94 pages • 3-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
Reluctantly, Turgon allows Aredhel (his sister) to leave Gondolin after several centuries in the heavily fortified castle. He sends three Lords to protect her on her journey. After they leave, Aredhel announces her plan to search for “the sons of Fëanor” (63). They are forced to take a long and dangerous path and Aredhel becomes separated from her guides, who return to Gondolin.
Aredhel survives alone and arrives in Himlad, where she spends some time with the people of Celegorm before becoming restless again. She reaches Nan Elmoth, the home of Eöl, the Dark Elf, who is a good friend of the Dwarves. Eöl spots Aredhel in the woods and lures her into his home and then he “took her to wife” (65). They spend years together and have a son, Maeglin (or Lómion in the forbidden tongue). As Maeglin grows up hearing tales of his ancestors, Aredhel begins to long for her family. Eöl forbids his son from leaving the forest, and an animosity grows between the two.
When Eöl attends a feast hosted by the Dwarves, Maeglin and his mother escape. Eöl returns early and becomes enraged. He chases his wife and child, stopping at the homes of various Lords who do not particularly like him. This reminds Eöl of how much he hates the Noldor. At the Brithiach, Eöl catches up with Maeglin and Aredhel as they enter the secret path into Gondolin. They enter and are “received with Joy” (66) by Turgon. Eöl is captured by guards as he tries to enter the city. Aredhel asks for him not to be killed but to be subjected to “the King’s judgement” (66).
Turgon informs Eöl that, because he has discovered the secret entrance to the city, he may never leave or else he will be killed. Eöl rejects this and grabs a javelin, throwing it at Maeglin, shouting “the second choice I take and for my son also” (67). Aredhel dives in front of her son and the javelin strikes her shoulder. She dies that night after pleading for mercy for Eöl. Turgon executes Eöl as Maeglin watches. Before he is thrown over the precipice, Eöl curses his son. Maeglin remains in Gondolin and prospers, though he bears an unrequited love for Idril, his cousin. This impossible love lays “a dark seed of evil” (67) in the city.
Finrod Felagund wanders away from his companions on a hunting trip. He hears distant song at night and investigates. It is the first Men to enter Beleriand by traveling over the Blue Mountains. Finrod watches until the men fall asleep and then begins to play his harp. The men wake and listen. Finrod befriends them, discovering that he can read their thoughts and interpret the meaning of their strange language; before long, he “could hold converse with Bëor” (68), their leader.
The men have come west to flee a dangerous past in the east. Melkor attempted to corrupt them but has not succeeded entirely. More men are coming, Finrod learns, and they establish a home on the east banks of the Celon. Some Elves, however, fear the arrival of the new race. Marach, another leader, brings his people down from the mountains and settles near Bëor’s camp. For a while, there is peace and Finrod visits them often. Fingolfin, king of the Noldor, sends the Men messages of welcome. After some time, the Men begin to move west again and settle across the various Elvish kingdoms. Thingol is worried by this, and Melian has a troubling premonition.
Some of the leaders of Men are uncertain about their relationship with the Elves. Amlach, a grandson of Marach, tells an assembly of Men that the Elves may be lying about Melkor, the Valar, and everything else, though he later denies being present at the meeting at all. Nevertheless, some Men decide to depart and leave the Elves to fight their own battle against Melkor.
Melkor is displeased at his failure to turn the Men against the Elves so sends his Orcs to attack an encampment. Haldad takes up arms and defends his people, though dies in an attack. At the last moment, an army of Elves saves the Men, led by Caranthir. When the Men are offered a safe place to live, they refuse and continue west, led by Haldad’s widow, Haleth. They settle in Brethil. Soon, there are many human settlements scattered around the Elvish kingdoms. They are united with the Elves to varying degrees.
Now allied with the Men, Fingolfin contemplates another attack on Angband, though there is little appetite for war among the content Elves. However, during the sixth generation of Men, Melkor attacks. He unleashes floods of lava and fire, as well as poisonous smoke. This is the Battle of Sudden Flame.
The attack is led by Glaurung the Golden, the father of dragons, followed by Balrogs and armies of Orcs. They kill many Noldor and Men and many Elves run to Thingol’s city, where Melian’s spells still protect them from unwelcomed guests. The attack continues and many famous Lords and leaders are killed. Maedhros, still furious at the harm done to him by Melkor, leads furious attacks against the enemy and they come to fear him “as one that returns from the dead” (74). The Orcs cross into East Beleriand and destroy almost everything they find. Fingolfin decides to avenge the death of so many Noldor and rides out against the enemy, so enraged that the Orcs believe that he is Oromë. He challenges Melkor to single combat. Melkor accepts and emerges from his subterranean dungeons “like a tower, iron-crowned” (74). Fingolfin ducks and darts beneath the heavy blows from Melkor’s hammer, Grond. He inflicts seven wounds on Melkor but is knocked back. Melkor places his foot on Fingolfin’s neck, attempting to crush him, but Fingolfin stabs Melkor in the foot and spills blood. Fingolfin dies under the crushing weight of Melkor’s foot. Melkor throws the Elf’s body to the wolves as Thorondor, king of the Eagles, watches on. Thorondor grabs the body and carries him to a mountaintop, where he was buried. Melkor’s wounds would never heal. Fingon takes over the kingdom of the Noldor.
Melkor has taken over the Northlands. The areas become deadly and dark. The Noldor defend the western pass with the help of Ulmo and Minas Tirith until Sauron arrives. He is Melkor’s “greatest and most terrible” (76) servant and he takes Minas Tirith and turns its tower into a watchtower from where he can see everything. Melkor inspires fear and terror in the Elves though “feigned pity” (76) to Men, trying to tempt them to his side. He fails and turns against Men with a fierce hatred. More Men arrive from the east and make an alliance with the Elves.
Húrin and Huor, the young sons of Galdor of Dor-lómin, “were dwelling with the Haladin” (77) and then were forced into battle. They lost, though were helped by Ulmo and Thorondor to escape to Gondolin, a place no man had ever visited. Turgon accepts them into his home, as he has been told to do by Ulmo, and they live there pleasantly for a year. They eventually desire to return to their people and plead with Turgon to be allowed to leave. They are not like Elves, they are not immortal, and they did not come to the city via the secret route. Turgon accepts, if Thorondor will carry them out the same way they arrived. When they are carried back to their people, they are well received but say nothing about where they have been.
On hearing of the war, Turgon decided that Gondolin was strong enough to hold out against the enemy. He fears the battles are the beginning of the end of the Noldor so sends out Elves to journey west and ask the Valar for help; they all failed. Melkor hears rumors of this but does not know about the existence of Gondolin, so he is troubled by the idea of Turgon and what he might achieve. He sends out more spies to Beleriand while recalling his Orcs and amassing a massive army. Seven years after the final battle, he launches a new assault against Hithlum. The combined might of Fingon and Húrin (with the help of the Elves of the Falas) is enough to drive the Orcs back. Húrin becomes ruler of his house, serving Fingon.
Eöl is a type of Elf that is not extensively discussed in The Silmarillion. Though most of the Elves live and operate in complex social groups, Eöl is a solitary figure and prefers to be left alone. He has elected to live apart from other Elves and only talks to them when he absolutely has to or when he requires something from them. As demonstrated in the above chapters, he is a powerful being and a negative influence. When he captures Aredhel and forces her to marry him, he is demonstrating his evil inclinations and uses his magic and a latent threat of violence to force her to remain in his house. In a novel where most evil acts are militaristic or large-scale events, this smaller scale domestic interpretation of evil is another way that Eöl is different from other Elves. Of all the characters in the novel, Eöl is one of the most unique and the most nefarious. That he then kills Aredhel in an attempt to murder his own son only confirms his position as one of the most loathsome characters in the novel.
The arrival of Men has been mentioned previously in the novel, but the first real interaction between Elves and Men is captured in the above chapters. At first, Men are a disruptive influence and—in contrast to the Elves—a much more morally nebulous species. While Elves are, for the most part, good, the Men seem far more prone to temptation, betrayal, and all of Melkor’s negative influences. While certain Elves have demonstrated such vulnerabilities, they are markedly different from the others. Figures such as Fëanor or Eöl are noted for their differences from most Elves, particularly on matters of morality. As such, the interactions between Men and Elves have the potential to be far more combustible than these early meetings indicate. This is partly why Thingol and his wife view the arrival of the new species as ominous.
The Battle of the Sudden Flame is a reminder of Melkor’s power. His threatening presence has been felt throughout Middle-earth, but this is one of the first times that he has launched a truly destructive attack. By this stage in the text, the Elves have constructed an entire world and social order that Melkor is now able to destroy. They have provided him with a target and he obliges, taking over the Northlands and killing Fingolfin. In doing so, he helps to lay the foundations for his own destruction: Melkor fortifies the bonds between Elves and Men, giving them a shared struggle and a common enemy. By attacking his enemies when he perceives them to be disjointed and weak, Melkor achieves the exact opposite and unites his enemies against him.



Unlock all 94 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.