56 pages 1-hour read

Sisters in the Wind

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of child abuse, child sexual abuse, illness or death, physical abuse, emotional abuse, and racism.

The System’s Betrayal of Vulnerable Children

Angeline Boulley’s novel critiques the American foster care system, exploring how institutional failures strip children of safety and identity, creating lifelong trauma. In creating Lucy’s fictional journey, Boulley argues that real-world failures in the system perpetuates cycles of harm, especially for Indigenous youth, making personal resilience and external intervention essential for survival. The system’s betrayal begins with the erasure of Lucy’s cultural identity. When she first enters foster care, her social worker, Mrs. Clark, actively subverts the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) by advising her to hide her heritage, saying, “It complicates everything. Just say you’re Mexican” (94). This initial act of institutional malpractice severs Lucy’s connection to her Anishinaabe roots and denies her the law’s intended protections, leaving her isolated and more vulnerable to the abuses that follow. The system’s failure to protect Lucy’s cultural identity is a precursor to its failure to ensure her physical and emotional safety, demonstrating a foundational disregard for the well-being of the children it is meant to serve.


The system’s betrayal escalates from cultural erasure to outright endangerment. In the Sterling home, Lucy suffers abuse from her foster brother, Steven. When she reports him, the system fails to believe her, prioritizing the word of her foster parents who frame her as a troubled teen with a drug problem: “By the time I reached Mrs. Clark, Mr. Sterling had already called and told her they’d found drugs in my bedroom. He said that, when confronted, I threatened to spread lies about their family” (132). This power imbalance illustrates how the system is ill-equipped to protect vulnerable children from their abusers. The ultimate institutional failure of the novel is embodied by Hoppy Farm, a placement that appears idyllic but is a criminal enterprise where foster children are exploited and murdered. The farm’s true purpose to traffic babies for illegal adoptions represents a complete perversion of the system’s mandate.


Boulley suggests that surviving such a corrupt system requires interventions from outside its broken framework. This intervention is embodied by Jamie and his company, Raven Air Associates, which he founded to counteract the exact injustices Lucy endures. His work training social workers on ICWA and helping former foster children reconnect with their tribal communities serves as a direct response to the systemic failures that betrayed Lucy and countless others. Through this contrast, the novel argues that while the institution itself may be irredeemably broken, healing and justice are possible through dedicated, culturally informed advocacy that operates to counteract the system’s deep-seated flaws.

Reclaiming Identity and Family

In Sisters in the Wind, the journey to selfhood is an act of reclaiming a fractured identity and reconnecting with familial bonds. The novel suggests that true belonging is found through forging active bonds of love, loyalty, and community, including but not limited to biological relationships.


The novel upholds biological family and genetic heritage as an important part of personal security and identity. Lucy’s father’s death is the catalyst for her negative experiences of adoptive and foster care, suggesting that biological bonds are a naturally strong source of care. Lucy’s sense of identity is also damaged by her father’s lie that her birth mother was Italian, not Anishinaabe, disconnecting her from her heritage and the potential protection of her maternal family. Lucy’s character arc to reconnect with her lost family and heritage, including her own role as a biological mother, frames the significance of kinship in the narrative. Lucy’s subsequent experiences with legally-created families deepen this presentation. Her adoptive mother, Bridget, terminates the adoption shortly after her father’s death, treating her as disposable: “Bridget requested to terminate the adoption. I didn’t know it was possible to undo an adoption. It was called a ‘failed adoption.’ I was to become a ward of the state” (95). This highlights the precarity of the legal bond in comparison to the biological one.


Later, the Sterlings, her foster family, prove to be a source of abuse rather than protection, as do the Hoppys. Both foster families are shown to be false or corrupt pseudo-families, hiding behind the image of virtuous family life: The Sterlings use religion to conceal and condone incestuous sexual abuse—a form of abuse that inherently perverts the nature of the family unit—while the Hoppys use a wholesome façade to hide an illegal and exploitative “baby farm.” In this way, both foster families present as nightmarish imposters for the true familial unit.


These false familial relationships teach Lucy that legal ties are no guarantee of love or safety, reinforcing her isolation until she is “found” by her connections to her maternal family and cultural identity. This process starts with Miss Lonnie, a foster parent who offers her stability and kindness, and Abe Charlevoix, who provides a crucial link to her Anishinaabe heritage by calling her “Noozhishenh,” or grandchild. Lucy’s most transformative relationships are with Daunis and Jamie, who offer unconditional support and reconnect her to her maternal family and community. Jamie explains the Anishinaabe perspective of family as an onion, where protective layers of relatives and community surround the child at the center: “That green center, where the onion is sweetest, that’s the Native child. Surrounded by layers of family and community” (163). This metaphor of layered, communal protection reframes the idea of family as a small, nuclear unit. Through these wider familial connections, Lucy begins to mend her fractured identity and understand that family can be an active, conscious choice.


Ultimately, Boulley portrays the reclamation of identity as an act of deliberate creation. Lucy’s journey culminates in the discovery of her past and in her choice to build family bonds on her own terms, one that integrates her past and her future. By the end of the novel, she has woven a resilient network of care that includes her son Luke, her mother. Maggie, her chosen sister Stacy, and her elders Miss Lonnie and Abe Charlevoix. These acts of emotional connection demonstrates Lucy’s healing journey, and that while one’s history is important, true selfhood and belonging are achieved by actively forging bonds of trust and mutual care.

Navigating a World of Secrets and Lies

Sisters in the Wind illustrates that survival in a predatory world often necessitates wielding secrets as both a shield for self-preservation and a weapon against corruption. Angeline Boulley demonstrates that, while secrecy is a vital tool for navigating dangerous systems and individuals, true connection and healing require the courage to embrace vulnerability and share the truth. From a young age, Lucy learns that the adults and systems meant to protect her are untrustworthy, forcing her to rely on secrecy to survive. In the Sterling home, she uses hypervigilance and deception to protect herself from her abuser, Steven, gathering her own evidence of his crimes while hiding her acts of self-defense: “Neutralizing Steven Sterling meant getting proof that he was bad news. I’d need it to blackmail him into staying away from me” (128). This behavior escalates at Hoppy Farm, where she secretly collects proof of the Hoppys’ illegal baby-selling operation. She understands that the journal and key she steals are her only leverage, a hidden shield that keeps her alive because the Hoppys do not know what she plans to do with the information: “I needed to find evidence of the shady things going on at the farm. I figured I could leverage the evidence to keep the baby safe. I could choose the adoptive parents. I could leave the farm” (314-15). For Lucy, secrecy is a necessary survival tactic in a world where the truth is more dangerous than a lie.


The novel complicates this reliance on secrecy by exploring its corrosive and destructive potential. The most damaging secret is the one kept from Lucy: her father’s lie about her Anishinaabe heritage, which isolates her from her culture and family. This initial deception sets a pattern of disconnection that she must later overcome. The path to healing only begins when others choose to be vulnerable with her. Daunis’s and Jamie’s honest accounts of their own traumatic pasts—Lily’s death and Jamie’s undercover work—create the foundation of trust that Lucy has never experienced. The character of Devery most clearly embodies the dual nature of secrets. Devery uses them for self-serving betrayal to survive at Hoppy Farm but also orchestrates a secret plan that leads to her own sacrifice to save Lucy and Luke. Her actions highlight that the intent behind a secret determines its moral weight, distinguishing between deceit for personal gain and concealment for the basic protection of the self and others.


Lucy’s journey culminates in her transition from solitary survival to communal trust, a shift marked by her willingness to share her own truths. Her final confession to Daunis and Jamie about her past—including her role in Boyd’s death and her knowledge of the crimes at Hoppy Farm—is a pivotal moment: “I found evidence of something even worse than the bonuses and illegal adoptions. I thought I’d lined everything up to keep Luke safe. So, I ran. And everything was fine for six months” (302). By revealing her deepest secrets, Lucy relinquishes her shield of isolation and chooses to trust in her found family. Boulley suggests that, while secrets may be an essential tool for enduring a predatory world, the path toward a healed and connected self relies on the vulnerability shared truths.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock every key theme and why it matters

Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.

  • Explore how themes develop throughout the text
  • Connect themes to characters, events, and symbols
  • Support essays and discussions with thematic evidence