66 pages 2-hour read

Immortal Consequences

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 5Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains descriptions of illness and death, child death, substance use, emotional abuse, physical abuse and sexual content.

Part 5: “The Beginning”

Part 5, Chapter 37 Summary: “Irene”

Five days later, Irene is thinking about the group’s research into the attack and Louise’s shadow magic, which they must complete within two more days. That night, the mandatory Decennial Ball will interrupt their ability to research. Her unhealed stomach wound throbs. Masika barges in, voicing suspicion of Louise. Irene admits she secretly used psyche magic on a sleeping Louise but learned nothing. Masika remains wary and leaves to investigate alone.


Irene summons Mateo, her Demien Order contact. He denies sending the shadow creature but admits he watched Irene’s fight. He praises her power and urges her to join the Order. Irene dismisses him, saying she will call him again after the third trial.

Part 5, Chapter 38 Summary: “Masika”

Masika investigates Louise without Irene. She rides wind magic over the barriers of Litterman House and lands on a balcony outside Louise’s room. She spots Emilio spying on a sleeping Louise below. Emilio shares notes on Louise’s odd behavior and a plan to break into the restricted Housemasters’ Library for a book on shadow magic with an iron key he stole from Housemaster Wesley. They agree he will retrieve the book before the Ball.


Before she leaves, Masika urges Emilio to confess his feelings for Olivier. They part with a plan for Emilio to get the book so they can compare what they learn.

Part 5, Chapter 39 Summary: “Emilio”

An hour before the Ball, Emilio decides to ask Olivier to be his date and picks a violet for him. He collides with Olivier, who says he plans to attend with Scarlett Byrne. Disappointed, Emilio crushes the flower, but Olivier clarifies the date is for appearances only and agrees to help with Emilio’s library mission. They slip into the Housemasters’ section using the stolen key.


Emilio uses a Seeing Orb to summon the book on shadow magic. When Housemasters Russo and Birdie arrive, Emilio and Olivier hide and overhear them discuss someone’s secret connection. They wait for the housemasters to leave and escape with the forbidden book.

Part 5, Chapter 40 Summary: “Olivier”

Back at Litterman House, anxiety from the close call lingers. Emilio heads to his room to read, and Olivier goes to his own for a jacket, where August is waiting. August demands Olivier promise not to tell Wren he placed a piece of his soul inside her. Olivier argues that keeping this secret is wrong, but August points to Olivier’s own secret—his memory loss. The reminder rattles Olivier and he agrees to stay silent. August leaves, and Olivier is left with the weight of both secrets as the Ball begins.

Part 5, Chapter 41 Summary: “Wren”

Restless, Wren detours to Asphodel Hall to check on the eliminated nominees. She disables a ward and conjures an illusion to distract the Ascended guards. Inside the infirmary, she finds injured students but not the nominees. She meets Maya visiting her unconscious friend, Keira.


When Wren asks Maya about the eliminated students, Maya shows no memory of them, and a fog briefly clouds her eyes. Wren realizes someone has altered Maya’s memory. When pressed, Maya panics and runs away. Wren leaves, concluding that the nominees and the school’s memory of them have been removed.

Part 5, Chapter 42 Summary: “August”

August enters the Decennial Ball. After a tense exchange with Irene, he speaks with Masika, who worries Irene might join the Demien Order. When Wren arrives, August hears her in his mind and realizes his soul-spell has created a telepathic link. They dance, and August is excited by their physical closeness.


They talk telepathically. Wren tells him the eliminated nominees are missing and that someone erased students’ memories of them. Understanding him better now that she has a telepathic link, she pushes him to drop his emotional barriers with others. Defensive, he ends the dance and warns her to trust no one before leaving the ballroom.

Part 5, Chapter 43 Summary: “Emilio”

Emilio stays on the edges of the Ball while Olivier drinks too much and snaps at his date, Scarlett. When Josie and Carter reminisce about their eliminated friends, Olivier lashes out at them too. Masika pulls Emilio and Olivier aside to discuss the shadow magic book, but Olivier leaves to refill his glass. When Emilio suggest he should slow his drinking, Olivier snaps and then looks regretful and apologizes.


Olivier walks away and Masika stays with Emilio, reassuring him that Olivier “adores” him and Olivier’s behavior is about something other than Emilio. They agree to regroup with the others to share what the book reveals.

Part 5, Chapter 44 Summary: “Wren”

Shaken by the telepathic link and August’s exit, Wren feels the crowd press in. Masika finds her and leads her to a quiet corridor. Wren explains that the eliminated nominees are gone and others’ memories of them have been wiped. Masika suggests they gather the other nominees in the campus garden to share information. She heads off to retrieve them. Wren follows an instinct toward the Memorium, believing she will find August there. She hears his voice in her mind as she steps inside.

Part 5, Chapter 45 Summary: “Olivier”

Guilt drives Olivier back to Emilio, who confronts him and demands the truth. Olivier admits he is losing his memories and that failing the Decennial means his soul will be sent to the Ether. Emilio is shaken by the secret but reaches out to him and tells him he matters. Olivier leans in to kiss him.


Masika arrives with Irene, Josie, and Carter, and calls them urgently into the garden. Olivier and Emilio follow.

Part 5, Chapter 46 Summary: “Wren”

Wren August in the Memorium. He is looking at letters and says he is grieving for someone he once lost to the Demien Order. When Wren offers to listen to him about his pain, he pushes her away. Headmaster Silas appears and reveals the Decennial is a ritual sacrifice. Every cycle, he uses psyche magic to erase the 11 eliminated nominees from memory, then sacrifices their souls to the Ether to maintain its balance.


Silas turns on Wren, taunting her with knowledge of her past and her role in her sister Maeve’s death. August moves to defend her, but Silas teleports them to the garden, where the other nominees wait. Silas announces he will now reveal the truth to them all.

Part 5 Analysis

These chapters build momentum for the mystery element of the plot by showing the different characters participating in various elements of their joint quest to answers. The reader observes Irene contemplating an alliance with the Demien Order while, in the next chapter, her closest friend Masika begins a separate investigation into Louise. This momentum culminates in the garden and Memorium, where Silas unifies their disparate threads of knowledge with his revelation. His climactic revelation brings the six nominees into a shared, catastrophic understanding, moving them into a phase of collective crisis. This is an example of Silas’s character continually acting in the novel as a force for group cohesion, although he constantly wishes to divide the nominees. In this way, the narrative constantly undermines Silas’s authority, revealing him as a flawed character, less clever than he supposes.


This section foregrounds the motif of secrets as a currency of power, protection, and control, with key settings functioning as symbolic arenas for these transactions. The Housemasters’ Library becomes a physical manifestation of forbidden knowledge, a space where truth is intentionally restricted by the institution. Furthering the theme of Adolescent Rule-Breaking as a Transition into the Adult World, the students’ transgressions become increasingly subversive as they challenge the corruption of Blackwood. Emilio’s liberation of the truth therefore becomes an act of reclaiming a suppressed history, and is also a parallel escape from his own self-narrative of doubt and fear, as his actions signify a shift from passive intellectualism to active rebellion. The telepathic conversation between Wren and August during their waltz epitomizes this subversive disobedience: Their bodies conform to the ball’s ritual while their minds engage in a secret dialogue about the system’s corruption.


The theme of The Tension between Collaboration and Competition is explored through the divergent paths the characters take when faced with systemic pressure. Irene’s pragmatism leads her to entertain an alliance with Mateo and the Demien Order, weighing a forbidden source of power against the potential for survival. She approaches this moral crossroads with cold calculation, viewing the Demiens as a variable in her equation for victory. Emilio, conversely, steals the forbidden book because of his increasing desire to protect his friends and uncover the truth. In doing so, he asserts his growing sense of self-worth and usefulness within the group. August’s development presents a more complex internal struggle; his plea to Olivier, “Do not force me to become the villain” (333), reveals a self-awareness of his own moral erosion. He is willing to manipulate, threaten, and conceal truth to protect Wren, framing his compromises as a necessity dictated by love and loyalty. The narrative shows that, although the arching trajectory is in favor of collaboration, the characters struggle with and resist this in accordance with their individual personalities.


The theme of Memory as the Essence of Human Experience is developed by Maya’s inability to recall the eliminated nominees, marked by a “strange river of fog briefly clouding her irises” (343). This provides the first concrete evidence of a deliberate, large-scale memory wipe. This act of erasure is a form of institutional violence, as it not only eliminates individuals but negates any remnant of their existence across time. Silas’s final confession weaponizes this concept, revealing that his power is rooted in his ability to rewrite history through high-level psyche magic. This revelation forms a cliffhanger at the end of Part 5, calling for a reassessment of Blackwood’s moral framework, and the nature of the challenges that face the six nominees as they move forward.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock all 66 pages of this Study Guide

Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.

  • Grasp challenging concepts with clear, comprehensive explanations
  • Revisit key plot points and ideas without rereading the book
  • Share impressive insights in classes and book clubs