64 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide features depictions of bullying, anti-gay bias, sexual violence, rape, mental illness, disordered eating, suicidal ideation, sexual content, death, substance use, physical abuse, and emotional abuse.
The night of the beach fire seemed almost too perfect; yet nobody could have predicted that the following morning, one of the women would be a killer.
Eleanor is in the kitchen again, preparing blood oranges and watermelon for breakfast, slicing into the fruit and watching the blood-red juice run out as if she were attacking a body. Bella appears, and they eye one another suspiciously. When Bella starts taking food, Eleanor slaps her hand away, and Bella walks off in a huff.
Bella walks away disturbed by Eleanor’s behavior and angry at almost everyone. She decides that instead of confronting Fen about leaving without her last night, she will join Fen for a swim instead. Bella gets changed and looks at herself in the mirror, seeing a darkness in herself that won’t go away. Thinking back to the day she was discovered in the hospital after accidentally causing Sam’s death, she cries.
Everyone sits down for breakfast except Ana, who apparently went to call her son. Robyn can sense that something is off or that others know something she doesn’t, but she has no idea what it might be. Bella asks Lexi who’s watching Luca while Ana is gone, mentioning his father, and Lexi casually answers that Luca’s father isn’t around. Everyone looks forward to the beach fire later that evening.
Lexi finds Eleanor after breakfast and invites her out on the rowboat, just the two of them, in an effort to spend time with her before the trip is over. Eleanor refuses at first, but Lexi insists, and when Ana returns, it’s clear she’s nervous about the idea of Lexi and Eleanor going off alone together.
The rowboat began as a symbol of a perfect holiday but turned into a symbol of tears, panic, and danger instead.
Eleanor and Lexi push the boat onto the water and head out with Lexi doing the rowing and Eleanor unsure what to say or how to act. Lexi mentions a memory in which she went rowing with Bella and Robyn as teenagers, often for the sake of sneaking off to smoke and drink. Eleanor tries to pay attention to Lexi’s story, but suddenly blurts out a question: “Why did you invite me on this hen weekend?” (269). Lexi doesn’t understand the sudden inquisition, but she explains that she wanted to get to know her future sister-in-law. This answer satisfies Eleanor for now. Later on, Lexi asks Eleanor about Ed and whether she thinks Ed will be happy as a father and husband. Eleanor believes that Ed genuinely will be, but she admits that he didn’t get along well with Sam. Eleanor thinks back to the day Sam died, and how she held his hand one last time in the morgue. She doesn’t say any of this aloud, because she feels like discussing death is pointless.
Bella finds Fen reading on the bed. She tries to keep the conversation light, but it inevitably leads into a conversation about the night before. Fen admits that she ran into a man she had bad memories with, but she doesn’t explain any further. Bella tries to reach for Fen’s hand, but she pulls away, and Bella can tell that Fen is drifting away. She asks if Fen is breaking up with her, and Fen admits that she is; Bella sobs and runs from the room, sure that it’s her fault the relationship is ending.
Robyn feels great as she goes for a hike on her own. She gets a call from home, and when she answers, she hears Jack on the other line. He tells her about his treasure hunt and finding chocolate treasure, and Robyn realizes how much she misses him. When Robyn’s mother picks up the phone, she sounds curt and challenges Robyn’s decision to get a divorce. Robyn doesn’t want to discuss it and insists outright that she never loved her husband, and her mother tries to argue that as well. She also demands that Robyn thank her for watching Jack and lectures her when Robyn tries to say that she wants more adventure in her life. When Robyn’s mother asks her if she hit her head, it brings Robyn back to a memory from when she was eighteen. Robyn’s mother saw her lying in bed with Bella, and because Robyn had been injured the night before, her mother blamed what she saw on brain trauma. Robyn swears at her mother and hangs up.
Lexi finds Robyn crying, and Robyn reveals that she just swore at her mother. Lexi commends Robyn for standing up for herself, and Robyn admits she wants more adventure and friendship in her life. Lexi affirms Robyn’s need for more time to herself and explains that she started yoga because it was all about focusing on self-care. Lexi adds that performing for others is overrated, and that satisfying one’s own needs and standards is all that really matters. When Bella joins moments later, Lexi thinks about why she never told Bella that the chaotic life they lived didn’t make her happy. She worries about Bella. Bella admits that she and Fen broke up, but doesn’t want to discuss it, instead putting her attention on making the last night special. Bella goes for a swim, but not before commenting on how “creepy” she finds Eleanor.
The last night at the beach fire had some wonderful moments, but these were overshadowed by conflict, pain, and a dire emergency.
Eleanor and Lexi share a quiet but emotionally weighted moment out on the rowboat, where Eleanor reflects on Sam’s death, acknowledging that she will never truly open up to anyone about it. This is an indication of her deep isolation. Robyn’s relationship with her mother is revealed to be strained and emotionally loaded, full of veiled insults and judgment. Her mother’s anti-gay attitude led to years of shame and denial for Robyn and led Robyn to deny her feelings for Bella, causing hurt and confusion. Her mother expects gratitude for watching Jack, questions the divorce, and subtly undermines Robyn’s confidence.
The interludes offer subtle but increasingly clear foreshadowing of the major conflict to come, especially surrounding the beach fire: “one of us would kill” (247). The line directly foreshadows the eruption of violence when Eleanor kills Ed. The tone begins to shift, growing more ominous and charged with tension as the narrative prepares for a critical turning point. Secrets continue to rise to the surface; Ana’s hidden past is closer to being revealed, and Eleanor is visibly beginning to unravel under the weight of her grief. Similarly, Bella can start to see her guilt physically eating away at her. Meanwhile, Lexi and Robyn have a heartfelt discussion about autonomy and societal expectations. Lexi says, “Maybe we all need to stop trying to meet everyone else’s expectations—and just meet our own” (289), emphasizing The Pressure of Patriarchal Gender Norms that each woman deals with.
The imagery of Eleanor cutting a watermelon in the opening scene is deliberately visceral, with descriptions that resemble cutting into a body, subtly foreshadowing the violence to come. The rowboat, once a symbol of Greek holiday charm, now evokes memories of panic, grief, and emotional volatility, becoming a metaphor for the friend group itself, in which a veneer of perfection masks darker truths. The narrative builds in suspense, hinting toward several upcoming confrontations. As secrets are revealed and relationships deteriorate, the power of Secrets as Bond and Solvent, cementing or breaking relationships, becomes clear. The breakup between Fen and Bella adds another layer of emotional drama and instability, pushing the group further toward crisis.



Unlock all 64 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.