52 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of illness or death, pregnancy loss or termination, bullying, emotional abuse, sexual content, and substance use.
At the private carnival, Angel leads Madelaine to an oak tree and digs up the cheap plastic earrings they buried there as teenagers. He apologizes for his past betrayal, and they tell each other they still have strong feelings. They ride on the Ferris wheel and kiss. Angels tells her he has arranged for the carnival to host sick children the next day.
They drive to Madelaine’s abandoned childhood house. They light a fire and talk. Angel explains why he left Madelaine: He confesses he took money from her father but left primarily out of fear, not greed. He admits that he feels anxiety about his health, and she reassures him. They have sex in front of the fire, and Angel tells her he is falling back in love with her.
Angel and Madelaine arrive home late, holding hands. Feeling excluded, Lina lashes out, telling Angel he is not her father and does not deserve Francis’s heart. Hurt, Angel sends her to her room. Lina climbs out her window and rides her bike to a party, where she feels isolated and realizes she wants a real family.
When Angel and Madelaine discover Lina is gone, they panic. Angel questions his ability to be a father, but Madelaine challenges him, saying that parenting means staying and persevering through fear. Shaken, he listens to her as they prepare to face Lina together.
Lina returns home, ashamed. Angel follows her to her room, admits his own failings, and asks to be her dad. Lina accepts, calling him “Daddy” for the first time, and they reconcile. On Thanksgiving, they follow a family tradition of adding painted handprints to a tablecloth; Angel adds his, claiming a permanent place in the family.
In December, the family attends a memorial mass for Francis. Angel delivers a eulogy honoring his brother, and Madelaine cues the choir to play a rock song from their youth. The music helps Angel connect with his memories, and he leaves the church with a stronger sense of peace and belonging.
On the night of Lina’s first school dance, Madelaine comforts a nervous Lina by sharing a story from her own youth. Angel playfully acts as an overprotective father toward Lina’s date, Zach. After taking family photos, the teens leave for the dance.
At the dance, Lina reconnects with a former best friend and enjoys the night. Back at home, Angel surprises Madelaine by transforming the living room into a private prom hall. He declares his love and proposes with a diamond ring. She accepts, and they dance together, reclaiming a moment she missed in her youth.
On a snowy day near Christmas, Francis’s spirit sits on the porch swing, watching Madelaine, Angel, and Lina decorate the yard. He makes the swing move, and the family walks toward it, smiling.
As they approach, Francis feels himself rise, weightless. He sees a vision of Angel and Madelaine’s long, happy future, which will include a son they will name Frank in his honor. Understanding that he will always be part of their lives, he lets go peacefully, hearing their laughter one last time.
These concluding chapters function as a sustained resolution, using symbolic acts of reclamation to bring the novel’s thematic concerns to their definitive conclusions, and showing how they help to resolve each other’s tensions. The narrative structure moves from personal reconciliation to the communal formation of a family, and finally to a spiritual confirmation of their future. This progression demonstrates that for The Power of Forgiveness and Second Chances to be realized, it must be enacted on multiple levels. The unearthing of the red carnival earrings serves as the initial catalyst. By digging up the trinkets they buried as teenagers, Angel initiates a symbolic excavation of their shared past, confronting the promises he broke, in a renewed act of bonding and reconciliation. His subsequent confession that fear, not greed, motivated his abandonment transforms his betrayal from an act of selfishness into a failure of emotional courage. The couple’s lovemaking in Madelaine’s father’s abandoned house re-consecrates a space defined by trauma. The act itself is a deliberate overwriting of a painful history, replacing a memory of loss and separation with one of intimacy. This sequence asserts that genuine second chances are granted by returning to traumatic origins rather than through repression.
The motif of homecoming finds its final expression in the parallel journeys of Lina and Angel, which cements the argument for Traditional Family and Home as the Location of Personal Fulfilment. Madelaine makes this lesson explicit when she challenges him: “You spent your whole life running from things like this, Angel. Are you going to run away again…?” (361). His decision to stay and establish his role as a father marks the definitive end of his flight. This act is pivotal, as it repositions “home” as a place of emotional commitment as well as a physical location. Lina’s brief flight from the house after witnessing her mother’s intimacy with Angel serves as a narrative microcosm of Angel’s own 17-year escape. While Angel’s running was a flight from responsibility and Lina’s is a panicked reaction to feeling excluded, both are underlaid by the incorrect feeling that they are unwanted. Her quick epiphany—that belonging requires returning to confront conflict—demonstrates that she has learned the lesson that it took Angel decades to learn, functioning as part of the novel’s argument that generational progress depends on functional family modeling—that is, Lina is now learning from her parents’ example. The Thanksgiving scene provides a visual metaphor for their nuclear, traditional family. By adding his painted handprints to the family tablecloth, Angel physically imprints himself into their kinship, reclaiming a permanent space within it as partner and father.
Angel’s character arc resolves The Tension Between Public Persona and Private Identity by illustrating his deliberate divestment from the former in favor of the latter. His initial attempts at fatherhood are performative, as seen when he adopts an exaggerated, overprotective stance with Lina’s date. Madelaine’s intervention, demanding that Lina see “her father, not some Hollywood hotshot” (382), forces him to discard this celebrity-inflected caricature for a more genuine parental role. His struggle to find an authentic private identity culminates in his proposal to Madelaine. Instead of a grand, public gesture, he creates a private prom in the living room, a deeply personal act designed to remedy a specific moment of loneliness from Madelaine’s youth, serving as a restitution and a promise. This action demonstrates his complete transformation; he now uses the resources of his public persona to serve an intimate purpose. By prioritizing Madelaine’s personal history over a performative display, Angel signals the final subordination of his public image to his new familial role.
The epilogue shifts the narrative perspective to Francis’s spirit, a structural choice that elevates the domestic resolution to a metaphysical plane and provides a morally- and religiously-charged validation for the newly forged family. From his vantage point on the porch swing—a symbol of his protective, familial love—Francis is granted a vision of his family’s secure future. This omniscient confirmation serves to remove any lingering ambiguity, assuring the reader of the permanence of the bonds that have been formed. Francis’s peaceful departure signifies the completion of his purpose, indicating that his spiritual presence is no longer needed because the family unit he helped create is now whole. The novel’s ending is a also markedly positive portrayal of organ donorship from the imagined perspective of the donor. Francis’s heart, both the literal organ and the metaphorical source of his love, has been successfully transplanted, ensuring that his life force continues to animate the family he leaves behind. This ending frames Francis’s death as an arbitrary loss that gained purpose through heart donation, enabling mutual redemption and the endurance of love in his surviving family.



Unlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.