65 pages • 2-hour read
Janet MockA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Vulnerability plays an important role within the narrative. Throughout the memoir, Mock is vulnerable for a variety of reasons: her burgeoning trans identity, her positionality as a person of color, and her parents’ lack of financial stability, to name a few. As a child, this vulnerability makes her an easier target for Derek, who capitalizes on these vulnerabilities in order to sexually abuse her. Mock remembers, “My inclinations made me all the more vulnerable to him, and my vulnerabilities made me easy prey” (43). Mock attributes much of her vulnerability to her identity as trans, which she does not necessarily understand as a child. Her burgeoning trans identity, unlike her racial identity and her economic status, make her different from other people; as such, she becomes an easy target for Derek’s predatory behavior:
Being or feeling different […] can result in social isolation and exclusion, which in turn leads to a child being more vulnerable to the instigation and continuation of abuse. Abusers often take advantage of a child’s uncertainties and insecurities about their identity and body (47).
Although Mock never explicitly says this, her early sexual abuse seems to have paved the way for her later sex work. It can be assumed, therefore, that many of the other girls on Merchant Street had a history of sexual abuse, as this is quite common with sex workers, especially those who have identities marginalized by society. Mock seems to link her trans identity implicitly with vulnerability, which she also conflates with isolation. This isolated vulnerability also plays off of a sense of shame that comes with being marginalized in society, which further leads her down a path of lower self-esteem, rendering her even more vulnerable to predatory male figures. Mock thereby seems to associate vulnerability with predation and creates a hardened exterior shell to protect herself from being a victim at the hands of other people.
This decision to protect herself leads Mock to shy away from exposing her vulnerabilities. As a result of her heightened vulnerability as a child and the sexual abuse that she sees as resultant from that vulnerability, Mock avoids emotional intimacy, especially regarding the intimacy that emerges as a result of disclosure. When speaking about her public disclosure, Mock states:
I was not ready for the vulnerability that comes with public openness when I spoke to Keirna at age twenty-seven. During our conversations, I withheld parts of myself and details from my journey (partly because I was unpacking my own shame; partly because I needed to save those details for my own story). As a result, the girl in the piece seemed untouchable, unscathed, a bit of an anomaly (xiv).
She has spent so much of her life protecting herself from her vulnerability that she feels isolated not only from other people, but from herself. Similarly, Mock realizes after telling parts of her story to Keirna that vulnerability is necessary to feel a sense of belonging among other people. More than anything, Mock wants to feel as though she belongs because she has spent so much of her life feeling like she does not belong. However, her hardened exterior—created due to her fear of rejection—prevents her from belonging as it isolates her from other people. Paradoxically, this isolation renders Mock more vulnerable, as she does not have a community to fall back on. In order to break this cycle of isolation, Mock realizes that she has to make herself publicly vulnerable, thus leading to her memoir.
Throughout the narrative, Mock capitalizes on the importance of words in terms of understanding her identity. She reflects on the power of words: “Words have the power to encourage and inspire but also to demean and dehumanize” (31). Mock demonstrates how words are powerful, but also how they can be used both positively or negatively, depending upon the context and intent. Words have a much larger psychological effect beyond their mere presence on the page. Throughout the narrative, Mock attempts to capitalize on this power in order to encourage and inspire her readers—cis and trans alike—to live their truths.
Although Mock’s narrative has a resoundingly positive message about self-identity and acceptance, she is quick to note that she has felt the negative effects of words throughout her life as well. Mock speaks to the ways that words have been used to denigrate her: “Sissy’s presence in my life helped numb me early on to harsher words that would soon be hurled at my body, from freak and faggot to nigger and tranny” (31). Even as a child, words were used to marginalize Mock. These words often implied violence against her body and/or identity, as discriminatory and biased words often do. The greater social context of these words lends them their power, leaving traumatic psychological effects on people who these words are used against. In essence, these discriminatory words are used to marginalize other people, to render them as Other to validate violence used against these bodies. Of course, this violence is not validated, and Mock uses her own words in order to counteract this discrimination. In many ways, her memoir serves as a reaction against these words—and the negative societal infrastructures they belie—that she has heard used against her throughout her entire life. In this way, Mock uses the power of words to counteract their power, working within the system as a means of dismantling it.
Mock also presents words as important in regard to their abilities to define people. Although she knows that categorization can be harmful—especially when the words are used in a negative way—they can also be helpful in terms of understanding oneself:
“As a tween, I was living in the murkiness of sexuality and gender. I knew I was viewed as a boy. I knew I liked boys. I knew I felt like a girl. Like many young trans people, I hadn’t learned terms like trans, transgender, or transsexual—definitions that would have offered me clarity about my gender identity” (80).
Because Mock does not know the words to use to define her gender identity, she feels out of control. It is the learning of these categorizations, then, that gives Mock a sense of agency over her own body. In this way, definitions of words can be incredibly helpful in making otherwise marginalized people feel like they belong.
Throughout the narrative, Mock discusses the interplay between secrets and truth as she searches for her identity. Mock fears that exposing her truth will result in rejection, internalizing the negative norms associated with trans identity in modern American society. She repeatedly wonders, “Who will ever love you if you tell the truth” (99). In this way, Mock feels she must keep her true identity a secret, so that she is not rejected by other people. She believes she must keep her truth a secret because she does not feel her true identity is worthy of love.
When Mock begins to live her truth, first as Keisha, she believes she will not be accepted, and so keeps part of her identity a secret. She remembers, “I didn’t approach Alan because I was scared he’d find out the truth and Keisha would be dismissed as a fraud. She was no longer imaginary to me; she was the most authentic thing about me” (70). Mock feels like Keisha is part of her truth, but she does not believe that people like Alan will accept her for this. Therefore, she decides to keep herself and Keisha separate from one another, keeping this most truthful aspect about herself a secret. However, this secrecy results in her isolation from the people who love her and prevents her from developing long-lasting and mutually-beneficial relationships with others. In essence, Mock is worried about acceptance, which she at first believes can only be achieved via secrecy. However, once Mock meets Wendi, she learns that disclosing one’s truth can also result in acceptance. Throughout the narrative, Mock transitions from associating acceptance with secrecy to associating acceptance with truth, demonstrating her growth as a person.



Unlock every key theme and why it matters
Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.