33 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Plot Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Book Club Questions
Reading Tools
Content warning: This section of the guide discusses mental health, pregnancy loss, ableism, anti-LGBT discrimination, cursing, and emotional trauma.
While the friends play Monopoly after dinner, Daniel’s anxiety is palpable as he constantly checks his phone. The game moves slowly, and Daniel explodes in a homophobic comment at Breckin. Holder kicks Daniel out. Six apologizes for Daniel and takes him to her room so they can be alone.
In Six’s bedroom, Daniel receives a long, emotional email from the adoptive mother, Quinn Wells.
They read the email together and learn that Quinn’s sister is Ava Roberts, the teacher who helped Six in Italy. Quinn writes that her and Graham’s struggle with infertility has made their marriage stronger and that they know it must have been difficult for Six to put her son up for adoption: “Because I am unable to comprehend the pain you must have faced, I sometimes wonder if you are unable to comprehend our absolute elation and gratefulness to you” (53). Their son is named Matteo Aaron Wells, which means “miraculous gift” (56).
Though terrified of becoming a mother at first, Quinn assures Six that she loves Matteo more than anything in the world. She includes photos and says they want to meet Six and Daniel, leaving Six overwhelmed with emotion.
After reading the email, Daniel and Six share a long, cathartic cry. They look at the photos of Matteo, and Daniel notes the resemblance to both of them. They then call the Wellses, who ask more questions about Six and Daniel. Daniel says they’re both first-year college students in Dallas; Six wants to be a psychiatrist (Daniel mistakenly says “psychologist”) and Daniel is undeclared. Graham and Quinn, who live in Connecticut, invite the couple to visit during Christmas break so they won’t miss any classes, and they accept.
Elated, they return to their friends’ gathering to share the news. After celebrating, Daniel tells Breckin that he’ll never call him Powder Puff again: “I’m a dad now,” he says. “I have to set a good example” (65). He and Six agree they must tell Daniel’s parents next.
Daniel and Six call a family meeting with his parents and sisters. When his parents become anxious, throwing out wild guesses as to what the issue could be, Chunk blurts out the secret: “For Pete’s sake, they had a baby!” (67). The stunned parents then listen as Six recounts the story of her pregnancy and the adoption. Daniel’s father thinks the story is a joke: It seems too outlandish to be true. Hannah and Chunk are stunned that they actually contacted the parents.
After stepping away to process the news, Daniel’s parents look at the photos of Matteo. Daniel’s mother emotionally reassures Six, who apologizes for having the baby adopted before she knew who the father was. The family wants to meet Matteo but agrees Daniel and Six should make the first trip to Connecticut alone. Daniel asks his parents to help pay for the flights.
Three weeks later, a nervous Daniel and Six fly to Connecticut. They have two suitcases: one full of their clothes, the other full of gifts from their families to Matteo.
Their Uber driver makes an insensitive comment on their arrival at the Wells’s home, prompting a tirade of insults from Daniel. However, Daniel deescalates the situation, apologizing to the driver, who in turn apologizes for his rude remark. They begin to bond over their shared love of tacos, when Six pulls Daniel away.
Graham comes out of the house to greet them, an attractive man wearing mismatched socks. Six and Daniel like him immediately. He and Quinn greet Six and Daniel warmly and lead them to Matteo. Overcome with emotion, they each hold their son for the first time. Daniel feels unworthy of being there but happy at the same time. Quinn shows Six an album of Matteo’s baby pictures, both mothers proud and happy.
While helping Graham prepare dinner in the kitchen, Daniel learns that his heartfelt phone call was what convinced Graham to allow contact. He thanks Graham for doing this for Six, and Graham corrects him, saying he did it for Daniel: “I could hear the desperation in your voice. […] The agony that comes along with not being able to take the pain away from the person you love more than yourself” (79). He notices Daniel is tearing up and changes the topic to the “poor tomato” that Daniel butchered while helping make the salad.
Quinn enters and takes over the food preparation, telling Daniel to go spend time with his family, which deeply moves him. He reflects that this is the best, most emotional time he’s ever spent with Six: “perfection. A damn Christmas miracle” (80).
On the first night of their visit, after Matteo is asleep, the two couples spend hours sharing their stories and bond quickly. Daniel is glad that Graham laughs at his jokes and notes that he’s a “stand-up guy” (81). The love Graham and Quinn share proves to Daniel that he and Six can also stay together and be happy despite their hardships.
Later, Six expresses her deep sense of peace, telling Daniel she is happy seeing Matteo thriving with his family. She thanks Daniel for making the reunion possible, and they reaffirm their love for one another. She’s especially glad that Daniel didn’t act immature and give Matteo a nickname like “Salty Balls” (83). Daniel jokes that he still has time, as they share an intimate moment.
These concluding chapters resolve the novella’s central conflicts of Daniel’s quest to make contact with the adoptive family and Six’s emotional disconnectedness from not knowing the outcome of her son’s adoption. These arcs culminate in a reunion that solidifies the narrative’s thematic threads. The motif of phone calls and emails is instrumental, demonstrating that long-distance contact can create the emotional space needed for vulnerable truths to be shared. The initial breakthrough occurs through Daniel’s phone call and culminates in Quinn’s email. Within this letter, Quinn discloses her own history of loss, which establishes an immediate empathetic bond with Six, highlighting The Invisible Pain of Motherhood. Quinn admits that she can’t understand the extent of Six’s pain in giving up her child, but she relates because of the pain of her struggle with infertility and the absolute joy she feels having Matteo in her life. She shares insights about being terrified at the prospect of becoming a mother, not knowing that Six has also spent the past year terrified about the fate of her child. Each woman approaches motherhood from a different point of view, but each shares a pain that no one apart from their significant other can see.
The subsequent phone call with Graham and Quinn builds upon the trust established by the email, moving the plot and character journeys forward. This progression illustrates The Role of Communication in Healing From Trauma, showing that healing can be initiated through digital means that lower the emotional stakes before a direct encounter. This is crucial because the time and space between each communication give both couples time to reflect, discuss, and prepare. These communications stand in contrast to Six and Daniel’s confrontation with Daniel’s parents, which presents them with news they aren’t ready to process or accept.
The novella’s narrative arc culminates in the theme of Redefining Family Beyond Biological Ties. The novella blends traditional notions of family into an inclusive model based on shared love and emotional generosity. This redefinition is a more expansive form of kinship than closed adoption laws allow. Quinn and Graham are portrayed not as gatekeepers but as welcoming role models in Daniel and Six’s life. Daniel and Six’s families send gifts for their biological grandson, signaling their desire to be emotionally supportive while respecting the Welles’ rights as parents. The most definitive moment occurs when Quinn tells Daniel to “Go hang out in the living room with your family” (80), a statement that validates Daniel and Six’s connection to Matteo and the Wellses. The novella thus rejects a zero-sum concept of parenthood as either defined by biology or legal adoption, instead proposing a collaborative model where both coexist. Six’s final realization that Matteo is both “ours and theirs” (82) signifies her acceptance of this new family structure and finally eases her fears. By presenting this blended family as the story’s resolution, the novella champions a vision of kinship that prioritizes emotional connection and the well-being of the child.
Parallel to the external plot resolution is the completion of Daniel’s character arc. In the novella’s first chapters, Daniel is characterized by emotional paralysis, trapped by his immaturity and fear of confronting the truth about his relationship. His decision to proactively seek out the adoptive parents shows selfless motivation; he is driven not by a desire to rebel and claim his son but by a need to alleviate Six’s suffering. This intention is recognized and validated by Graham, who admits he was prepared to refuse contact until Daniel’s phone call. Graham explains that he was moved because he could relate to Daniel’s desire to see the woman he loved happy. This mirroring establishes Daniel’s actions as an expression of mature, sacrificial love. Graham is a role model for Daniel; unlike Daniel’s own father, Graham shows emotional maturity and doesn’t rely on outdated gender roles. He gently teases Daniel for not knowing how to slice a tomato but still laughs at Daniel’s jokes, showing that Daniel doesn’t have to lose his sense of humor to become a responsible adult. This is a New Adult coming-of-age moment because it rejects the traditional trappings of adulthood, showing that emotional responsibility and integrity are all that matter.
Daniel’s coming-of-age arc is also shown when he apologizes to the Uber driver after calling him a “Dick Prick”; the driver told them to get out of the car while Six was crying, and this upset Daniel. Once Daniel walks back his insult, his sincerity and loquacious personality lead him to quickly bond the Uber driver. It’s the same quality that led him to emotionally connect with Graham. When Daniel stops acting defensively, he learns that he can connect with people almost instantly rather than pushing them away. It’s a lesson he internalizes after delivering the news to his friends about his son, promising Breckin that he’ll stop using the offensive nickname Powder Puff now that he’s a father.
The novella’s resolution employs symbolism, most notably through the child’s name, Matteo Aaron Wells. The Italian name Matteo means “gift,” and Aaron means “miraculous,” framing the child as a “miraculous gift.” This codifies the child’s role within both families. For Quinn and Graham, he is the answer to their struggle for a child; for Six and Daniel, he becomes the gift of resolution and peace. The name’s significance bridges the gap between the two couples, ensuring the resolution feels complete.
Finally, the narrative structure of the concluding chapters is crafted to provide emotional catharsis, utilizing the Holiday motif to frame the reunion as a celebratory event. Thanksgiving highlights Six’s sense of loss and Daniel’s penchant for confrontation while Christmas, which is culturally associated with hope and togetherness, brings all characters growth and a happy resolution. This seasonal backdrop plays into classic holiday tropes, with Daniel referring to the outcome as a “damn Christmas miracle” (80). The novella concludes with an image of contentment, fulfilling the promise of its title, Finding Perfect, by offering complete emotional closure for Six and Daniel while setting Quinn and Graham up for their standalone novel All Your Perfects.



Unlock all 33 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.