56 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussions of child abuse, child sexual abuse, substance use, illness or death, physical abuse, and emotional abuse.
Devery’s presence at Hoppy Farm lifts Lucy’s mood following Diego’s death.
While doing chores, Lucy updates Devery about her life and the abuse at the Sterlings’ home. Devery suggests Bridget manipulated Lucy into running away to control her inheritance. Later, Lucy tells Devery she is two months pregnant with Diego’s child and that Diego has gone. They discuss her options and Devery offers support.
In May 2009, while Jamie handles legal strategy, Daunis takes Lucy to Harbor Springs to visit her father’s grave. At the cemetery, Lucy offers semaa and recalls that her father took the middle name Matthias after claiming his mother was killed by a drunk driver.
At the library, Lucy finds an article revealing her grandmother was the drunk driver, causing her own fatal crash. She realizes her father lied, likely changing his name to punish his mother. This prompts her to consider what else Luke lied about. Before leaving town, she drives past her childhood home and offers semaa there.
At Hoppy Farm, with Devery’s support, Lucy tells Missus she is pregnant. She later learns of Tonya’s death from a drug overdose and catches Missus in a lie about when she hears the news. One of Lucy’s foster sisters confirms that a past resident had been pregnant by Boyd before Tonya.
While cleaning Missus’s private apartment, Lucy connects her iris artwork to a pendant from Boyd’s memento box, suggesting that the two had a relationship. Later, Missus reveals she knew about Lucy’s involvement in Boyd’s death and threatens her with a fabricated letter from Tonya, placing Lucy at the scene of the crime.
In June 2009, Jamie adds an arson-defense specialist to Lucy’s legal team. Daunis finds character witnesses, reassuring Lucy. Feeling overwhelmed by the loss of control, Lucy asks about a plea deal. Daunis urges her to hold firm, insisting they will prove her innocence.
The Hoppys announce that the farm will now only accept pregnant teens. Lucy realizes the memorial trees around the property are likely connected to pregnant girls who have died or disappeared.
After rejecting adoptive parents presented by the Hoppys’ lawyer for her baby, Lucy searches the Hoppys’ rooms for evidence. While she is photographing a file, Mister nearly catches her and Lucy fakes early labor to escape. This false alarm becomes real and Lucy gives birth to a son, Luke, in the hospital.
In June 2009, Lucy tells Jamie and Daunis about her son, Luke, whom she placed for adoption. She explains that Hoppy Farm is an illegal operation that preys on pregnant foster girls and gives their babies to the highest bidder. She knows that Boyd murdered Diego, Luke’s father, to benefit from her pregnancy.
Lucy admits she started the fire that killed Boyd. The night she visited his room, he admitted to killing Diego, and offered to have sex with her so they could both earn money. She agreed to lull him into a sense of security. Afterwards, when he was asleep, Lucy left the room, leaving a candle lit next to the drapes.
Missus witnessed this and blackmailed her, forcing Lucy to find evidence of the farm’s other crimes to protect herself and her baby. Fearing for her loved ones, Lucy asks for Daunis and Jamie’s help to clear her name so she can disappear safely.
From March to May 2008, Lucy breastfeeds Luke before choosing a teacher, Isabella Rivera, as his adoptive mother. While sorting books in the library, she finds a 1982 note from Mona Hix, a former foster child, detailing the Hoppys’ plan to murder her after taking her baby, whom Lucy deduces is Allen Hoppy, Mister and Missus’s son.
Bruce reveals to Lucy that he kept a journal of where all the trees on the farm were planted. Lucy uses it to confirm that they were memorials for missing girls. Gaining access to the Hoppy apartment again, Lucy finds Missus’s journal logging the illegal adoptions and a key to a safety deposit box. Lucy takes the key and takes pictures of files with her phone. Lucy visits the memorial trees before using a movie outing with Devery as a chance to escape Hoppy Farm.
In June 2009, Daunis takes Lucy to visit Abe Charlevoix, who is recovering from cancer surgery. Abe greets her as his grandchild and gives her a copy of Charlotte’s Web that belonged to her father. She learns that Luke gave Abe books for him to continue giving to Lucy on her birthday after he died, each with its own inscription. She offers semaa and asks for a teaching about fire. Abe accepts the tobacco and explains that fire’s nature demands respect. Lucy feels more grounded after visiting with Abe.
In 2008, on the night of Lucy’s planned escape, Devery instead drives Lucy into a trap where Mister’s truck blocks their path. Devery admits to setting Lucy up, explaining that she cooperated with Mister and Missus for a chance to be accepted into the Hoppy family. Lucy grabs her backpack of evidence and runs into the woods. She hides the backpack and submerges herself in a pond, breathing through a bulrush stem. Using survival skills, she remains hidden, evading the Hoppys.
In June 2009, Jamie advises Lucy against accepting a plea deal offered by the prosecutor. One day, Stacy Sterling calls Lucy with a cryptic message, directing Lucy to the library at the Hoppy farm, warning her to come without her ankle monitor. Stacy whispers something, and Lucy believes it is a warning, but she does not understand it. Lucy decides to comply, hoping Stacy is not in danger.
In this section, the swift shifting between the grim events at Hoppy Farm in 2007-2008 and the fragile trust Lucy is building with Daunis and Jamie in 2009 creates an increasing sense of difference between past and present, signifying Lucy’s gradual healing in the present day. As she uncovers layers of corruption at the farm—from the illegal adoptions to the memorial trees that hide a graveyard—the audience simultaneously witnesses her tentative steps toward connection in the present. This dual narrative intensifies the stakes of Lucy’s eventual confession in Chapter 32. Her admission of having a son and her role in Boyd’s death is crucial structurally as the moment the two timelines collide, and the guarded survivor of the past finally entrusts her full story to the potential family of her future. The theme of Navigating a World of Secrets and Lies gains significant complexity, demonstrating that secrecy is a double-edged sword: a necessary tool for survival that simultaneously isolates and endangers. At Hoppy Farm, Lucy’s survival depends on her ability to operate in secret—photographing files, searching the Hoppys’ apartment, and concealing her knowledge of their crimes. Her deception is a strategic weapon against a predatory system. Devery’s character embodies the most tragic outcome of this theme. Desperate for the security of a family, she becomes an agent of the Hoppys’ corrupt world, betraying Lucy for what she perceives as her only path to belonging: “Missus wants me to marry Bruce [...] Someday it can be my house and my farm and my family. Please, Lucy, just give me the stuff. This is my one chance” (325). Her plea reveals a worldview so damaged by systemic failure that complicity seems her only means of survival. In contrast, Lucy’s decision to confess everything to Jamie and Daunis marks a thematic pivot, transitioning her from wielding secrets as a solitary shield to sharing truths as the foundation to protect herself and the people she loves. This narrative design ensures that Lucy’s confession is understood as an essential act of self-acceptance and psychological integration.
The acquisition and protection of knowledge—both textual and spiritual—emerges as a critical tool for survival and identity formation. The library serves as a sanctuary where Lucy can access objective truths, such as the newspaper article that corrects her father’s lie about her grandmother. This form of documented knowledge is paralleled by the sinister records she uncovers at the farm: Bruce’s tree journal and Missus’s hidden log of illegal adoptions. These texts are physical evidence of buried crimes, tangible proofs in a world where her word has consistently been dismissed. When Lucy reunites with Abe Charlevoix, he gives Lucy her father’s copy of Charlotte’s Web. This moment represents a key moment of healing for Lucy, as the continuation of her father’s tradition is the first instance of books reclaiming a positive association in her life, at the same time that she rekindles a healthy familial relationship. The simple book is therefore a vessel of familial love and cultural lineage, essential components for Reclaiming Identity and Family.
This section explores motherhood as a complex site of agency, exploitation, and protection. Missus Hoppy calculatedly performs a false maternal warmth that masks a predatory enterprise, viewing pregnancy and babies as commodities within her “baby farm.” This transactional motherhood is juxtaposed with Jennifer’s quiet, empathetic support and, most significantly, with Lucy’s own fierce, protective instincts. Upon giving birth, Lucy’s entire focus narrows to protecting her son, Luke. Her decision to breastfeed, to meticulously vet and select an adoptive mother, and to refuse any illegal payments, are all acts of maternal agency within a system designed to strip her of control. Giving Luke up for adoption is presented as an act of protection and self-sacrifice: “My eyes welled up with tears I’d suppressed over the past few months. I could hand the book to someone in authority. The Hoppys and their attorney could be prosecuted. Luke would be safe” (316). Giving Luke up is a painful, deliberate choice to save him from the dangerous world that surround Lucy. This redefines motherhood as an act of will and sacrifice rather than one of biological possession or physical proximity. By naming him Luke, Lucy asserts her connection to her own father, weaving her fragmented family history into the future she is securing for her son.



Unlock all 56 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.