Second First Impressions

At a diner, Teddy introduces Ruthie to his pregnant ex-girlfriend, Brianna, who jokes that Teddy is the baby’s father before clarifying she is married. Brianna warns Ruthie that Teddy has a history of disappearing from serious relationships and shows Ruthie a bluebird tattoo Teddy designed. Later, Teddy admits he has hurt every girlfriend he has ever had.

The evening is interrupted when Renata calls, reporting the office security alarm is sounding. Ruthie rushes back but finds the office secure. The false alarm triggers a panic attack stemming from her past. At 16, Ruthie was falsely accused of the theft of a church charity fund; her parents used her college fund to repay the money, forcing her to abandon her dream of becoming a veterinarian.

Teddy follows Ruthie and helps calm her. She confides in him, explaining the story of the stolen money. He mentions his therapist and encourages Ruthie to consider reaching out. They spend the night watching Heaven Sent. Before leaving, Teddy asks for and receives a spare key to Ruthie’s cottage.

The following workday, Melanie helps Ruthie create an online dating profile. They also plan a vintage prom-themed Christmas party for the residents. Meanwhile, Teddy receives his tax refund, bringing him closer to his financial goal for the tattoo studio.