Island of the Blue Dolphins

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of gender discrimination and animal death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. What struck you most powerfully about Karana’s transformation from a village girl to a solitary survivor? How did her journey challenge or confirm your assumptions about human resilience and adaptability?

2. The novel draws from the true story of the Lone Woman of San Nicolas, who survived alone for 18 years in the 1800s. How did this historical foundation affect your reading experience? Does knowing the story has real roots make Karana’s achievements feel more or less believable?

3. Survival stories like Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe often focus on survivors conquering nature, while O’Dell shows Karana learning to live in harmony with her environment. What makes this approach to the survival genre distinctive, and which elements of her relationship with the island surprised you most?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Karana violates her people’s sacred laws by crafting weapons, knowing that survival demands this transgression. Have you ever found yourself choosing between following established rules and doing what you believed was necessary for your wellbeing or that of others?

2. Loneliness emerges as one of Karana’s most formidable enemies on the island. What strategies do you use to cope with isolation, and how do you maintain emotional connection when physical distance separates you from loved ones?

3. The friendship between Karana and Rontu transforms from deadly enmity to deep loyalty. What does their relationship reveal about your own capacity to forgive past hurts and find unexpected sources of companionship?

4. After years of hunting for survival, Karana decides to stop killing animals entirely once she befriends the otters. When have you experienced a fundamental shift in your values or practices because of new relationships or understanding?

5. Tutok’s brief friendship awakens Karana’s hunger for human conversation and shared laughter. How important is it for you to connect with people who share your cultural background versus finding understanding across differences of language, tradition, or experience?

6. Karana masters skills from weapon-making to house-building. What survival abilities do you possess, and what crucial knowledge do you feel you’re missing? If you had to become completely self-sufficient tomorrow, what would worry you most about the challenge?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The Aleut hunters’ exploitation of Karana’s people reflects broader patterns of colonization and resource extraction in 19th-century California. How do these historical injustices connect to contemporary discussions about Indigenous rights, environmental protection, and cultural preservation?

2. Karana’s village maintains strict gender roles that she must abandon to survive, yet her defiance brings her strength rather than the promised disasters. What parallels do you see between her struggle against these limitations and modern conversations about breaking down restrictive gender expectations?

3. The novel shows how the Aleuts’ overhunting devastates the island’s otter population, affecting the entire ecosystem. How does this environmental destruction from the 1800s illuminate current debates about sustainability, wildlife protection, and the long-term consequences of prioritizing short-term profits?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. O’Dell presents Karana’s story through her own mature voice, looking back on years of solitude. How does this retrospective narration shape your understanding of her experiences? What might we lose or gain if the story were told through a contemporary observer’s eyes?

2. Time becomes increasingly fluid for Karana as the seasons blur together and she stops marking days. What effect does this treatment of time create for readers, and how does it reflect her psychological journey from desperation to peaceful acceptance?

3. The island setting functions as more than just a backdrop, actively shaping Karana’s development through its challenges and gifts. Which aspects of the natural environment prove most crucial to her transformation, and how does she, in turn, leave her mark on the landscape?

4. Dolphins appear at pivotal moments throughout the novel as harbingers of hope and change. How does O’Dell use their symbolic appearances to create emotional resonance? What other elements of the natural world carry deeper meaning in Karana’s story?

5. Karana’s friendships with Rontu and Tutok teach her different lessons about trust and connection. What distinct wisdom does she gain from her animal companion versus her human friend, and why does she need experiences with each type of relationship?

6. The novel’s structure moves from community tragedy to solitary struggle to renewed hope for human connection. How does this arc reflect universal patterns of loss, adaptation, and recovery that extend beyond Karana’s unique circumstances?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine you’re creating a documentary about Karana’s years on the island. Which three scenes would you choose as the most visually compelling moments to film, and how would you help modern audiences understand the significance of each turning point in her journey?

2. If you could spend one season on the island as Karana’s companion, what modern knowledge or skills would you contribute to your shared survival? What traditional techniques and wisdom could you learn from her that might prove valuable in your regular life?

3. The novel concludes with Karana sailing toward an uncertain future at the mission, carrying both hope and the weight of leaving her island home. Design an alternative ending where she makes a different choice about her future, and explain what factors might influence her decision and how her story would continue to unfold.

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.