51 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of gender discrimination.
Annabel is able to make a decent breakfast for Bill, but she accidentally calls him “Daddy,” which puzzles him greatly (11). When Ben asks for scrambled eggs, she refuses, as she does not know how to make them. She thinks that her mother’s usual policy of making eggs to order for each member of the family is evidence that she spoils Ben. She puts down a box of the sugary cereal she has bought with her own money to have as a special snack and insists that Ben eat it, despite his protests that “Annabel” will be mad at him for eating it.
Aware that she has not yet seen “Annabel,” she wonders whom she will encounter when she goes to her room to check on her “daughter.” She does not know whether the person in the Annabel body will be her mother or another version of her own consciousness. Annabel’s room is a mess, and the person in Annabel’s body is lying on the bed reading a comic book and eating marshmallows. Annabel decides that whoever is in the Annabel body cannot possibly be Ellen, because Ellen never eats marshmallows. The person also seems completely unaware of the body swap. Annabel is frustrated when the other Annabel refuses breakfast, claiming to be full of marshmallows, but she lets it go because it is time for both children to be off to school.
Annabel hunts through the disorganized mess of her room for the blue tights the other Annabel insists on wearing. Because the signs indicate that this person is another version of her own consciousness, Annabel is not surprised when the other Annabel is moody, switching from demanding to silly and cheerful very quickly. She asks the other Annabel about her homework, and, just as her mother would ordinarily do, she pretends to accept the other Annabel’s quick lie about the homework being done. Ben comes in and announces that he has already walked Max, the family dog, and is ready to leave. The other Annabel snarls at him, calling him “Ape Face” and demanding that he get out of her room. The real Annabel reprimands her for the mean nickname, reluctantly kisses Ben goodbye, and sends the two children off to school.
Once the children are gone, Annabel starts to wonder what has become of her mother. She hopes that her mother is having fun, whatever she is doing, and that she will not pop back into her own body too soon. Annabel definitely does not want to suddenly find herself in school, facing her teacher without her homework. She looks in her mother’s appointment calendar and finds that she has made a note to buy scotch and that she has some kind of appointment at 2:30. Unfortunately, she has not noted where or with whom.
Annabel is not sure how much scotch costs. Finding only $17 in her mother’s purse, she mentions buying scotch to Bill, hoping to get some information. When he asks her to add three more bottles of alcohol to her shopping list, she tells him she may not have enough money. Bill chides her, saying that he gave her $50 just yesterday. He demands to know where the money went, speaking to “Ellen” as if she is a child. Annabel stammers out some guesses about where her mother may have spent the money. She remembers that she lost her raincoat and boots for the third time that year, and her mother had to buy her new ones. Bill chides “Ellen” for being too easy on their “careless and sloppy” daughter (21).
Bill offers another complaint about money: He is irritated with Ellen for promising Annabel that she could go to an expensive camp with her friends. Annabel tells him the truth: She pestered Ellen until one day, distracted by a phone call, Ellen finally said yes just to get Annabel to be quiet. Bill tells “Ellen” that he knows she wants Annabel to be happy, but decisions like this interfere with the family’s happiness. Now, they will not have enough money to go on the family vacation they had planned. She apologizes to him, and the spat blows over. Knowing that she will not be able to make dinner, she asks whether they can get a sitter and go out to dinner and a movie that evening, and Bill agrees. Before leaving for work, he asks her to make sure to launder some of his shirts during the day, noting that he does not want their usual cleaner to do it, as she does a poor job.
Annabel starts a load of laundry. The doorbell rings, and Annabel sees her neighbor, 14-year-old Boris Harris, waiting outside. Annabel has a crush on Boris, and she affects a sophisticated charm as she opens the door to him. He explains that he has come to return a colander his brother borrowed, although it is difficult to understand him due to his nasal congestion. Annabel invites him in, but she has to slam the door of her bedroom when she sees the shocked look on Boris’s face. Boris says that the room’s owner is a slob.
Annabel offers him some Vitamin C and then asks him to join her for a game of Nok Hockey. He is impressed that a grown woman would be so good at the game, and she says that she plays often with Annabel. She suggests that he come over to play with Annabel, but Boris says he would rather not. Acting as Ellen, Annabel sings her own praises, assuring Boris that Annabel has matured into a very interesting person who is entirely different from “the person who cut [his] scalp open with a tin shovel” when they were younger (29-30). Boris expresses doubt, saying that Annabel is “a bad seed” (30). Boris says that he has to be getting home. His speech is much clearer when he thanks her for the Vitamin C.
After Boris leaves, Annabel discovers that she has overloaded the washing machine and put in too much detergent. The machine is making a horrible noise and spewing bubbles everywhere, but before she can do anything about the problem, the phone rings. While she is picking up the call, the washing machine dies, leaving the floor full of suds. Max starts lapping up the soapy water. She picks up the phone, intending to call a washer repairperson, but then she realizes that whoever called is still on the line. It is her grandmother, irate that Ellen has not called at 9:00 as she usually does. She invites Ellen and the family to visit on the fourth of July, and Annabel has a sudden idea.
Annabel suggests that the family come and stay with her grandmother for the entire month of July, thinking that this will be a suitable family vacation and she can still go to camp. She is confused when her grandmother says something about Bill clearly having clearly had a “change of heart,” but she does not pursue the matter (35). She hangs up the phone feeling pleased with herself: In her mind, she has saved both camp and her father’s vacation, and now she simply has to figure out what to do about the washing machine and her father’s shirts.
In Chapters 3-5, the rising action complicates Annabel’s central conflict. She desperately wants to have a fun and successful day acting as her mother, in order to confirm her ideas about the ease of adult life—and yet circumstances keep conspiring to make the day complex and prove that Annabel understands far less about herself and the world than she thinks she does. These chapters offer Annabel the initial obstacles that she needs to overcome on her road to maturity.
In these chapters, Annabel gets her first real glimpse of The Responsibilities That Come with Adult Freedoms. Taking care of tasks like cooking, housekeeping, and shopping involves skills and knowledge that she lacks. Unfortunately, instead of being humbled by this realization, Annabel falls back on childish thinking. When she cannot make eggs the way Ben wants them, for instance, she does not stop to appreciate how hard Ellen works to make both of her children happy—instead, she decides that the made-to-order eggs are evidence of Ellen spoiling Ben, ignoring the fact that Ellen also makes eggs however Annabel herself wants them each morning. In other words, faced with an adult responsibility she is not equal to, she simply decides the responsibility itself is not important.
Annabel also creates new problems through her overconfidence in her understanding of adult life. One example is her struggle with the family’s washing machine. Because her mother runs the washing machine without problems, Annabel assumes that there is “Nothing to it” (27). She does not read any instructions and rushes ahead, overloading it with both clothing and detergent. Similarly, she does not understand that there are nuances to adult relationships that she is not privy to as a child. After Annabel suggests that the family stay with her grandmother for an entire month, it is clear from her grandmother’s questions about Bill’s “change of heart” that Bill has previously refused such a visit (35). Unfortunately, Annabel is still too wrapped up in her own perspective to really hear the meaning behind these words. She is busy congratulating herself for finding a way to have both camp and the family vacation and does not heed the warning sign of her grandmother’s confusion.
Annabel is not completely unchanged, however, even at this early point in the story. She is slowly beginning to see herself from a new perspective. During her discussion with her father about how much of the family’s money goes to replacing things Annabel loses and paying for things like camp, she learns how her own carelessness and self-centered thinking impacts the family. When Boris stops by, Annabel sees her room through his eyes and realizes that her parents are not the only people disgusted by her messiness. She also learns that Boris—the one boy she most wants to like her—actively dislikes her because of her self-centered and reckless behavior and thinks she is a “bad seed” (30). It is painful to Annabel to confront how her own behavior impacts others, but learning to recognize one’s own strengths and weaknesses is a necessary step toward maturity and Learning to Value and Understand Oneself.
Annabel is also learning to see her mother from a new perspective. She learns that Ellen is kinder and more interesting than Annabel gives her credit for and that Ellen’s life is not the paradise of freedom without responsibility that Annabel fantasizes it is. Boris’s visit shows her that other people enjoy her mother’s company and appreciate what Ellen has to offer in ways that Annabel herself often fails to. Acting as Ellen, Annabel has to ask Bill for money, explain her purchases, and be lectured about them. This shows Annabel that her father has power over her mother in ways similar to her mother’s power over Annabel. Her grandmother’s call also shows her that her mother still, in many ways, answers to her own mother. She begins to see that adult life is full of hidden responsibilities and rules and is not as sharply distinct as she thought from her own life as a teenager.
One person that Annabel still sees through her original, limited perspective is her brother Ben. Ben’s behavior makes it clear that he is actually a considerate, caring child. He walks the dog without being reminded to and gets himself ready for school on time. His worries about Annabel being angry if he eats her cereal show that Ben is not the selfish monster Annabel believes him to be, but Annabel ignores this evidence and just snaps at him to eat the cereal. Although she is finally beginning to see her parents’ lives from a new perspective, Annabel’s greatest obstacle to an Appreciation for Family Bonds continues to be her inaccurate understanding of Ben.



Unlock all 51 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.