61 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide features discussion of bullying, death, and mental illness.
Shane sometimes has a recurring nightmare of standing by as the forces of darkness come to kill his family. Although this nightmare represents his greatest fear, he recognizes that something deep and instinctive is driving him to save Bethany.
Shane remembers how, when he was in high school, a girl he had a crush on invited him to join her religious youth group, Young Life. Shane was unaffected by the influence that Young Life tried to exert on him, but he was later inspired by one of the boys he met there named Charlton, who stood up to defend another schoolmate from bullying. Twelve years after the bullying incident, Shane wept at a Narcotics Anonymous meeting, where he experienced a religious conversion. Shane realized that accepting God could make him as brave and as strong as Charlton. In the present, Shane throws two punches at Dean to force him to release Bethany. Dean drops Bethany and shoots Shane in the head.
Bobby is shocked by the murder of Shane, which Dean tries to argue was an act of self-defense. Rhys becomes disillusioned with his Atlas of Wisdom project in the face of Dean’s cruelty. Determined to risk his life for his family, Rhys takes the air rifle and aims at Dean’s hip. The shot disarms Dean. Rhys prepares to shoot him again. When Dean recovers and retrieves his weapon, Rhys throws his air rifle at him to distract him. Brian arrives and shoots Dean in the arm, neutralizing him. Rhys retrieves Dean’s gun and holds Bobby at gunpoint, forcing his surrender. Bethany weeps over Shane’s corpse.
Brian is shocked after shooting Dean. Joanie, who rode up to Rhys’s house with Brian, goes to call the police and paramedics. A large force of emergency units soon arrives at the scene to take Dean and Shane’s corpse away. They find that David Jr. has kept Asher and Leah safe inside the house, having discovered the air rifle that Bethany used against Dean.
Rhys is also placed into an ambulance so that he can undergo surgery for all the injuries he has sustained over the past few days. Before he goes, he reassures Bethany that he is okay and apologizes for what happened to Shane. Rhys tells Bethany that he loves her as he goes.
Brian shares his experience with the police, who are impressed by the shot he took at Dean. Brian goes to check on Rhys in the ambulance. When Rhys sees Brian, it occurs to him how close he and his family were to getting killed, which causes him to weep. Brian reassures him by saying “X̣est sx̣l̓x̣al̓t,” the only consolation he has learned at Salish School.
After undergoing reconstructive surgery, Rhys moves to Spokane to facilitate his recovery and to support Bethany and her children through their grief. He similarly experiences post-traumatic stress, grappling with the reality of their near-death experience.
Lucy gets Allison to write a story about Rhys’s experience, though the article disappoints him because it reduces the death of Shane to a petty domestic squabble. He reflects upon the failure of daily journalism to capture the wider social and cultural issues that underlie everyday violence. On the other hand, the story amuses him because it misrepresents Brian as an “air force marksman,” rather than as an electrician.
Brian also experiences post-traumatic stress, fixated on the alternate outcomes that could have happened if he had arrived late or if his bullet had been a few inches off from where it hit Dean. He and Joanie have become friends with Jeff from Paititi, who has offered to give them a guided LSD trip.
Dean’s trial is scheduled for the following year, though he tries to challenge the case by blaming Shane for his own death. The prosecutor is skeptical that Dean’s assertion will hold in court. As a result of his gunshot wound, Dean’s arm was amputated to save his life.
Rhys gets a new cellphone, which he struggles to adjust to. Although he finds relief in his ability to contact Bethany, he worries about the constant stream of news he gets on it. Despite his best efforts to avoid reading the news, Rhys cannot help but stay informed.
Shane is buried in Salem, though the funeral is tense as Shane’s parents blame Bethany for his death. Rhys reassures her that it was not her fault. Leah grieves more than Asher does. After the funeral, however, Asher experiences intense nightmares of Shane as a ghost. He reckons with the fact that Dean was supposed to be Shane’s friend. Bethany supports him as he struggles to make sense of Shane’s death.
Leah starts closing herself off to everyone except David Jr., with whom she continues to correspond over email. David’s parents call off his conversion therapy. David Jr. takes a leave from school to explore his identity, postponing his betrothal to Leah. Leah attends public school, which starts affecting the way she talks to her family. She declines family therapy and starts expressing her doubt in God. The only other person Leah is open with is Rhys, whom she helps to clear his library in exchange for newer titles. Rhys shares that there may be nothing to his Atlas of Wisdom project. Leah encourages him to reframe the book to discuss “what to do when the world seems like it’s gone crazy” (253).
Bethany chooses to remain in Spokane, working as a part-time English as a Second Language teacher with the intention to go full-time. Rhys puts the Kinnick property up for sale, regretting only that he did not share it with his family the whole time he lived there. Rhys starts working as a golf course starter, urging the players to respect the land they are playing on. He remains in touch with Lucy, who tells him that Chuck is dating another woman now. Rhys raises the possibility of them dating again, which Lucy nearly laughs off.
Asher starts playing chess with a boy named Abdel, who is much better than him at the game. Instead of being discouraged, Asher is awed by Abdel’s technique and aspires to reach his skill level. Asher continues going to church at a Unitarian service with Bethany, who is relieved that the church does not have a militant wing.
The novel ends with Bethany and Rhys visiting the part of the Spokane River where Bethany had scattered Celia’s ashes. They spend time cleaning up waste from a nearby clearing, after which Bethany goes to spend a moment of solitary silence by the water. Rhys respects her privacy and admires the place. When Bethany gets back, she reveals that she told Celia that Rhys is home again.
Shane’s sacrifice redeems his character, allowing the noble parts of his flawed humanity to shine through. Walter communicates this by drawing out Shane’s backstory in the split seconds between the moment he chooses to act and the moment Dean kills him. Through these flashes, the novel depicts Shane as someone who typically acts according to fear, which is why the act of trying to save Bethany represents him overcoming that fear and trying to become something more. It is revealed that Shane’s religious conservativism is really a manifestation of his self-doubt. Although he is misguided in his moral values, he knows that he wants to be braver than he thinks he is, and the militancy of his church gives him a way to feel brave. Walter describes the force that propels Shane into action as “immediate, primal, physical” (237), suggesting that Shane’s bravery is fundamental to him. He springs into action when he recognizes that something is urgently wrong. When he stops to think about a situation, his flawed thinking gets in the way.
Shane’s sacrifice brings the characters into a new status quo, which is unveiled over the final chapter of the novel. The biggest change to the status quo established at the start of the novel is that Rhys gives up his family property to live closer to Bethany and her children in Spokane. Although this requires Rhys to reintegrate himself into the world, even going so far as to get a new cellphone that alerts him to the same horrors that scared him into self-exile in the first place, Rhys learns to reckon with those fears by spending more time with his family, embodying the theme of Reckoning with a Broken World Through Community. Having previously fled a world that seemed hopelessly broken, he has learned that he doesn’t have to fix everything wrong with the world to make an impact; instead, he can simply do his best to make life better for the people closest to him.
Just because the characters have resolved the novel’s central conflicts doesn’t mean that everything wrong in their lives is put right. Leah, for instance, begins to go through the angst of the changes brought about by adolescence. Her story, especially with David Jr., is far from over when she appears for the last time. The same could be said for Bethany as she struggles to work through the guilt she feels over Shane’s death and her career as a teacher. The difference, however, is that Rhys is present, offering a support system that can help her to live through her most overwhelming problems. As Bethany advises Asher, their family exists to support each other through times of senseless strife. This advice resolves the theme of Family Dynamics in a Post-Truth World. Though the seemingly irreconcilable political tensions of this era can tear families apart, family can also be a vital source of support. Not only does this advice hold true for Asher as he reckons with the death of his father, but it also applies to the Kinnick family, living through the mess of a senseless world.



Unlock all 61 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.