Magpie Murders

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of illness or death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. The dual narrative structure of Magpie Murders creates two parallel mysteries that ultimately intertwine. Did this story-within-a-story approach enhance your reading experience, or did you prefer one narrative over the other? What aspects of each mystery did you find most compelling?

2. Horowitz draws heavily from the tradition of classic British mystery writers throughout this novel. Have you read other mysteries that play with the genre’s conventions, like Agatha Christie’s The Murder of Roger Ackroyd? What distinguishes Horowitz’s approach from these other metafictional mysteries?

3. Were you satisfied with how both mysteries were resolved? Did you feel the real-world solution to Alan Conway’s death was as carefully crafted as the fictional Atticus Pünd investigation?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Susan discovers that many people had reasons to want Alan Conway dead. When have you discovered that someone you knew had a side to them that completely changed your perception of who they were?

2. Dreams remain unrealized for many characters in the novel. In what ways have you had to compromise on dreams in your own life?

3. Throughout the novel, we see characters trapped in situations they never anticipated for themselves. Which character’s circumstances or disappointments did you find most relatable to your own experiences?

4. What was your reaction to Susan’s decision to leave publishing behind and move to Greece with Andreas? Have you ever made a dramatic life change that took you in an unexpected direction?

5. How have you had to become a “detective” in your own life to solve a problem or uncover a truth?

6. The book suggests that people cannot escape their pasts, no matter how they try. Do you believe this is true in real life? What experiences have shaped your perspective on whether people can truly start over?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. What does the novel reveal about the corruption that can exist beneath the surface of small, idyllic communities? How does this portrayal compare with other depictions of village life in literature or media?

2. Alan Conway was pressured to continue writing mystery novels despite his desire to write literary fiction. What does this conflict say about the publishing industry and the tension between commercial success and artistic fulfillment?

3. Mystery novels have enduring popularity despite often following predictable patterns. Why do you think we continue to be fascinated by stories about murder and deception? What social or psychological needs might they fulfill?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. How does Horowitz use architecture throughout the novel to reflect the personalities and emotional states of the characters?

2. What significance does the magpie hold as a symbol throughout the novel? How does this bird imagery connect to the themes of deception and trickery?

3. The novel employs various forms of wordplay, from anagrams to character names based on birds. How does this linguistic playfulness contribute to both the mystery elements and the novel’s larger themes? What message does Horowitz send about the relationship between language and truth?

4. In what ways does Susan Ryeland differ from traditional detective figures like Atticus Pünd? How do these differences speak to the evolution of the mystery genre itself?

5. Susan directly addresses readers about the unique relationship between detectives and readers in mystery novels. Do you agree with her assessment that “of all characters, the detective enjoys a particular, indeed a unique relationship with the reader” (324)? How did this self-awareness affect your experience?

6. Both narratives explore disappointment and unrealized dreams. Which characters best exemplify this theme, and how does their unfulfilled potential drive the plot forward?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Imagine you’re adapting Magpie Murders for television or film. What challenges would you anticipate in translating the dual narrative structure to screen? Which actors would you cast in the key roles?

2. If you were to write a sequel focusing on Susan’s new life in Greece, what type of mystery might she encounter? Would it maintain connections to the publishing world or explore entirely new territory?

3. The story ends with Susan starting a new chapter of her life in Greece. Create an alternative ending where she decides to take over Cloverleaf Books instead. How might her professional and personal life have unfolded differently?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources