53 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summaries & Analyses
Plot Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Book Club Questions
Reading Tools
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child abuse, graphic violence, mental illness, physical abuse, emotional abuse, animal cruelty and death, and death in childbirth.
At Pinewood Studios in London, Aimee thinks about her fight with her husband, Ben Bailey, the night before. She drives to their home and finds it silent. On the coffee table is an apology bouquet beside Ben’s wallet, keys, and phone. She sees a missed call from an unknown number, but can’t unlock his phone. Ben’s coat and shoes are still by the door, and it’s clear that he has vanished, leaving all his essential items behind.
The morning after reporting Ben missing, Aimee goes for a run, passing spots from their first date, and feels sad that he didn’t want children. When she stops at the coffee shop for a latte, her card is declined.
An ATM also rejects the transaction. On the phone, a bank representative tells her that someone emptied more than £10,000 from their joint account and closed it the previous day. Bank records show that Aimee authorized the closure in person, a claim she can’t reconcile with her memory.
Detective Inspector Alex Croft and Detective Sergeant Wakely arrive to investigate Ben’s disappearance. Aimee gives her account but omits the fight, instead mentioning a past stalker and the emptied bank account. While searching the house, Croft notes a broken bolt on the bedroom door. She asks for a recent photo of Ben, but Aimee can’t find one.
She then discovers that both their passports are missing. As the detectives leave with Ben’s phone and wallet, Aimee feels their suspicion and admits to herself that she has killed someone before.
In Galway in 1987, a young girl named Ciara watches her father force her older brother to kill their pet chicken with an axe. When the boy hesitates, his father hits him. Later, when Ciara tries to comfort her brother, he shoves her, accusing her of killing their mother (who died in childbirth).
He taunts Ciara about the red shoes she wants for her birthday, which the family can’t afford, and threatens her with the bloody axe. Ciara runs away in fear.
Late for her final day of shooting at Pinewood Studios, Aimee learns from her costar, Jack Anderson, that a reporter is in her dressing room. The reporter, Jennifer Jones, who has written harsh coverage of Aimee before, begins to probe Aimee’s personal life. Aimee is glad when she’s called to the set, cutting the interview short.
After filming, Aimee receives a message from her agent, Tony, who warns her not to speak to the press and confirms that he didn’t arrange an interview. Jennifer’s unauthorized access unsettles Aimee.
Upset after the confrontation with her brother, Ciara sits, crying, outside a shop and notices that the red shoes are gone from the window. A young woman approaches, introduces herself as Maggie, and comforts Ciara, earning her trust.
Maggie offers to help her get home. Though Ciara knows home is in the other direction, she takes Maggie’s hand and walks off with her, marking the start of her abduction.
On the set, Aimee and Jack perform an intense romantic scene for their film, Sometimes I Kill. The sequence moves from a restaurant to an elevator, ending in a hotel room, where the characters kiss before the director calls cut. The day’s work mirrors Aimee’s chaotic private life.
Maggie takes Ciara to a holiday cottage, distracting her with television and cake. She gives Ciara milk that tastes chalky and pretends to phone her father, returning to say that he agreed she could stay for a few days.
Ciara grows drowsy from the milk but is clearheaded enough to know that Maggie is lying, as her family has no telephone.
Aimee returns home and senses someone watching her. She closes the curtains and thinks about a stalker from two years ago who sent menacing postcards and once appeared across the street dressed just like her. She also recalls a childhood trauma that she had pretended to forget after a diagnosis of transient global amnesia.
Ciara wakes in the back of Maggie’s car, realizing that they’ve traveled far from home. Maggie tells her to go back to sleep, promising a surprise. Ciara pretends to sleep, now understanding that she has been taken.
Unable to find a recent photo of Ben for the police, Aimee searches the attic. The space is bare except for a single shoebox. She opens it and recoils when she sees its contents. She carries the box downstairs and hides it in her wardrobe without examining it further, convinced that she may not know her husband as well as she thought.
Maggie arrives in Essex and leads the sleepy Ciara into a flat where a man with a gold tooth waits. He introduces himself as John Sinclair, her new father. Ciara screams as Maggie hands her over to John.
Detectives Croft and Wakely are waiting for Aimee when she returns from her run. Croft shows Aimee restaurant CCTV footage of her slapping Ben. Aimee admits that it happened, but calls it a one-time event. The detectives take her laptop to investigate the stalker, and they search Ben’s car. The boot (trunk) is empty, but Croft points out a discrepancy between a recent fuel receipt and the nearly empty petrol gauge.
In the Essex flat, the terrified Ciara wets herself. Maggie slaps her, roughly bathes her, and hacks off her hair. Maggie hands her pajamas embroidered with the name Aimee and declares that this is the girl’s new name, threatening punishment if she uses her old one.
Aimee retrieves the shoebox from her wardrobe and lays out its contents: more than 50 vintage postcards, each threatening that the sender knows her identity. Unsure why Ben kept them, she slides the box under her bed. In the kitchen, she finds two empty lighter gel bottles in the bin.
Days later, the girl, now Aimee, wakes and notices bars on her bedroom window. Maggie dismisses them as protection. She brings Aimee into bed with John, and they eat buttered digestive biscuits for breakfast. Maggie tells the child to call her Mum.
On her final day of filming, Aimee reads a profile of a rival actress, Alicia White, and notices that Alicia uses the shade of red Chanel lipstick that Aimee recently found under her bed, hardening her suspicion that Ben was having an affair.
Detectives Croft and Wakely arrive on the set. Croft shows Aimee grainy petrol station CCTV of a woman resembling her buying lighter gel with Ben’s card. Aimee denies it’s her and suggests that her stalker, Maggie O’Neil, made the purchase. She then tells the detectives that Maggie is dead.
Maggie takes Aimee to the bookmaker’s (betting) shop beneath the flat, explaining that they sell dreams that never come true. Aimee asks if she can go home for her birthday in September. Maggie tells her that this is her home now and that her birthday is in April, stripping away the last piece of her old identity.
The novel’s “present” timeline is set in London in 2017 and centers on actress Aimee Sinclair, whose amnesia makes her narration unreliable. Alternate chapters focus on a past timeline beginning in 1987 and center on a young Irish girl, Ciara. The past sections track Ciara’s abduction from Galway to Essex, where she’s forced to adopt the name Aimee.
This dual-timeline structure establishes one of the novel’s main themes: The Unreliability of Memory as a Consequence of Trauma. By alternating between Aimee’s disoriented present in 2017 and Ciara’s linear past in 1987, the narrative creates a structural dissonance that mirrors the protagonist’s fractured psyche. Aimee’s first-person account is unreliable; as an actress, she admits that “[l]ying is what [she does] for a living” (1), and her account contains memory gaps and reveals diagnosed amnesia. Consequently, readers may be skeptical of her perceptions about Ben’s disappearance, the empty bank account, and her actions. In contrast, Ciara’s chapters present her story as chronological recollections of trauma, lending them an initial sense of objective truth. This juxtaposition may manipulate readers’ sympathies, compelling trust in the traumatic memories of the child while fostering distrust of the adult she becomes. The structure is itself disorienting, forcing readers to piece together a reality from fragmented and contradictory evidence.
This narrative fragmentation introduces another theme: The Fragility of a Constructed Identity. The text explores this theme through Aimee’s profession and the erasure of her original self. Aimee’s career as an actress is a metaphor for her life: She finds competence in performance because her core identity has been shattered. She confesses, “Acting is easy; it’s being me that I find difficult” (3), revealing a significant alienation from an authentic sense of self. Reinforcing this disconnect is the recurring motif of mirrors and reflections, in which she observes her image as a separate, constructed entity. The Ciara flashbacks provide the violent origin of this schism. Her captors, Maggie and John, systematically dismantle her identity by forcibly changing her name, cutting her hair, altering her birthday, and (later) erasing her Irish accent. This isn’t merely an abduction but a psychological re-engineering that replaces a child’s real identity with a fictional one. The narrative posits that identity is not innate but a performance that external forces can rewrite. When Maggie renames Ciara “Aimee” because, she claims, it means “loved” (58), she manipulates Ciara, framing an exercise in control as an act of affection.
The psychological warfare inherent in Aimee’s creation extends into her adult life and develops another theme: The Destructive Nature of Deception in Relationships. The dynamic between Aimee and her husband, Ben, mirrors the abusive control exerted by her childhood captors. Ben’s isolation of Aimee from friends, his accusations of infidelity, and his verbal cruelty are forms of gaslighting designed to erode her perception of reality. This pattern of manipulation culminates in the police revealing CCTV footage of Aimee slapping Ben, which they use to frame her as the aggressor. This deception (though not of the detectives’ making) echoes Maggie’s methods of using comfort and care (offering cake and feigned concern) to kidnap and control Ciara. The drugged milk that Maggie gives Ciara symbolizes this poisoned nurturance, physically manifesting a relationship built on toxic falsehoods. The narrative draws a parallel between the supposed parental care of her captors and the supposed marital love from her husband. Both relationships weaponize affection to control Aimee, suggesting that unresolved trauma has conditioned her to accept relationships defined by psychological manipulation.
Throughout these opening chapters, symbols and motifs reinforce the atmosphere of threat and the cyclical nature of violence. The recurring image of the red shoes represents Ciara’s stolen childhood and unfulfilled desires, a symbol of innocence denied by her family’s poverty and then by her abduction. In the present, the phrase “I know who you are” (39), appearing on the stalker’s postcards, is a motif of psychological terror. This refrain externalizes Aimee’s fear that her fragile identity is transparent and that her traumatic past is about to reclaim her. Sinister meaning imbues mundane objects: The two empty lighter gel bottles in the kitchen garbage and the mismatched fuel receipt for Ben’s car tangibly signify a larger plot against her. Furthermore, the broken bolt on the bedroom door physically marks a violated sanctuary and foreshadows domestic violence. These elements build a world in which Aimee’s environment reflects her internal state of siege. Her final admission that she has killed someone before positions her not merely as a target but as a potential participant in this cycle of violence, complicating her role.
Craft elements help create the novel’s tension. The use of short chapters, many ending on cliffhangers, maintains a rapid pace and may keep readers off-balance. The text delivers significant revelations (that Aimee herself emptied the bank account, that she has killed before, and that a woman resembling her was captured on CCTV at a gas station) in chapter-ending sentences, destabilizing Aimee’s (and potentially readers’) understanding of events. The first-person narration immerses readers in Aimee’s paranoia, conveying her confusion with immediacy. By strategically withholding information through Aimee’s amnesia and the curated flashbacks, the narrative constructs a mystery that is as much about psychological excavation as it is about solving a crime. This structural approach mirrors Aimee’s struggle to make sense of her present by mimicking the cognitive experience of trauma, in which memories aren’t linear but surface as intrusive, jarring fragments.



Unlock all 53 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.