No Great Mischief

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of substance use, illness or death and animal death

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. MacLeod structures the novel around Alex’s visit to his alcoholic brother Calum, using this present-day frame to explore decades of family history. What similarities do you see between this technique and other family saga narratives like Anne Tyler’s Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant? How does this framing device shape your understanding of the MacDonald family’s story?

2. What significance does the recurring motif of ice hold throughout the novel? How does it transform from a physical threat to a symbolic representation of family tragedy and memory?

3. Which family member’s story resonated most powerfully with you, and what made their particular struggles or triumphs stand out?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Alex struggles to balance his successful modern life with his obligations to family members like Calum who’ve been left behind by progress. How do you navigate similar tensions between personal advancement and family loyalty in your own relationships? Do you find yourself torn between pursuing opportunities and maintaining family connections?

2. What role does storytelling play in your own family? The importance of preserving family stories emerges as a central concern for characters throughout the novel.

3. Language serves as both a bridge and barrier in the novel, with Gaelic representing deep cultural connections that younger generations struggle to maintain. Have you experienced similar challenges with preserving cultural or linguistic traditions in your family or community?

4. Where do you feel most authentically yourself? Calum’s decision to return home to die reflects his belief that geography shapes identity and belonging.

5. Reflecting on Alex’s relationship with his grandfather and other family influences, which relative or mentor has had the most profound impact on shaping who you’ve become?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. How do contemporary families maintain connections and cultural identity in our increasingly mobile society? The novel portrays the erosion of clann Chalum Ruaidh as industrialization and modernization scatter family members across vast distances.

2. MacLeod presents the mining camp as a microcosm of ethnic tensions and cultural preservation efforts. What parallels do you see between the MacDonald family’s experiences and current discussions about immigration, cultural assimilation, and maintaining heritage?

3. The contrast between Alex’s professional success and Calum’s marginalization reflects broader social changes that leave some people behind. How does modern society address the needs of individuals who struggle to adapt to rapid economic and cultural shifts?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. MacLeod employs a non-linear narrative structure, weaving between past and present as Alex walks through Toronto. How does this technique enhance your understanding of memory and its influence on identity?

2. How does the moon function both literally and symbolically throughout the narrative? The celestial body appears repeatedly as “lochran àigh nam bochd” (the lamp of the poor), watching over the family during crucial moments. What does its presence suggest about hope and guidance in the characters’ darkest hours?

3. What does this motif reveal about loyalty, survival, and the costs of caring “too much”? Dogs serve as a microcosm of the family’s experiences, from Calum Ruadh’s loyal companion to the tragic fate of Alex’s parents’ dog.

4. How does MacLeod use Calum’s transformation from confident young leader to broken alcoholic to illustrate broader themes of cultural displacement and historical change? This character arc forms the emotional core of the novel. What does his downfall reveal about the costs of carrying family burdens?

5. The sea functions as both provider and destroyer throughout the narrative, offering sustenance while claiming lives. How does this duality reflect the complex relationship between the MacDonald family and their environment?

6. Language barriers and misunderstandings contribute significantly to the novel’s climactic tragedy at the mining camp. How does MacLeod use communication failures to explore themes of cultural conflict and family betrayal?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. What artifacts, stories, and interactive elements would you include in a museum exhibit about clann Chalum Ruaidh’s journey from Scotland to Cape Breton? Imagine you’re designing this exhibit to help visitors understand the family’s cultural heritage and the challenges they faced. How would you make their experiences feel relevant to contemporary audiences?

2. Picture yourself as a member of clann Chalum Ruaidh working at the mining camp alongside Alex and Calum. What strategies would you develop to bridge the cultural divides between different ethnic groups and prevent the escalating tensions that lead to tragedy?

3. The novel ends with Alex driving Calum home through a terrible storm to Cape Breton, knowing his brother intends to die there. Write an alternative ending where Calum makes a different choice about his future.

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.