Magnolia Parks

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of sexual content

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Magnolia and BJ’s relationship is described as both toxic and magnetic, challenging conventional ideas about healthy romance. What surprised you most about their dynamic?

2. The world of London socialites serves as the backdrop for this intense love story. In what ways did the setting of designer brands, luxury hotels, and constant media attention enhance or detract from your engagement with the characters?

3. Readers often draw parallels between Magnolia Parks and other works featuring tumultuous relationships among the ultra-wealthy, like E.L. James’s Fifty Shades series or Jenny Lee’s Anna K. Did this novel offer any fresh perspectives on the “toxic love” trope that you haven’t seen in other stories?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Do you have metaphors or shorthand expressions in your close relationships similar to Magnolia and BJ’s code of checking the weather?

2. The novel portrays Magnolia’s internal struggle between her passionate but problematic connection to BJ and her healthier but perhaps less intense relationship with Tom. When have you faced similar dilemmas in your own relationships?

3. Throughout the story, Magnolia wears BJ’s family ring on a necklace hidden beneath her clothes, symbolizing her inability to fully let go. What items have you kept from past relationships, and what did hanging onto them represent for you?

4. Betrayal shapes many of the relationships in the novel, from BJ’s infidelity to Marsaili’s affair with Magnolia’s father. Have you experienced similar breaches of trust? What did you think about how the characters processed their feelings of betrayal?

5. Bridget suggests that Magnolia’s need for male attention stems from her father’s emotional absence. How have your own family dynamics influenced your relationship patterns? Has this awareness changed how you approach connections with others?

6. Several characters derive their self-worth largely from how others perceive them. Social media has amplified this tendency in modern relationships, creating pressure to maintain a curated public image. Have you experienced similar pressures in your own life?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. Hastings offers us a glimpse into the world of London’s young socialites and their privileged lifestyle. What commentary do you think the author is making about wealth and celebrity culture through Magnolia’s story?

2. Why do you think fashion and material possessions hold such importance for Magnolia’s character? What does her obsession with designer brands suggest about status symbols in contemporary society?

3. Despite their extreme wealth and privilege, the characters face significant emotional challenges throughout the novel. Does the book succeed in making these wealthy characters relatable despite their privileged positions? What makes their struggles universal or specific to their social class?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Alternating between Magnolia and BJ’s first-person perspectives creates a dual narrative structure. What insights does this provide that a single perspective would miss? How does it shape your understanding of their relationship?

2. Magnolia’s middle name is Juliet, directly invoking Shakespeare’s tragic romantic heroine. What other parallels does the novel draw to Romeo and Juliet, and how does Hastings use or subvert these expectations?

3. Tom England serves as a foil to BJ throughout the story. What purpose does this contrast serve in developing the central romantic conflict? How does his maturity highlight aspects of both protagonists’ characters?

4. What does the symbol of the willow tree on Magnolia’s family property signify in the narrative? How does Hastings use the contrast between this natural setting and the urban, high-fashion world that dominates most of the novel to underscore the novel’s themes?

5. After discovering BJ’s betrayal with Paili, Magnolia heads to Heathrow Airport in the novel’s cliffhanger ending. What expectations does this conclusion satisfy or subvert? How does it prepare readers for a sequel?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. The story highlights specific locations like the Mandarin Oriental hotel and the willow tree by the lake. Where would you place the most pivotal moments of Magnolia and BJ’s relationship on a map? What would you add as the next important location in their story?

2. Imagine you’re Magnolia’s therapist after the events of the novel. How would you help her process her complex feelings about BJ? What advice would you offer about the patterns in her relationships?

3. BJ copes with emotional distress through destructive behaviors throughout the novel. Rewrite a key scene where he confronts his feelings in a healthier way. How might this alternative approach change the trajectory of his relationship with Magnolia?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources