51 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of child death, illness, and rape.
Sara takes Hosea to his doctor’s appointment. On the way home, he expresses to her that he’s made his peace with his death, and she begins to try to accept it as well. When they get home, Jacob has arrived. Sara realizes that Hosea has crafted a special greeting for him, as Hosea has done with all his family members. After Alana and Jacob are settled at the kitchen table, Sylvia keeps entering and exiting the room. When Sara asks her why, she explains in private that she’s demonstrating Jacob’s genuine politeness—he stood every time she entered the room. Sylvia uses this experiment to argue that Sara needs to move beyond her past and begin to trust Jacob. Sylvia also points out that Jacob is an attractive man, which Sara balks at with humor.
Jacob goes to the doctor to receive a second injection of growth hormone to stimulate his bone marrow. He’s aware of the potential flu-like side effects, but the first injection didn’t result in any. He arrives at his tutoring session with Alana, and she asks about her grandmother. He tells Alana that Birdie likes to garden, which leads to Alana asking Sara if they can start a garden.
A little later, Sara and Jacob sit together and talk while Alana cleans up before dinner. Sara explains that she developed ways to say no to Alana regarding things that could lead to Alana’s discovery, but it’s become a habit that she would like to change. Jacob encourages Sara to tell Alana the whole truth about his family when she’s ready. Sara thanks him for his relationship with Alana and for not being angry with Sara for keeping Alana a secret. Sara invites him to stay for family pizza night, and he eagerly accepts.
Jacob comes to pizza night and slowly warms to the easy intimacy of the Lancasters working together to make dinner, sharing stories, and working through philosophical questions. He tells them about the island he lives on and suggests taking the family to a private beach he knows nearby. After dinner, Alana and Sara invite Jacob to movie night the next day, but when he gets home, he falls into bed, exhausted.
Jacob doesn’t show up for movie night or his next tutoring session with Alana. Initially, Sara is angry, but after she attempts to reach Jacob and can’t, she gets worried. She goes to his address and finds his friend Locke, who takes her on his boat to Jacob’s island. Jacob is sick from the side effects of the hormone injection. He has a high fever and can’t stay awake. He tells her, in his delirium, that he’s been preparing for a bone marrow transplant for Daniel. Sara and Locke try to convince him to go to the hospital, but he refuses. Sara finds his doctor’s phone number, and the doctor tells her to make sure he stays hydrated, eats, and takes Tylenol for the fever.
She cobbles together the ingredients for beef stew, calls Sylvia, and stays to care for Jacob. She finds a photograph of the Wyler family before Naomi died and recognizes how Jacob and his family have also been torn apart by Daniel’s actions. When Jacob wakes up, recovered from his fever, they share the stew and sit on the porch in the night air. They talk about family and Jacob’s long estrangement from Daniel. He tells her about Daniel’s cancer, and she tells him that she had already figured that out.
Jacob and Sara sit on the porch until late into the night, talking and looking at the stars through Jacob’s telescope. The next morning, they watch the sunrise together, and Sara tells him about Lubec, Maine. He asks if she’ll leave Savannah and go back, and she’s noncommittal, saying that Alana has needs that Georgia is meeting. She hugs Jacob goodbye as Locke pulls up to take her home, and Jacob wishes that he could stay in that moment for longer.
Jacob travels to Atlanta to see the doctor with Birdie. On the way to Atlanta, she made calls, and then they talked about gardening. The doctor tells them that Daniel’s infection is too severe to move forward with the transplant at the moment and that they’ll resume the medication for the transplant when Daniel recovers. On the drive home, Birdie figures out that Jacob is beginning a relationship with someone. A song on the radio reminds them both of Naomi, and they talk about her, sharing memories. Birdie returns to her suspicion about Jacob’s love life and suggests that she set him up with someone. Jacob argues with her, but then she switches her approach and says that he could “uncomplicate” his love life. She tells him about the challenges that she, a Black woman, had with her relationship with his father, a rich white man, in Georgia.
Sara, Alana, and Jacob work together to construct the garden. They travel outside of Savannah to get supplies in Jacob’s truck. At the nursery, Alana approaches a stranger to tell her about a plant, breaking Sara’s rules for behavior in public. Jacob calmly explains the reason behind the rules, and Alana apologizes, embracing her mother. Sara is struck by Jacob’s ability to work with Alana. When Sara asks him later how he knew how to talk to Alana at that moment, he tells her about Naomi. Sara tells Jacob about coming to love Alana slowly after her birth. Jacob tells Sara that he had a vision of Naomi in Alaska and that he still talks to her sometimes. Sara shares that learning about Jacob and Naomi is helping her understand Alana more fully.
Harris continues to explore The Complex Nature of Forgiveness in these chapters through Sara’s internal conflict, experience with motherhood, and growing attraction to Jacob. In Chapter 16, Sara says that she thinks of everyone else first because “[she’s] a mother. It’s what [mothers] do. What any mother would do” (251), which summarizes Harris’s exploration of the nature of motherhood in the novel. Part of Sylvia’s role in the novel, however, is as a catalyst pushing Sara to look at the future in a new way. Specifically, Sylvia encourages Sara to imagine a future in Savannah, slowly convincing her that Alana will flourish in the social and intellectual world they’re creating for her there. To do so, Sylvia understands that Sara will have to come to terms with residing in a location that holds significant trauma for her due to Daniel’s violent actions. She also suggests that Sara start to see Jacob in a more tolerant light as an individual and an attractive man who’s good with her daughter, rather than the brother of her rapist. That push drives Sara to consider Jacob differently when they’re alone together on his island. Her interest in him begins to grow in direct response to Sylvia’s pushing. Birdie, though she has no idea that Jacob’s new love interest is Sara, similarly pushes Jacob to view his love life as a space that can be a series of solutions rather than problems, especially as he grapples with his ability to show compassion to his brother due to his crime. Birdie and Sylvia, despite being a cold mother and a surrogate mother, respectively, provide the characters with advice that they believe will usher Jacob and Sara toward a healthier future.
As the internal and external tension created by the secret of Alana’s existence rises, Jacob and Sara become closer. Jacob’s reaction to the drug preparing him to donate bone marrow to Daniel pulls Sara to Jacob’s island; for the first time in the novel, they talk about each other and their experiences instead of Daniel, the rape, and their families. Instead, they share their passions: Jacob’s work on space and Sara’s poetry. Considering one another as individuals apart from the complexity of their families and outside the lens of The Impact of Sexual Violence that previously framed their interactions allows them to see each other from a different perspective. The shifting point of view further establishes their growing attraction, showing that both of them feel the same way, while neither is ready to express that openly.
In this section, Harris also further develops The Shifting Definition of Family through Sara’s and Alana’s interactions with Jacob and, by extension, the Wyler family. The author emphasizes the connection between Naomi and Alana in the middle of the novel: “Alana talks to strangers. Naomi talked to strangers. Alana loves math. Naomi loved math. Now I know where she gets it from. I look at her and see him. You look at her and see Naomi” (274). The comparison initially drew Jacob to Alana and made it easy for him to connect to and love his niece. Here, however, that connection allows Sara to view the Wyler family through a wider lens. Rather than seeing her rapist in her daughter, and, by extension, in Jacob, she is beginning to see Wyler family traits through a more sympathetic eye. Alana’s similarities to Naomi offer Jacob a second chance at nurturing a girl like his sister, and they offer Sara a new avenue of connection to Alana’s extended family. While Sara initially desired to avoid the Wyler family at all costs and shield Alana from them, her perspective is beginning to change due to her positive interactions with Jacob.



Unlock all 51 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.