50 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of death, graphic violence, substance use, addiction, mental illness, emotional abuse, physical abuse, illness, and sexual content.
Brooke hesitates outside Abby’s bedroom door. Abby has abruptly returned after a month away. She casually greeted Brooke, who, feeling disheveled, used Julian spitting up as an excuse to run upstairs and clean up before facing her.
When she returned, Abby made tea, and they chatted. Abby then gently asked about the night Kiersten died. Brooke described pulling Kiersten from the pool while untangling her from a panicked Natasha. Abby offered support, and Brooke interpreted the moment as a tentative restart for their marriage. However, she does not want to push Abby for more too soon.
At a park, Jade meets Whitney with their children. Whitney reports that police are aware of the escort business, which it emerges Jade has been helping to run for the last six months. Panicked, Jade flashes back to a low point when Whitney found her sobbing in a parking lot of a thrift store after a credit card was declined. In that moment, Jade admitted that her family was broke and that Ryan could not hold a job. Whitney kept this a secret, cementing Jade’s faith in her.
Back in the present, Whitney says that she had to give the police the business files, which include Jade’s name. Whitney worries a client might be tied to Kiersten’s death, while a more vulnerable Jade fears the police will make her a scapegoat.
At home, Whitney thinks about Jade’s shock and recalls Jade telling her about her daughter Lily’s cancer diagnosis, which pushed Jade to join the escort business to fund treatment. Detective Perez calls and asks Whitney to identify a client named Allen Grigsby, whose real name is Dustin Miller. She texts a photo, and Whitney confirms the match.
Perez explains that Miller has a violent criminal record and that the police are investigating a potential connection to Kiersten. Whitney is horrified that her business may have led a dangerous man to her friend.
In a flashback, a frazzled Jade arrives at Whitney’s house with her children. Her babysitter canceled, and she must take Lily to her first cancer treatment. Whitney offers to watch baby Iris. When Jade rushes off, Whitney sees a way to solve Jade’s financial crisis by bringing her into the escort business. She weighs the risk of sharing her secret against the benefit of a partner.
Later, Jade returns with a distraught Lily. Their distress solidifies Whitney’s decision, and she tells Jade she has a plan to help.
Brooke attends Kiersten’s memorial service and feels numb. She notes that Tommy doesn’t give the eulogy, because he’s too upset. When Abby quietly sits beside her, Brooke takes it as a positive sign for their relationship.
After the service, Brooke looks for Abby and finds her with Taylor. Overhearing their conversation, Brooke hears Abby describe her as anxious and admit that she only came home to protect their son, Julian, from Brooke. Brooke hides what she heard and resolves to try harder to repair their marriage, even though she knows Abby suspects her of murdering Kiersten.
The next morning, Brooke wakes to an empty house. Abby has left with Julian and his essentials. Brooke calls and texts Abby and her mother but receives no response. She then phones a friend, crying that Abby kidnapped their son.
Abby soon returns alone. She tells Brooke that Julian is safe at Whitney’s and that she is looking for an apartment. Stating that Brooke is not safe for Julian to be around, she cites recent behavior, including a fight where Brooke shoved her. Brooke pleads for Julian’s return, but Abby refuses.
On a planned date night, Ryan shows Jade Brooke’s recent activity on Instagram. They watch Brooke’s frantic live videos, which accuse Abby of kidnapping Julian. Jade is shocked, while Ryan takes Abby’s side.
Jade texts Whitney, who confirms that Abby and Julian are with her and invites Jade over. Jade postpones her date night, telling Ryan that she needs to support her friends. As she leaves, she notes that Ryan has been more supportive since Kiersten’s death.
At Whitney’s, Abby struggles to feed a screaming Julian, who has rejected a bottle for hours. Whitney tries to help just as Jade arrives. Hearing what is happening, Jade suggests that since both she and Whitney are lactating, one of them can nurse him.
Whitney hesitates, but Jade volunteers. Desperate, Abby agrees. Julian immediately calms and latches. Stunned, the three women break into relieved laughter and decide to postpone any talk of the investigation.
In a flashback, Jade anxiously cleans her kitchen before her first escort client interview, worrying about the risks and the possibility of her husband finding out. She recalls the conversation where Whitney offered her a way to earn money, insisting that it was a job, not charity. Whitney laid out the secrecy rules: use a separate phone, guard client identities, and claim the house is a rental if asked. When the doorbell rings, Jade steadies herself.
Brooke sits in her car down the street from Whitney’s house, watching her friends and their husbands arrive. Feeling isolated, she looks at an unopened whiskey bottle in the back seat, finding it “comforting” to have.
She decides that everyone inside has taken Abby’s side and sees her as a murderer. She runs through her lack of motive—Kiersten was always kind to her—and feels Abby’s betrayal most of all. She concludes that if she did not kill Kiersten, then the person who did is among the friends gathered inside.
These chapters continue to scrutinize The Performance of Motherhood and Social Status, presenting motherhood as a series of social acts. Moreover, the characters’ self-conscious awareness of how they are perceived clarifies that this performance is at least partly calculated. Brooke manages her appearance before facing Abby, projecting an image of calm that she does not feel. Her internal monologue reveals a need to “be cool” and not “mess up this opportunity” (122), framing a potential reconciliation as a high-stakes performance; as she correctly recognizes, the failure to perform motherhood “correctly” could lead to the loss of her child. Jade breastfeeding Brooke’s son, Julian, literalizes the text’s presentation of motherhood. Described by Jade as feeling “exactly the same but different […] like dancing with someone else” (158), the gesture implies a construction of motherhood in which both mother and child are interchangeable; what matters is conforming to a certain role. As later events reveal, this is something at which Jade excels, and her actions in this scene foreshadow this ability to maintain a nurturing, maternal façade.
The act of wet-nursing is also an ironic performance of solidarity, enacted by women whose relationships are built on deceit and betrayal. The flashbacks underscore the theme of The Corrosive Power of Secrets in Friendships. The flashback to Whitney discovering Jade in a parking lot shows the ambivalent relationship between secrecy and intimacy. Whitney’s willingness to keep Jade’s admissions to herself secures Jade’s trust: “She kept my secret. She was really good at keeping secrets. It was why I trusted her when she told me nobody would ever find out about [the escort service]” (129). Jade’s inner monologue highlights the irony of her faith in Whitney: Someone who is “good at keeping secrets” could be keeping secrets from Jade as well. Secrecy thus gives the illusion of drawing people closer together while in reality opening the door to suspicion. Moreover, Jade’s remark about the escort service implies that sharing her secret with Whitney led to a later judgment on whether to get involved with a risky business proposition. Whitney sees her offer to bring Jade into her escort service as altruistic, yet the context makes it difficult for Jade to refuse, both because of her genuine gratitude to Whitney and because of the leverage Whitney now has over her. The flashback to Jade’s first client interview shows her internal struggle between anxiety and necessity. The latter wins out, in part because she fears the consequences of changing her mind: “What if [Whitney] got mad? I’d seen Whit mad before. She was vicious” (163). Regardless of whether Whitney would actually retaliate, Jade’s desire to keep her financial circumstances a secret gives Whitney the ammunition to do so.
Meanwhile, Brooke’s perspective allows for an examination of the subjectivity of truth, developing the theme of The Unreliability of Perception in a World of Deceit. Initially, she interprets Abby’s return home as a sign of potential reconciliation. This perception is brutally dismantled when she overhears Abby confessing her true motive to Taylor: “I have to pretend […] I’m not just there to make sure my kid is safe” (140). What Brooke perceived as kindness was in fact surveillance. For those around her, her subsequent emotional crisis, broadcast through frantic Instagram videos, becomes further evidence of her deteriorating mental health and probable guilt. However, the narrative allows the reader to see this crisis as a response to gaslighting and betrayal. Her perception is distorted principally by the constant deceit of those around her, although her actions toward Abby—stalking her, shoving her, etc.—complicate any reading of her simply as a victim. This balance forces the reader themselves to continually question objective reality.
The seizure of Brooke’s son, Julian, is a key turning point in her character arc. Stripped of her roles as wife and mother, Brooke is physically and emotionally exiled from the group, a process that culminates in her solitary vigil outside Whitney’s home. From this vantage point, she is no longer a participant but an observer, and her isolation sharpens her perception into a dangerous clarity. The unopened bottle of whiskey illustrates her proximity to a relapse. In the chapter’s closing lines, she recognizes that “the real villain sat among them” (165), transforming her from an object of the group’s suspicion into an active threat.



Unlock all 50 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.