Gray After Dark

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of graphic violence, physical abuse, emotional abuse, mental illness, and gender discrimination.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. The novel’s prologue shows Miley poised to shoot someone, and the chapters then rewind to the events that led to this moment. How did this narrative framing affect your reading experience and expectations?

2. Gray After Dark spotlights female resilience in life-and-death scenarios, like Noelle W. Ihli’s earlier thriller, Ask for Andrea. If you’ve read both novels, compare their portrayals of survival. If not, how does Gray After Dark stack up against other survival thrillers you’ve read?

3. Fred justifies his and Hamish’s lifestyle by claiming they are “the last real men” and “the last of a dying breed” (136, 103). What did you think about the novel’s portrayal of survivalism? Did it challenge or reinforce your existing perspectives?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Throughout her captivity, Miley balances her instinct to openly defy her captors with the need to appear “tame” to survive. Reflect on a time when you had to adapt your natural responses to navigate a difficult situation. How did this experience affect you?

2. Miley’s phantom shoulder pain symbolizes her unprocessed grief and guilt about her mother’s death. How did you respond to the novel’s portrayal of emotional trauma manifesting as physical pain? Have you observed similar connections in your own life?

3. The biathlon requires both physical endurance and mental focus, transitioning from intense skiing to precise shooting. What moments in your life required you to shift between different modes of thinking or being?

4. Mary/Rayna finds comfort in caring for her chickens, seeing them as symbols of hope and connection. What objects, activities, or rituals have offered you comfort during challenging times?

5. When faced with extreme situations, both Miley and Brent demonstrate different kinds of resilience. Miley adapts to her captivity while maintaining her sense of self, while Brent refuses to give up searching despite overwhelming odds. Which character’s approach to adversity resonates more with you and why?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. In the Epilogue, Miley notes that some media outlets glorify Fred and Hamish as resourceful survivalists who captured an “Olympic belle” rather than as abductors and abusers. How does this mirror broader societal tendencies to romanticize violence against women or idealize “mountain men” figures?

2. The novel shows how isolation can be weaponized as a means of control, particularly in abusive relationships. How does this connect to real-world patterns of domestic abuse? What social systems might help to prevent or address such isolation?

3. Gray After Dark challenges traditional gender roles and expectations through its portrayal of female athletes and its subversion of the typical “male rescuer” narrative. How do these choices contribute to current conversations about gender in literature and media?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. The novel uses predator and prey imagery throughout, from the owl hunting a rabbit to Fred taunting Mary with the song “Run, Rabbit Run!” How does this motif evolve throughout the story, and what does it suggest about power dynamics between the characters?

2. Discuss how the biathlon serves as a metaphor in the novel—particularly its idea of waiting for the right shot. How does it reflect Miley’s evolving escape strategy?

3. Compare Miley and Mary/Rayna’s character arcs. How do their different responses to captivity reflect their personalities and backgrounds? What does the novel suggest about the long-term psychological effects of trauma and abuse?

4. Both Miley and Brent serve as first-person narrators in the novel. How does this dual perspective enhance the narrative? What insights do we gain from Brent’s chapters that we wouldn’t have from Miley’s perspective alone?

5. How do Fred, Hamish, Brent, and Wes each embody different facets of masculinity? How does this portrayal of diverse male characters compare to works like Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl, which similarly explores complex gender dynamics?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. The novel’s Epilogue reunites Miley, Brent, and Rayna four years after their ordeal. Imagine their lives 10 years later. How might their experiences in the wilderness continue to shape their relationships and choices?

2. Design a “survival kit” inspired by Gray After Dark. What physical items, mental strategies, and emotional resources would you include in this kit? How might these elements apply to different types of challenging situations?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources