41 pages • 1-hour read
Jackie FrenchA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death, graphic violence, racism, and antisemitism.
The rain continues to cause the creek to swell, and Mark can’t stop thinking about the story and what Anna said about his parents. He thinks about how it’s true that he cannot possibly know them entirely and decides to ask his father some serious questions. At first, Mark’s dad thinks he’s joking, but then he begins to understand that his son is considering these issues personally. Mark asks his dad what he would do if his father were Hitler, and whether his father would still love him if he killed hundreds of people. Mark’s father tells his son that he hopes he would do the right thing and that he would love him no matter what. He is left wondering why his son is suddenly asking such heavy questions.
At the bus stop the next day, Anna continues her story. Heidi found out that she would be moving to a much more remote home with Fraulein Gelber, and the car ride there was long and arduous. Heidi was not allowed to speak to the driver, presumably because he didn’t know who she was, and at one point, the driver had to duck the car under a tree to avoid an Allied Forces bomber plane.
The new house was much smaller, had only one guard (who was elderly), and there was a new cook hired named Frau Leib. Fraulein Gelber warned Heidi not to speak much to the new cook and instructed her to lie and say she was her adopted niece, rather than Hitler’s daughter.
Frau Leib had a rough exterior as a result of working on a farm her whole life, but she was kind, and Heidi bonded with her almost immediately. Frau Leib’s husband was a member of the Nazi Party, and Frau Leib had a habit of talking too much. She often forgot how young and isolated Heidi was and would tell her things she wasn’t supposed to know. At first, these secrets were relatively harmless, like Frau Leib’s trick of feeding cows beer to keep them calm after giving birth. When Frau Leib gifted Heidi a rabbit, she was so thrilled she was nearly speechless.
Heidi noticed that Frau Leib would sometimes put sugar or flour into her pockets, obviously sneaking it home to use it. Heidi understood that it would risk Frau Leib’s job if anyone found out and kept her secret. Heidi also used to go for walks near the woods with Fraulein Gelber and often saw animals wandering about. They would sometimes collect mushrooms to make omelets. One day, Heidi saw an Allied Forces plane fly over and could see the bottom half of the pilot’s face. It made her want to wave, but something told her she shouldn’t.
On the school bus, the bus driver, Mrs. Latter, overhears Mark talking about Jewish people and asking Anna if she thinks some groups can be better than others. He brings up the fact that Ben’s dad believes all Asian people are “criminals.” Mrs. Latter cuts in and says that Ben’s dad is racist and adds that people today tend to listen to whatever they hear on TV rather than thinking for themselves. When Mark asks Mrs. Latter if she believes there are any superior groups, she answers that she thinks women are and goes on a long tangent about her feelings on the matter. Mark sighs and regrets ever asking.
Mark’s daily experiences at the bus stop transition from having a resentful, irritated undertone to his being eager to arrive there every day; this changes as he begins to question his perceptions of truth and morality. While Mark starts to find his place among a new and unexpected group of friends, Heidi experiences even more isolation, as she is forced to move to a more remote location. The imagery in these chapters deepens the story, particularly when Heidi and Frau Gelber take long walks through the countryside: “They walked across the Leibs’ fields too. There was a wood not far away and once they saw a deer, grazing delicately by the edge of the trees, and once a wild pig, a ‘wildschwein’” (64). The scene is almost too innocent, as though something is off, but it isn’t exactly clear what. These moments of quiet beauty are like the calm before the storm, as Heidi is about to experience an Awakening to the Horrors of the World.
In this section, several minor symbols emerge that enhance the novel’s themes. Heidi’s dolls, which she takes with her only the first time she relocates, symbolize the “perfection” that Hitler demands and which Heidi knows she does not have. Heidi’s imperfections are the very reason she is kept hidden from the world. This tension between the dolls and Heidi’s sense of imperfection is a hint toward her building inner conflict. French continues to use the Nazi regime as a motif in the narrative; when Heidi sees an Allied Forces plane fly overhead, she realizes that the man inside it is human, much like herself. “She could see the man’s chin and mouth” (64), and she even thinks about waving to him but knows that Fraulein Gelber would not approve. This moment humanizes the enemy and alerts Heidi to the fact that “good” and “evil” are not as simple as they seem.
Mark’s internal conflict deepens as the blend of truth and fiction in the narrative confuses him, especially as he struggles to understand the horrific realities of the past. He begins to question the nature of unconditional love, asking his father if his love would be unchanged even if Mark killed hundreds of people. Mark’s question reflects his growing comprehension of the complexities of morality and love, which are illustrated by Heidi’s complex connection with her father. Despite the horrors he committed, Heidi still loves Hitler, and Mark tries to reason through this difficult concept. Meanwhile, Heidi’s character continues to develop. She grows more aware of the world around her through her relationship with Frau Leib. Frau Leib is the wife of a Nazi, and her endless conversations provide Heidi with glimpses of the outside world. Frau Leib often forgets how isolated and young Heidi is. Frau Leib’s conversations open Heidi’s eyes to the broader complexities of life, even though Heidi is still sheltered from the full impact of these truths.
The chapter titles reflect Mark’s evolving character, as seen in titles like “Mark Decides” and “Mark Wonders,” mirroring Mark’s increasing involvement in the story and emphasizing The Importance of Questioning. Strong imagery reflects the rain motif, which French uses to emphasize the emotional state of the characters: “The creek bubbled and twisted, brown and muddy in the growing dark just like the thoughts inside him” (41). This metaphor vividly captures Mark’s confusion and pain as he confronts the complex questions about good and evil. Foreshadowing is evident when Heidi is told not to speak much to Frau Leib and to lie about who she is to her, hinting toward the awakening that Heidi experiences through the Frau. Irony appears when it is revealed that Frau Leib’s husband, Herr Leib, was in the Nazi Party, but “his wife was supposed to be trustworthy” (57). This revelation forces both Heidi and Mark, as he hears her story, to grapple with the complexity of human morality, deepening the novel’s exploration of deception, truth, and the blurred lines between good and evil, a recurring motif.
The Importance of Questioning, especially authority, also emerges as Mark listens to Mrs. Latter, the bus driver. Mrs. Latter discusses how people often accept whatever they hear without thinking for themselves, a sentiment that is similar to the blind obedience seen in Nazi Germany. This moment is ironic because, after overhearing Mark discuss Ben’s dad’s prejudice against Asian people, Mrs. Latter admits that she believes all men are inferior. Her hypocrisy demonstrates how unquestioned beliefs can happen to anyone, and that while people think they are right, they uphold harmful biases in practice.



Unlock all 41 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.