49 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
On July 10, 1941, Jedwabne Mayor Marian Karolak coordinated the murder of the local Jewish citizenry. He called the Polish Gentiles to the town hall and “ordered them to round up the Jews to the square” (58). The Gestapo had also visited town, but no one can confirm if this visit occurred on the day of the massacre or the day before. The sole “town council member who left a deposition is Józef Sobuta, and his testimony is less than forthcoming” (58). The Germans gave municipal authorities eight hours to get rid of the Jews but insisted that “some Jewish craftsmen be kept alive” (173).
Gross wonders about what “specific role the Germans [played] in the implementation” (59) of the Jedwabne massacre. He also speculates about how many Germans were in town that day and what they did. The Germans were, after all, the “undisputed bosses over life and death in Jedwabne” (59). The Germans officiated over all “sustained organized activity” (59), usually by giving orders or expressing their consent. They were the only group of people who decided what happened with the Jews. They could have stopped the murders at any time but never chose to mediate.
On the day of the massacre “the German gendarmerie was the safest place in town for the Jews, and a few survived only because they happened to be there” (60). However, no Jews would have been murdered by their neighbors had the Germans not occupied the region. Nonetheless, German participation on July 10, 1941, amounted to nothing more than taking photographs.
Edward Sleszynski told Gross that many Jews burned in his father Bronislaw’s barn. Though he did not witness the murders himself, he learned from his Gentile neighbors how his Jewish neighbors were burned.
Julia Sokolowska, a cook for the gendarmes at the time, was another witness. During the investigation against Ramotowski, which was conducted on January 11, 1949, she testified that Polish residents of Jedwabne began to kill Jews alongside Germans just a few days after the invading army arrived. The Poles “killed over one and half thousand people of Jewish nationality,” according to Sokolowska, who emphasized that she never saw “any Germans beating the Jews” (61). Ironically, there were some Germans who protected “three Jewish women” by taking them to the gendarmerie, where Sokolowska provided them with something to eat. Sokolowska named 15 individuals as well as fathers and sons who participated in the slaughter.
During the trial, however, Sokolowska was “reluctant to speak on the witness stand” (63). Then she testified that “there were sixty gestapo men” on the day of the murders, which she knew because she had “cooked dinner for them” (63). There were also, she claimed, around the same number of gendarmes. This reveals that there were many Germans in Jedwabne on the day of the pogrom.
Sokolowska’s testimony is unique because most of those accused during the trial “had families and friends in the vicinity” (63) who could create internal pressure within the small community to prevent further testimonies.
Toward the end of the Nazi occupation, there was an active and “very strong Polish nationalist underground organization” (63) called the National Armed Forces (NSZ). Most of its members lived in the nearby forest. On September 29, 1948, “an armed detachment” from a group called “Wiarus” (64) overtook Jedwabne for a few hours. The inhabitants of Jedwabne feared these “boys from the forest” (64) as much as the Soviet secret police. Thus, this group may have had some influence on witnesses’ reluctance to testify.
Karl Bardón—the only defendant in the trial given a death sentence—appealed the verdict by the Lomza District Court. In the supplemental testimony that he attached to his appeal, he claimed that Sokolowska’s testimony about the presence of many Germans and gendarmes during the murders was false. Bardón recalled not seeing “any gestapo men or gendarmes” in “the square where Jews were assembled” (65). Bardón returned to the gendarme outpost where “a few civilians” ran into the courtyard and attempted to grab “three Jews who were chopping wood” (65). The commander there—a man named Adamy—emerged and scolded the mob for being greedy; eight hours was enough time “to do with the Jews as [they pleased]” (65). Thus, Bardón asserted, civilians conducted the murders—not the Gestapo—with the guidance of Mayor Karolak.
During the Ramotowski trial held in Lomza, nine of those accused “were found not guilty” (66). Even though numerous participants in the pogrom were mentioned by name, there were likely plenty of others assembled who remain anonymous. There were also, according to one defendant, people who arrived from nearby towns to watch the murders. Boleslaw Ramotowski noted that “it was very crowded” (66) on the day the Jews were chased into Sleszynski’s barn.
All 92 of the identified perpetrators were adult males and citizens of Jedwabne. Of the 2,500 people who lived in Jedwabne before World War II, Jews made up two-thirds of that population. There were around 450 male Poles of all ages. If this number is divided, that leads one to conclude that around half of all adult males in Jedwabne were identified as perpetrators of the pogrom, which “lasted an entire day” and took place in an area “no bigger than a sports stadium” (67). Sleszynksi’s barn “was but a stone’s throw of the square in the center of town” (68). Many of the assaults on Jewish citizens took place in the Jewish cemetery across the street.
On the day of the murders, all Polish men were called to the town hall. Mayor Marian Karolak and Józef Sobuta ordered the men to bring all the town’s Jews “to the square in front of the town hall” (69). One witness claimed that the Poles were served vodka, though no one else repeated this detail. Supposedly the Jews were to be gathered to perform a chore. They had been assembled before to do “cleanup jobs” (69). Several minutes after they gathered, the Gentiles (whom the Jews called “goyim”) began beating a young boy to death.
The Jewish community knew early on that it was in danger. Some fled into “neighboring fields, but only a few succeeded” (71), due to the difficulties of getting out of town undetected. More worryingly, there were bands of peasants “milling around trying to ferret out and catch hiding and fleeing Jews” (71).
Violence quickly overwhelmed Jedwabne. Jews were stoned and clubbed to death while their homes were pillaged. The kheyder teacher’s young daughter was beheaded, then her head was kicked around. A woman fainted from dehydration and “no one was allowed to help her” (72). The mob then killed her mother for trying to bring her water. Another woman was murdered while she held an infant.
The crowd decided to drive their victims to Sleszynksi’s barn because they realized they could kill 1,500 people more easily by burning them. This same method had been employed in Radzilów several days earlier. They initially tried to get local man Józef Chrzanowski to give them his barn, but he pled with the mob to spare his barn and they agreed, in exchange for his assistance with driving the Jews toward Sleszynski’s barn.
Józef Sobuta led the effort in organizing “a sideshow.” The victims were forced to perform various activities, including exercises. Sobuta demanded that the Jews scream “[w]ar is because of us, war is for us” (180). He and his colleagues also forced them to take down a statue of Vladimir Lenin, which stood near the town square. The Jews broke up the statue at command and carried its various pieces around on boards.
However, some Jews managed to escape, and some of those given preferential treatment refused it to remain in solidarity with their community. Michal Kuropatwa was spotted in the crowd of Jews and offered the opportunity to go home because he “had helped a Polish army officer hide from his Soviet pursuers” (75). Kuropatwa refused, choosing to remain with his people even as they faced death. Janek Neumark managed to escape from the burning barn. He wrestled an ax from a man who had barred him, his sister, and her five-year-old daughter from leaving the barn. The three then ran into the cemetery. From there, they watched flames consume the barn.
Most of the bodies were completely consumed by the fire. The barn was so crowded that those on the lower layer were probably “crushed and asphyxiated” (76) while those on the higher tier were incinerated. The bodies “were so intertwined with one another that [they] could not be disentangled” (76). Still, some Poles searched the bodies for valuable objects.
A man named Kobrzyniecki was rumored to have set the barn on fire and earned the reputation for being “[t]he worst murderer of the whole lot” (76). Kobrzyniecki killed 18 Jews on his own by stabbing them to death. He admitted as much one day to a homemaker while installing a stove in her apartment.
After the bodies were burned, Adamy, “the commander of the German gendarmerie in Jedwabne” (78), demanded that the Poles bury all of the bodies. He was afraid that, in the heat, the decomposing bodies could cause an epidemic. Moreover, stray dogs were sniffing around the corpses. Someone in the crowd had the idea of dismembering the corpses to make it easier to throw them into the ground. Thus, everyone brought pitchforks and set to work with tearing the bodies apart.
After July 10, the Poles no longer had permission to kill Jews without German consent. Those few who had survived the pogrom returned to town. Among them were several who worked at the gendarmerie. However, they were all later taken to a ghetto in Lomza. Around a dozen of those driven out survived after World War II.
Gross depicts how the German occupation created an atmosphere that enabled genocide, though no Nazi ever lifted a finger to murder a single Jew. Instead, they gave orders. The Germans cleverly used the favor they had curried with the Poles, who regarded the Nazis as their rescuers from Soviet rule, to get the town’s authorities, starting with Mayor Karolak, to organize a massacre. The Nazis expertly manipulated the Poles’ sympathies to prompt organized murder. The proliferation of underground nationalist organizations with antisemitic positions ensured that the community would be steadfast in its commitment to silence about the massacre. There was, after all, an ideological link between Polish nationalist organizations and Nazi invaders.
The Poles’ determination to eliminate their Jewish neighbors was apparent from their refusal to allow any Jews to escape during the pogrom. Though the Germans had a reputation for exacting efficient methods for carrying out their “final solution,” the Poles concocted their own methods for committing mass murder and relied on precedent in establishing the best means.
A few non-Jewish Poles were coerced into the murder frenzy. Józef Chrzanowski attempted to avoid participation in the violence when he pleaded with a crowd to spare his barn, only to end up conscripted in the effort to corral the town’s Jews. By complying, Chrzanowski avoided becoming another victim. This fear of victimization was not expressed by Jewish resident Michal Kuropatwa, for whom the mob tried to make an exception. His show of solidarity with his community contrasted with that of Chrzanowski because it was a moral choice, not an act performed out of desperation.
With the examples of Chrzanowski and Kuropatwa, Gross complicates our understanding of moral choice and elucidates how mortal fear influences people’s decision-making. Chrzanowski chose self-preservation, while Kuropatwa chose communal solidarity, sensing—quite rightly—that the Poles or Germans would eventually come for him later. Kuropatwa may have also worried that his acceptance of the Poles’ offer would weigh on his conscience.



Unlock all 49 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.