My Favorite Half-Night Stand

Reid receives a message from Catherine, ending their correspondence. Shortly after, Millie calls, asking him to come to her townhouse to discuss their relationship.

When Reid arrives, he sees Millie’s bare shoulder and realizes that her scar, which he is so familiar with, is the same as Catherine’s scar in her profile picture. The scar, a specific typo, and a few references from her emails make him realize that Millie is Catherine. During their conversation, Reid gives her several opportunities to confess the truth to him.

Millie asks for a committed relationship but does not confess her secret. Needing honesty, Reid says he needs time to think and leaves. He immediately deletes the IRL app. Later, Reid goes to a bar to meet Ed, Alex, and Chris, and Ed and Alex confess that they knew about the deception and helped her. Feeling betrayed, Reid storms out.

The following night, convinced Reid knows her secret, Millie drives to Hendry’s Beach, a favorite thinking spot. She reflects on her history of emotional distance, her jealousy, and her ex-boyfriend, Dustin. She resolves to be honest with Reid.

Later, Millie goes to Reid’s house and confesses to being Catherine. Reid says he already knew and confronts her for not being truthful sooner.