Razorblade Tears

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of antigay bias, racism, graphic violence, substance use, and death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. The novel opens with Ike and Buddy Lee struggling to accept their sons’ orientation, yet by the end, they’re fighting to avenge them. What did you think about this journey from intolerance to understanding?

2. Have you read other works by Cosby, like Blacktop Wasteland or All the Sinners Bleed? If so, do you notice recurring themes or stylistic elements across his Southern noir fiction? If not, do you intend to read more?

3. Cosby titled his novel after Ike’s grief, described as tears that feel “like razorblades.” What impact did this visceral imagery have on your reading experience?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Ike and Buddy Lee both regret how they treated their sons when they were alive. Can you recall a situation where you wished you had acted differently in a relationship but didn’t get the chance to make amends?

2. The novel portrays both fathers as relying on violence despite trying to leave that life behind. Are there behaviors or tendencies you find hard to abandon when faced with extreme circumstances?

3. Buddy Lee describes himself as “a hell-raising, whiskey-drinking, hard-loving redneck” who isn’t ashamed of who he is (270). Which aspects of your identity do you embrace unapologetically?

4. Tex quotes Martin Luther King Jr.’s famous remark in “Letter From Birmingham Jail” that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere” (87). Do you agree with this principle? Why or why not?

5. Ike realizes that Isiah shared his relationship news because he wanted his father to know about his happiness. Have you ever shared your joy with someone who wasn’t initially supportive? How did the experience impact you?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The barbershop scene portrays a space where Black men can “be themselves,” yet it also reveals antigay bias. What other social spaces can serve as both safe havens and sites of exclusion?

2. Cosby writes about the intersection of racism and antigay bias through his characters. What insights does the novel offer about overlapping prejudices in contemporary American society?

3. Tex tells Ike that growing up Black and gay was difficult to navigate. In what ways does the novel remind you of stories like Richard Wright’s Native Son in its exploration of societal traps and impossible choices?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Cosby describes rage as something that “could turn against you and slit your own throat” (125). What role does this personification of violence play in developing the novel’s themes?

2. In what ways does Buddy Lee function as a foil to Ike throughout the narrative?

3. The novel alternates between violent action sequences and quieter moments of reflection. What effect does this pacing have on character development and reader engagement?

4. What role do symbols like Buddy Lee’s knife, Ike’s tattoo, and the transformation of tears from razorblades to rain play in the novel’s exploration of redemption?

5. Cosby writes within the tradition of hardboiled crime fiction yet introduces characters and themes not typically found in the genre. Where does Razorblade Tears adhere to noir conventions, and where does it break new ground?

6. Arianna functions as a symbol of second chances. What might her character represent for the future beyond the novel’s conclusion?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. If Razorblade Tears were adapted into a film, which actors would you cast as Ike and Buddy Lee? What scenes would be most challenging to portray effectively on screen, and why?

2. Imagine an epilogue set five years after the novel’s conclusion. What might Ike’s relationship with Arianna look like by then?

3. Create an alternative ending where both Ike and Buddy Lee survive their final confrontation. How might their relationship evolve, and what kind of grandfathers might they become?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources