Island Beneath the Sea

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of racism and death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Allende weaves together personal stories with the sweeping historical events of the Haitian Revolution. How does this combination of intimate character development with epic historical scope compare to other historical novels you’ve read, such as Alex Haley’s Roots or Toni Morrison’s Beloved?

2. What aspects of the novel’s magical realism elements, such as Tété’s Voodoo practices and spiritual possessions, felt most compelling to you? Did these supernatural moments enhance or distract from the historical narrative?

3. Which character’s journey surprised you most as the story unfolded across decades and continents?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Tété’s quest for freedom spans decades and requires tremendous sacrifice and patience. When have you had to persist through long-term challenges to achieve something important to you? What kept you motivated during the most difficult moments?

2. Maurice’s unwavering opposition to enslavement puts him at odds with his father and society’s expectations. How do you navigate situations where your personal values conflict with family expectations or social norms? What factors influence whether you compromise or stand firm?

3. The novel explores different approaches to parenthood through Tété, Valmorain, and others. What qualities do you think define good parenting? How do the parent-child relationships in the novel reflect or challenge your own experiences with family dynamics? What lessons about responsibility and unconditional love emerge from these contrasting examples?

4. Tété ultimately chooses to forgive Valmorain rather than care for him in his old age, letting go of her hatred. Have you ever found that forgiveness was more beneficial for yourself than for the person you forgave? What makes forgiveness possible in situations involving deep hurt?

5. Throughout her journey, Tété adapts to new places while maintaining her core identity and beliefs. When you’ve faced major life transitions, what aspects of yourself have remained constant, and what have you allowed to evolve?

6. The relationship between Maurice and Rosette develops despite societal taboos and family opposition. How do you weigh love against practical considerations and social acceptance when making important relationship decisions?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The novel depicts how imbalanced power structures create cycles of violence and oppression in Saint-Domingue’s colonial society. Where do you see similar power imbalances creating harm in contemporary society? What can individuals do to address these systemic issues?

2. The Haitian Revolution was one of the most successful uprisings of enslaved people in history, yet it remains less well-known than other revolutions. Why do you think this historical event receives less attention in education and popular culture? How does learning about it through Tété’s perspective change your understanding of this period?

3. Characters like Dr. Parmentier and Père Antoine work within oppressive systems while trying to create positive change. What does their approach suggest about the possibilities and limitations of working for justice from within established institutions?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Allende alternates between Tété’s first-person chapters titled “Zarité” and third-person omniscient chapters following multiple characters. How does this dual narrative structure affect your connection to different characters? What unique insights does each perspective provide?

2. Dancing serves as a recurring symbol of freedom throughout the novel, from Honoré’s teachings to Tété’s ecstatic moment in Cuba. How does this motif evolve as Tété’s circumstances change? What other activities or symbols represent freedom in your own life?

3. Tété’s emancipation document transforms from a symbol of hope to a legal weapon she uses to secure her freedom. How does Allende use this physical object to illustrate the gap between promises and reality in the struggle for justice? What does the document’s journey reveal about the nature of freedom itself? Why do you think Allende chose to make this piece of paper so central to Tété’s story?

4. Valmorain begins as an idealistic young man but gradually compromises his principles to maintain his plantation lifestyle. What specific moments mark his moral decline?

5. The novel spans multiple locations, from Saint-Domingue to Cuba to Louisiana, showing how the characters adapt to different social and political environments. How do these geographic transitions mirror the characters’ internal journeys?

6. Voodoo practices appear throughout the novel, sometimes presented matter-of-factly as magical realism and other times as cultural traditions that bind communities together. How does Allende balance the spiritual and political aspects of these religious practices? What purpose do they serve in Tété’s journey toward freedom?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine you’re designing a museum exhibit about Tété’s life that uses objects to tell her story. What five items would you choose to represent different phases of her journey, and how would you display them to help visitors understand her experiences?

2. The novel ends with Tété at age 40, finally free but having lost many loved ones along the way. If you were to write an epilogue set 10 years later, what do you think Tété’s life would look like?

3. Several characters in the novel never get to tell their own stories directly, such as Honoré, Loula, or Tante Rose. Choose one of these secondary characters and imagine writing a chapter from their perspective about a key moment in the novel. What insights or memories would they share that might change how readers understand the main events?

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.