54 pages 1-hour read

Heated Rivalry

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 12 - 22Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of cursing, sexual content, and antigay bias.

Part 3, Chapter 12 Summary: “October 2016 - Philadelphia”

The story jumps ahead two years. In Philadelphia, Ilya Rozanov plays through a hostile away game while fans shout insults and slurs. He treats the abuse like background noise and even enjoys stirring the crowd. From the penalty box, he watches a highlight of Shane Hollander scoring in Montreal. Shane looks happy, and Ilya decides he will answer by scoring twice.


In Montreal, Shane spends the day with his best friend and teammate, Hayden Pike, plus Hayden’s three young children. Hayden reveals another baby is on the way. Shane enjoys the family chaos but worries that he does not fit the usual married-player path. Hayden tries to set him up with a woman, but Shane refuses and keeps his attraction to men secret.


Later, Ilya watches a TV segment about Shane’s quiet home life and mocks it, even as he stays focused on Shane’s image.

Part 3, Chapter 13 Summary: “November 2016 - Boston”

Before a Boston game, Shane sneaks out of his hotel and goes to Ilya’s place. Shane plans to talk and try to end their relationship, but he falls back into it immediately. Afterward, they stay in bed, kiss, and talk more than usual. Ilya asks Shane to stay the night, and Shane agrees even though he is scared.


Ilya surprises Shane with ginger ale and food. Shane realizes Ilya learned his habits, and he knows Ilya’s. They talk about their dating history. Shane admits he struggles in his relationships with women. A call from Ilya’s father interrupts the moment.


After the call, they get more intimate, and Ilya uses Shane’s first name. Shane answers with Ilya’s. The intimacy overwhelms Shane. He panics, leaves quickly, and takes the stairs to escape.

Part 3, Chapter 14 Summary: “November 2016 - Montreal”

Shane attends an after-hours party in Montreal with his teammate J. J. Boiziau. He meets actress Rose Landry. Rose feels easy to talk to, and Shane leaves feeling hopeful because he truly likes a woman.


Weeks later, Ilya sees headlines and photos that link Shane and Rose. More stories follow, and the attention irritates him more than he wants to admit. He tells himself it means nothing.


Rose invites Shane to the club. Shane dislikes clubs, but he goes anyway and tries to act normal among Rose’s friends. That same night, Ilya ends up at the same club and spots Shane with Rose. Ilya reacts by dancing with another woman and making sure Shane sees him. Shane watches, spirals, and leaves before Ilya can reach him.


Ilya leaves shortly after. He cannot sleep and thinks about Shane.

Part 3, Chapter 15 Summary: “One week later - Montreal”

Shane enjoys spending time with Rose, and they see each other frequently. However, the romantic and sexual side never clicks. During a private dinner, Rose gently confronts Shane. She asks whether Shane is attracted to her, and she suggests he might prefer men. Shane admits he has been with a man before and that it felt better for him. Rose helps him name the problem and stop forcing the relationship. They decide to stay friends, and Shane leaves feeling relieved.


In Boston, Ilya spends time with Svetlana, a casual, hockey-loving partner. She praises Shane as she teases Ilya about the All-Star Game. Ilya acts annoyed, but her comments land. He realizes no one affects him like Shane. He cannot stop picturing Shane with Rose, and for the first time, he dreads the All-Star weekend instead of looking forward to it.

Part 3, Chapter 16 Summary: “January 2017 - Tampa Bay”

All-Star weekend in Tampa Bay rattles Shane. He realizes he is attracted to men and wants a relationship with Ilya. For the first time, Shane and Ilya land on the same All-Star team, and the media obsesses over their “rivalry.”


Ilya arrives tense after months of little contact. Jealousy spikes when Ilya sees Shane looking confident and polished. Their conversation starts stiffly, but softens when Shane admits he is no longer seeing Rose.


Over the weekend, Shane watches Ilya joke with kids by the pool, and Ilya uses roughhousing to touch Shane in public. On the ice, they click immediately, passing like they share one brain. After a goal, Ilya kisses Shane’s cheek in celebration and disguises it as teasing.


Later, Shane walks alone on the beach to calm down. Ilya finds him, links their hands in the dark, and gives Shane his room number when Shane asks for a private talk.

Part 3, Chapter 17 Summary

Ilya waits in his hotel room, unsure whether Shane wants sex, a breakup, or something worse: Honesty. Shane arrives and forces the issue. He says their last time together felt different, and he demands that Ilya admit it. Then, Shane blurts out that he thinks he is gay.


Ilya tries to protect himself with jokes and distance, but the conversation cracks open. Shane explains that the hardest part is not being gay, but wanting a relationship with Ilya, his rival. Ilya admits the last encounter was different for him, too. However, he insists they cannot become “more” because if he lived openly, he could not safely return to Russia. He reveals his family situation, including his father’s strict beliefs, his mother’s death, and his father’s Alzheimer’s disease.


The weight turns into tenderness. They kiss, cuddle, and talk. Shane offers support, and Ilya thanks him. Shane leaves because the risk scares him, but they part using their first names.

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary: “February 2017 - Montreal”

Shane and Ilya start texting regularly, though still under their code names. They trade gossip and jokes.


In Boston, Ilya texts Shane while he rests from an elbow injury, but he does not admit he got hurt. He imagines Shane’s private life and grows more obsessed. He tells himself he needs more time with Shane so he can get Shane out of his system.


By March, the season tightens, and Boston and Montreal fight for the top spot. Shane expects their usual distance rule before the playoffs. Instead, Ilya invites Shane over on game day. Shane refuses, then goes anyway. They steal an hour together.


Afterward, they talk, and Ilya admits his father is declining and his family keeps demanding money. Shane offers support and tells Ilya he can call for any reason.


That night, Boston wins. Ilya plans to meet Shane again, but his brother calls. Ilya realizes that he would only call for one reason: Grigori’s death. Shane waits for Ilya’s message, gets nothing, and lies awake worried.

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary: “The next day - Detroit”

Shane hears teammates say Ilya did not travel with Boston to Nashville. The media reports only “undisclosed reasons,” which scares Shane. Shane texts Ilya, gets no reply, and plays badly because of his worry. After the game, Shane calls Ilya.


Ilya answers, explaining that he flew to Moscow because his father died. Ilya sounds stiff and exhausted. Shane offers condolences and urges Ilya to take time. However, Ilya insists on returning soon. Before the call ends, Shane asks Ilya to reach out if he needs to talk. Ilya admits Shane helped.


Two days later, Ilya calls Shane after Shane’s game in Buffalo. Ilya struggles with English, so Shane invites him to speak Russian and unload everything. Ilya does, and the release changes their bond. Their talk slips into flirting, and they admit they wish they were together.


After the funeral, Shane calls again. Ilya asks about Shane’s home and bedroom. Ilya jokes about marriage for citizenship, then admits he does not love the woman he mentions. Shane impulsively invites Ilya to his cottage in Ontario. Ilya does not say no.

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary: “The next day - Moscow”

On his final night in Moscow, Ilya prepares to fly back to Boston and feels finished with Russia. He gives his Moscow condo to his brother, not caring what happens to it. Alone, he asks Shane to video call.


The call starts playfully. Ilya teases Shane about his glasses and pushes Shane to show his bedroom. Their conversation turns intimate. They trade compliments. Shane admits that other experiences with men never felt right because they were not Ilya. They talk about early memories, rivalry, and desire, and they admit how often they think about each other.


After the call ends, Ilya faces the truth: He loves Shane. Their relationship could damage both their careers. Ilya decides to end the relationship, though the decision hurts.

Part 3, Chapter 21 Summary: “April 2017 - Montreal”

Montreal and Boston meet for the final regular-season game. During warm-ups, Shane sees Ilya drift onto the centerline. Shane skates over, and they speak carefully, faking animosity. They confirm plans to meet after the game and promise to talk later. Shane senses Ilya’s tension but cannot ask about it.


Shane and Ilya compete happily until Shane collides hard with Cliff Marlow and drops motionless on the ice. Shane wakes in fragments, terrified. He hears Ilya’s voice shaking as he asks if Shane is okay. Medical staff strap Shane to a board and rush him out. Shane fears paralysis, worries about his parents, and wonders if he will miss the playoffs.


Ilya cannot sleep and visits the hospital the next morning under the excuse of the captain’s responsibility. Shane has a concussion and a fractured collarbone, which ends his playoffs, but not his career. Alone together, Shane admits he wanted to talk before the injury. Shane asks again about the cottage. Ilya answers with a “maybe,” then leaves when a nurse enters.

Part 3, Chapter 22 Summary: “May 2017 - Ottawa”

Shane recovers at his parents’ house in Ottawa and watches the playoffs. His mother, Yuna, spots Ilya protecting his injured ribs, and Shane silently agrees. Montreal’s early loss hits Shane hard because his injury kept him from helping. He remembers Ilya’s hospital visit in flashes and realizes he loves Ilya. Still, he cannot bring himself to come out to his parents, even when his mother asks about Rose.


Shane texts Rose instead and jokes about “coming out.” Rose responds warmly, and Shane hides the conversation from his parents. While Ilya’s season ends, Shane worries their relationship will end too.


In June, Ilya watches the Stanley Cup Final alone in Boston and texts Shane. New York wins, and Scott Hunter, their star player, kisses a man on live television. The moment shocks both Shane and Ilya. Ilya calls Shane immediately and tells him he will come to the cottage.

Part 3, Chapters 12 - 22 Analysis

Part 3 is a turning point in the novel, as Shane and Ilya’s secret affair becomes serious and vital for both men. The public encounters between Shane and Ilya reinforce Rivalry as a Mask for Emotional Vulnerability. They play up their aggression publicly, so their teammates, as well as the spectators and the media, will read their interactions as fiercely competitive instead of emotionally fraught.


This constant commitment to outward performance as supposed rivals gives them freedom to exchange loaded looks, sharp words, and physical contact without scrutiny. Since hockey normalizes confrontation, even moments of closeness are concealed by the game’s violence and speed. Rivalry becomes a shield, allowing Shane and Ilya to simultaneously express and hide their feelings. Ilya even manages to kiss Shane on the cheek during the All-Star Game, passing it off as teasing. When Shane is seriously injured, however, Ilya becomes visibly panicked. Shane, though barely conscious, still warns Ilya that others are watching, “We’re not alone, […] Ilya. They can see us” (248). Even while frightened, Shane focuses on staying hidden, but his use of Ilya’s first name gestures towards their real connection.


Shane’s injury also illustrates The Tension Between Personal Fulfillment and Public Expectation. Before the game, Ilya plans to end his relationship with Shane, convincing himself that walking away is the only sensible option: “[H]e had to end this thing with Shane. It was never supposed to have gotten to this point. He was never supposed to have fallen in love with Shane Hollander. He should have ended it long before because now it was going to hurt so fucking much” (244). Ilya believes that continuing the relationship risks exposure, professional consequences, and even a forced return to Russia. However, Shane’s injury disrupts his plans, as when faced with the possibility of losing Shane, Ilya’s careful logic begins to shatter. Ilya’s desire for personal fulfillment conflicts with his public role, with Ilya starting to realize that the tensions between his public and private personae must be resolved.


Shane’s emotional arc also mirrors Ilya’s. Shane struggles when comparing himself to his teammates, as most are married to women and have families. The differences between Shane and Hayden Pike are particularly stark, as Hayden already has three kids and another on the way. In this chapter, Shane has yet to fully accept that he is gay, believing that he “probably would meet a nice girl someday and settle down and then his occasional attraction to men would be moot” (147). This pressure to conform to heteronormativity drives his relationship with Rose Landry. Rose stands for a life that conforms to public stereotypes about male athletes, so Shane wants the relationship because it matches what he thinks he should want. For example, he goes clubbing with Rose, even though he hates it, reflecting, “[H]is gorgeous, movie star girlfriend—wanted him to go out dancing with her. And that was a thing that boyfriends did. Right?” (176).


Even after Shane admits for the first time that he is gay to Rose, he still struggles with The Psychological Cost of Compartmentalizing Identity. Shane still hides his sexuality from Hayden and his parents, still fearing their possible rejection of him if he comes out as gay: “His mother looked at him sympathetically. ‘When the right one comes along, you’ll know,’ she said. And Shane chickened out. Because he couldn’t tell them that the right one had come along, and it was the pissed-off Russian man who was currently heading to the penalty box on their television” (255, emphasis added). Despite finally recognizing his gay identity, Shane still feels obliged to keep this part of his identity private, fearing how others might react.


Ilya faces a similar conflict, though it emerges from different pressures. He knows that returning to Russia as an openly gay man would be dangerous, especially because his family is tied to law enforcement and his father holds strict beliefs. Like Shane, Ilya compartmentalizes his identity into different roles: Public athlete, private individual. However, when his father’s illness and death leave him unable to manage his emotions alone, he can no longer keep the parts of his identity so clearly separated and turns to Shane for support. The phone call in which he speaks Russian freely becomes a defining moment in this section, as language carries symbolic meaning here. English, for Ilya, requires restraint and control, while Russian allows emotion to surface without filtering. Shane does not understand the words, but his willingness to listen creates a new kind of closeness. At that point, emotional intimacy replaces physical secrecy, and Ilya acknowledges the feelings he has long avoided.


The men’s use of physical spaces further reflect this pattern. Hotel rooms offer temporary privacy, but they also emphasize the character’s isolation and the impermanence of their relationship. The constant movement between cities and rooms reflects the fragility of their bond and their reluctance to commit. While Ilya willingly invites Shane to his apartment, Shane keeps his cottage separate. When Shane invites Ilya there, he offers more than time together; he offers continuity. Ilya hesitates, despite frequently envisioning the place, because he understands what crossing that threshold would mean. Likewise, when Shane shows Ilya his bedroom in a video call, the space symbolizes the true intimacy and commitment the men are still avoiding.


By the end of Chapter 22, both men recognize that their system no longer holds. Shane understands that ending the relationship would protect him, but he refuses to choose self-preservation over honesty. Ilya tells himself he will end the relationship, yet he cannot bring himself to act. When a rival publicly kisses another man, the image upends their perceived limits. Ilya responds immediately by calling Shane and committing to visiting the cottage. While both men still hesitate to publicly declare themselves, they both resolve, individually, not to give the relationship up, foreshadowing their commitment in the final chapters of the novel.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 54 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs