50 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of illness, death, and suicide.
When it’s time for Charlie to accept his induction, he does so with grace and an uncharacteristic level of lucidity. Watching the livestream at home, Chelsea and her mom are overcome with emotion because they see the Charlie they know and love, not the man who’s been slowly slipping away from them. Simultaneously at the event, Marcus and McTavish cheer for Charlie. When the portable stage is rolled away, they realize Charlie is gone. Frantically, they search the field, finding Charlie exiting through a tunnel under the bleachers. By the time they catch up, Charlie is gone again, and they ask around until a woman tells them he got arrested by campus police for trying to climb a statue.
At the campus security center, Charlie is fine, and Marcus comes face-to-face with the cop from back home. Marcus takes full responsibility for the incident, admitting to McTavish that Charlie’s family didn’t want him to attend the ceremony. McTavish doesn’t understand why Charlie’s loved ones would deprive him of this experience. The cop doesn’t know why—only that it’s what the family wanted. He’ll drive Charlie home in his police cruiser. McTavish says they’ll follow, telling Charlie the day’s over, to which Marcus thinks “truer words had never been spoken” (210).
Chelsea attends her first football game in a year, where she sees Troy desperately scanning the audience for his parents. Chelsea explains where Charlie is and what Marcus did. Troy is furious, but after seeing her dad at the ceremony, Chelsea knows Marcus did the right thing. When one of Troy’s teammates comes to get him, Troy throws a punch straight into the guy’s helmet. Though there’s no evidence of injury, Troy is certain that his hand is broken. In a quiet, terrified voice, he tells his coach he can’t play.
On the road driving back, Marcus apologizes to McTavish for the thousandth time, and McTavish tells him to stop because the risks of the day are well justified by what the experience did for Charlie in the moment. Suddenly, the cop pulls over, signaling for McTavish to join him. He got a message on the radio that Troy is out of the game and the team needs Marcus to play quarterback. Marcus struggles to reconcile the cop helping him get back for a football game after Marcus kidnapped Charlie.
In town, Charlie makes a comment when they speed by the exterminator’s store. The cop realizes that Marcus has been covering for Charlie this entire time because Marcus didn’t want word of Charlie’s illness to get out. Since there’s no keeping it a secret after today, the cop implores Marcus to tell the truth at his hearing. Marcus will think about it, and the cop is impressed with Marcus’s dedication, even though he thinks Marcus is “some weird, loyal, stupid piece of work” (220).
Marcus arrives at the field, where a mob yanks him from the police car and suits him up before shoving him toward the game. Troy intercepts him, whacking his chin guard with an icepack. At once, Marcus realizes Troy’s hand isn’t broken, but he doesn’t have time to figure out what’s going on. After telling Troy that Charlie is fine, Marcus enters the game and helps tighten the score, bringing his team to a three-point lead. In the last seconds, Marcus makes a dive for the ball but is hit by a linebacker. As Marcus drops, he feels “a violent motion deep inside his skull” and then passes out (226).
Marcus groggily wakes to Alyssa kissing him. Though he’s conscious, there’s a ringing in his ears, and his knees feel like pudding. Despite this, he’s pronounced fit to play. Before Marcus can return to the game, Troy steps in to finish the game. He warns Marcus to sit down because “you don’t want to end up like him” (229). Troy’s newfound willingness to mention his dad’s condition in public makes Marcus take his situation seriously. He benches himself.
Troy plays a very toned-down game, but he still helps his team to keep their winning score. The following week, Troy quits the team, and Marcus becomes starting quarterback. While he knows why Troy quit, Marcus will never understand it because he loves the rush of the game too much to give it up. On his way back from Three Alarm Park one afternoon, Marcus encounters the exterminator. The man knows the truth about Charlie and apologizes for being such a jerk. He gives Marcus an old picture of the store’s former owner that features the teenaged Charlie and McTavish in the background.
Marcus brings the picture to Charlie’s house, where he chats with Chelsea. She’s still mad Marcus took Charlie to the induction ceremony without permission, but she truly believes it was the right thing to do. Talking to her, Marcus isn’t sure he agrees because “the moment of triumph had been so fleeting compared with the grim reality of what was in store for Charlie” (239). Charlie’s family asks Marcus to accompany them for a visit to a nursing home. The place is full of people much older than Charlie, some of whom don’t respond at all when talked to. When Charlie realizes his family wants him to live there, he becomes lucid and terrified, looking to Marcus for support. Marcus can’t bring himself to lie to Charlie anymore and agrees with the family.
By the last football game of the season, Marcus has led his team through a string of victories. Though Troy doesn’t play anymore, he comes to games with Charlie, and his presence reminds Marcus uncomfortably of the nursing home. Ever since the visit, Charlie has been subdued, as if he senses that something bad is coming. As Marcus prepares to throw the winning touchdown, he notices Charlie climbing the bleacher stairs, heading for the narrow top platform, about four stories above the ground, where a hawk is perched.
At once, Marcus realizes that Charlie thinks this is the hawk mascot he released years ago. Instead of making the throw, Marcus drops the ball and runs after Charlie. When Charlie steps on to the top ledge, Marcus yells for him to stop. Charlie looks back at him, seeming lucid. As Charlie reaches for the bird, Marcus closes his eyes, and “when he opened them again, Charlie Popovich was gone” (249).
Many people turn out for Charlie’s funeral. The eulogy is full of words like “charismatic” and “quirky,” but there’s no mention of Charlie’s illness. The entire time, all Marcus can picture is the moment he realized Charlie had fallen, followed by finding Charlie’s body in the parking lot. After the service, Marcus goes to the reception at Charlie’s house, where he’s unsurprised but still a bit sad to see Alyssa back with Troy. Though she doesn’t owe him an explanation, Alyssa tells Marcus that she understands Troy pushed her away because of Charlie and that she and Troy need each other. Marcus understands and leaves them alone.
Outside, Marcus listens to former NFL players and McTavish swapping stories about Charlie. McTavish explains that he thinks Charlie was caught up in the past trying to get to the hawk, but Marcus doesn’t think so. He remembers the look in Charlie’s eyes before he fell: “clear and lucid and knowing” (256). The memory of the moment overwhelms Marcus, and he decides he needs to leave. Before he can, he finds Troy watching an old NFL game Charlie played in. Marcus joins him and is amazed by Charlie’s boundless energy and clear love for the sport. After shaking Troy’s hand, Charlie goes to Three Alarm Park, which feels like a fitting place for him to be on the day of Charlie’s funeral.
While much of Pop focuses on Charlie’s rapid mental decline, this last section shows how moments of lucidity make the progression of diseases like CTE so difficult to measure. At the induction ceremony in Chapter 22, it is clear to Marcus, McTavish, and Charlie’s family that Charlie is fully himself during his speech. This moment—back in a familiar place of which Charlie has fond memories—is powerful enough to break through the confusion Charlie experiences, allowing him to be present and aware in a way he normally isn’t. Though Charlie seems to forget the ceremony immediately after, the significance of this moment is imprinted on his mind as a notion of who he is and what’s important to him, illustrating How Legacy Shapes Identity.
The ceremony also shows that, in some ways, Marcus understands Charlie better than Charlie’s family does. This discrepancy illustrates the negative aspect of Caregiving as a Crucible of Empathy. While the rigors of caregiving can forge empathy, they can also destroy it. Charlie’s family has become so exhausted by the pressure of caring for him and the grief of watching his decline that they can no longer recognize his emotional needs. Marcus’s decision to bring Charlie to the ceremony without his family’s permission is wrong, but Charlie’s family acknowledges afterwards that letting Charlie have this moment was the right thing to do. When Chelsea and Troy realize the favor Marcus has done for Charlie here, the kids are able to start working past their issues to come together around their love for Charlie.
Charlie’s demonstration of lucidity at the nursing home informs Marcus’s understanding of his death. When Charlie realizes the nursing home will be his new home, something in him changes, as shown by his subdued nature afterwards. Though Charlie doesn’t remember visiting the nursing home or even that he’s on the waiting list for the place, Marcus believes that he has internalized the reduced quality of life he can look forward to. The calm awareness on Charlie’s face as he reaches for the hawk in Chapter 27 suggests to Marcus that Charlie has chosen to risk his life for this final taste of glory. His choice to go after the bird, knowing he will likely die, is Charlie’s way of taking control of his life. The bird is a living symbol of How Legacy Shapes Identity: It embodies Charlie’s most hopeful image of himself. Though Marcus has no way to know what Charlie was really thinking in his final moments, he takes comfort in the idea that Charlie died knowing who he was.
Marcus’s injury in Chapter 25 is the final hurdle in his relationship with Troy, as well as the moment Marcus must experience in order to choose football. Though Marcus knows something is wrong, he refuses to acknowledge it because he’s finally playing quarterback and doesn’t want to let his team down. More broadly, Marcus’s situation here highlights the toxic culture of football in this town, where coaches and officials are willing to let a child risk lifelong injury for the sake of entertainment. Though Troy is terrified of getting hurt, he takes on the caretaking responsibility that the adults on the field have abdicated: He volunteers to play because he sees what Marcus can’t—that Marcus is not fit to play and that additional hits in his condition could do permanent damage. Troy’s mention of Charlie allows Marcus to accept the situation because he knows what it costs Troy to do so. This also shows the respect Marcus has for Charlie. Marcus doesn’t want to appear weak, but he also knows that intentionally putting himself in danger could ruin his chance at playing future games. By taking himself out of play, Marcus acknowledges the harm football brought to Charlie. However, by continuing to play on the team, Marcus also decides that doing what he loves is worth the risk. By contrast, Troy’s decision to quit shows that he can’t love the game like he once did because of what it’s taken from him.
Chapter 28 brings resolves the conflict between Marcus and Troy’s relationship and highlights the effect Charlie had on the two boys and the town more broadly. Though Marcus and Troy aren’t teammates anymore, the boys are now friends, united by Charlie’s love of football and how the sport changed him. Alyssa gets back together with Troy, their healed relationship symbolizing the power of releasing secrets. Without the strife of keeping his anger bottled up, Troy starts to become his former self again, and he returns to the things he’s left behind, such as positive relationships with his family and Alyssa. Marcus’s inability to listen to old football stories about Charlie shows how deeply watching Charlie’s death affected Marcus. While Troy quit the game in honor of his father, Marcus decides to continue playing for the same reason, but this does not mean Marcus is the same person he was at the beginning of the book. Charlie awakened a love of physical exertion in Marcus, but as a result, Marcus also internalized the importance of taking responsibility for himself first. He shows this by no longer covering for Charlie in his legal battle and by making up with the exterminator. Marcus ends the book back at Three Alarm Park in a final tribute to Charlie, since that’s where the two first met. This also symbolizes how Marcus won’t let what happened to Charlie stop him, even as Marcus acknowledges the potential danger of continuing to play football.



Unlock all 50 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.