of the story for you?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Margaret often describes herself as a “butterfly” or “pilgrim,” without a permanent home. Have you ever experienced periods of restlessness or transition in your own life? How did you navigate finding a sense of belonging?

2. Throughout the novel, Margaret pushes against the conventions of her time while still yearning for acceptance. When have you found yourself challenging expectations while simultaneously seeking approval?

3. Lidian Emerson points out that she is helping make the world “more just” through practical charity work while criticizing the transcendentalists for their abstract idealism. Do you identify more with Lidian’s practical approach to creating change or Margaret’s intellectual activism?

4. In Paris, Margaret gains inspiration from George Sand because she’s a woman who defies convention without apology. Who are the figures in your life who have expanded your sense of what’s possible for yourself?

5. Margaret’s relationship with her father was complex: She valued the education he provided but sensed that “his love was always conditional, determined by [her] performance” (14). How have your own family relationships shaped your ambitions and approach to achievement?

6. The novel portrays Margaret as torn between the life of the mind and the desire for love and family. Have you ever felt pulled between seemingly contradictory desires or paths? How did you reconcile them?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The novel depicts the tension between transcendentalist philosophy and practical social reform during a pivotal period in American history. How does the debate between idealism and pragmatism continue to shape American political and cultural discourse today?

2. Margaret Fuller’s Woman in the Nineteenth Century helped launch the first wave of feminism in America. How does Pataki’s portrayal of Fuller’s feminist awakening relate to contemporary feminist movements? What elements of her struggle remain relevant?

3. The Italian unification movement depicted in the novel shows how national identity forms during periods of political upheaval. What parallels do you see between this historical struggle and current movements for independence or self-determination around the world?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The novel is structured around Margaret’s expanding sense of freedom and independence as she moves from Concord to New York to Europe. How do these different geographic settings mirror her intellectual and emotional development and the novel’s events?

2. Pataki uses first-person narration for Margaret’s chapters but third-person point of view for the Prologue and Epilogue. How did this narrative framing affect your understanding of Margaret’s story and legacy?

3. Defying Convention is a theme that runs throughout the novel. How do different characters—Margaret, Waldo, Lidian, Nathaniel, George Sand—embody different responses to social expectations?

4. Gardens appear repeatedly as symbolic spaces in the novel. How does Margaret’s reaction to gardens change throughout the story, and what might these spaces represent in terms of her development?

5. The butterfly motif appears throughout the novel, particularly in Waldo’s gift of butterfly combs. How does this symbol relate to her transformation and restlessness and to the theme of Searching for Home? How does this novel’s use of symbolism in this novel compare to Pataki’s use of symbolism in her 2022 historical novel, The Magnificent Lives of Marjorie Post, in which material possessions often represent character growth?

6. How do the novel’s major themes, including Defying Convention, Searching for Home, and The Struggle for Independence, interrelate? Are they complementary or sometimes in conflict with each other?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. If Margaret Fuller lived in today’s era, what cause or movement do you think she would champion? What modern tools or platforms might she use to spread her ideas?

2. Margaret’s life is tragically cut short just as she’s about to begin a new chapter in America with her husband and son. Imagine an alternate ending in which they survive the shipwreck. How might Margaret have continued to influence American feminism and literature?

3. The Epilogue is told from Louisa May Alcott’s perspective as she reflects on Margaret’s legacy. Write a brief alternate Epilogue from the perspective of another character in the novel (Waldo, Lidian, Nathaniel, or Giovanni), reflecting on how Margaret changed their life.

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.