Son of a Witch

Gregory Maguire

56 pages 1-hour read

Gregory Maguire

Son of a Witch

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2005

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Damaging Effects of Corruption

Throughout Son of a Witch, Maguire builds on the themes of Wicked by exploring how the nation of Oz responds to the deaths and disappearances of its major leaders. With both the Wicked Witch of the West and Wicked Witch of the East dead, and the Wizard departed, new powers rise to fill the void, and in order to control the population during these tumultuous times, the government uses corrupt tactics to both appease and terrorize its citizens.


Liir’s first introduction to the effects of governmental corruption comes when he arrives in the Emerald City and joins the Home Guard, where he encounters Commander Cherrystone, the same person who once attacked his home. Cherrystone warns Liir that everything is not as it seems, and that despite Glinda’s work as a temporary leader, war will soon arrive. As he states, “Your highborn champion, Lady Glinda, thinks all is peaches and creams. She’d like it to be. But given the uncertainty of the political situation, the economy needs stimulus, and the threat of war is a great incentive to spend” (143). With this cynical declaration, Cherrystone foreshadows the fact that the government of Oz is deliberately fomenting war as a means of stimulating its own economy, thereby enriching the Emerald City at the expense of other regions. In Cherrystone’s unique view, war must be manufactured and incited in order to stimulate the economy, and this pattern suggests that the government will actively look for a fight in which to embroil its people. 


When Shell rises to the position of Emperor Apostle, he uses his station and immense power to expand his control, as evidenced by his development of a legion of attack dragons: the fulfillment of Commander Cherrystone’s earlier hints to Liir. Candle tells Liir what happened after he and his company fomented an insurrection in Quadling Country, admitting, “[T]he Emerald City flared up in reprisal. Overreacted. A small fleet of flying dragons was unleashed against the Quadlings at Qhoyre. It was pretty terrible. There were only a few survivors” (241). While Candle’s uncle believes that the government overreacted, Liir realizes that Shell had been waiting for such an instance to justify his use of force. The lethal attack quells the population and spreads rumors, making others wary of the capabilities of the government. Shell uses this strategy of repression throughout the novel.


In a fractured Oz, the power of the Emerald City strives to be absolute. In order to achieve this, its leaders use their power, status, and resources to either keep the population ignorant and obedient, eliminating any who resist. Whether it is the attack on the Quadlings, the “scrapings” of maunts in a bid to divide the tribes, or the hunting of Birds, the Ozian government uses its power to create crises that work to its benefit.

The Impact of Belonging on Identity Formation

At its core, Son of a Witch is a bildungsroman that explores Liir’s growth from childhood to the early years of adulthood. At the end of Wicked, the death of Elphaba, his supposed mother, leaves him with little direction or sense of self, and throughout the novel, Liir strives to find a place or community to claim, often twisting himself into metaphorical knots in his attempts to conform to the dictates of others.


At the beginning of his journey, Liir leaves his life with Kiamo Ko behind and opts to join Dorothy—the one who killed Elphaba—as she heads back to the Emerald City. When he even begins to imagine building a life with Dorothy, it is clear that he is responding to the traumatic changes in his life by aligning himself with another person’s goals so that he will not have to forge his own path. In this headlong quest for belonging, Liir overlooks her role in upending his world. As the narrative cynically notes, “Perhaps he harbored a zesty secret anger toward her, too, but if so it kept itself in disguise. If Liir lashed out at Dorothy—well, what would he have left in the world? Who? Pretty nearly nothing. Just about nothing at all” (54). Liir is too afraid to challenge Dorothy because he knows that doing so may jeopardize his relationship and future with her. His reticence on this point marks him as a follower, for he tags along after Dorothy in the same way that he always followed at Elphaba’s heels. He sees Dorothy as the new guiding force of his life and hopes to redefine himself through his connection with her. When she leaves, he is inevitably lost once again, and he begins searching for Nor in earnest only because he hopes to reclaim some part of his former self.


Only when Liir uses Elphaba’s broom to escape the grim prison of Southstairs does he begin to appreciate the essence of the woman who is supposedly his mother, and with this act, he finally experiences a new sense of belonging and personal identity. For the first time in his life, Liir recognizes himself as an individual and glories in the solitude of the airy setting: “It was Liir and wind and height and stars, it was alone and alone and alone; the understandings were distinct and differentiated, and then suddenly annealed by a process he couldn’t name. Maybe fear of height! His Liirness applied, suddenly, applied to himself and no one else” (134). The rushing, delighted tone of this passage conveys Liir’s tumultuous emotions as his solitude compels him to appreciate his status as a unique individual. 


In this moment high above the earth, when he finally experiences full isolation, the wonder of flying provides him with a crucial epiphany. Although his loneliness remains, it is not necessarily a negative experience. Instead, it proves to Liir that he can have an identity in isolation, without the influence of others. Although Liir’s dependence on others to form his identity has plagued him throughout the novel, his struggle to understand his place in the world eventually leads him to feel more confidence in himself.

The Complexities of Using Religion as a Political Tool

In Maguire’s version of Oz, religion plays a significant role in the actions of individual characters and governmental forces alike, and Liir encounters a barrage of people who define themselves and their worldviews through the lens of their religious faith. Although Unionism is the primary faith featured in Son of a Witch, its tenets and morals are debated by different factions. While Shell uses it to style himself as Emperor Apostle and pursue an authoritarian path of conquest and control, others, like the maunts, use it as inspiration and justification for resistance and rebellion. On either side of this conflict, religion and faith are used to construct unique worldviews that influence people’s individual actions and their views of others. 


When Liir first meets Shell, the future religious leader is, at this point, a cynic with no ties to any faith at all. Despite coming from a devoutly Unionist family and having two high-profile siblings—Elphaba and Nessarose—who are now championed for their respective beliefs, Shell refuses to give credence to even the idea of martyrs. When Liir asks about Shell’s relationships with the agnostic Elphaba and the zealously Unionist Nessarose, Shell explains, “Martyrdom implies a religious faith, and Nessarose had so much faith that no one else in the family could breathe. Elphaba affected a salty agnosticism; I never knew whether it was genuine or not. For me to consider them martyrs, I’d have to have faith, and I don’t” (108). While Nessarose, the Wicked Witch of the East, was fiercely religious and used her faith to lead Munchkinland, Elphaba refused to put any faith in a higher power. Though others now see both women as martyrs and use them as symbols for their own ends, Shell cannot bring himself to view his siblings in such lofty, abstract terms. Because he has no faith, he cannot apply a moralistic perception to his siblings; he sees them for who they were as people, not as leaders of movements.


However, this encounter comes to hold a certain degree of irony, for despite Shell’s early atheism, Liir eventually discovers that his maybe-uncle undergoes a major transformation. Later, when Liir returns to the Emerald City, which Shell comes to rule in his self-styled role as the “Emperor Apostle,” Liir sees a man who uses his supposed faith to seize political power and change the course of the world. Evidence for this pattern abounds in Shell’s many propaganda posters, such as the one depicting “a male foot in an open, leather-strapped sandal stepping out of a cloud,” and a “painted landscape” showing that “wherever the Apostle had already set his foot, communities like miniature Emerald Cities spr[a]ng up” (246). As Emperor, Shell deliberately forges an association between faith and prosperity, positioning himself as the one figure whose faith and morals have brought about the prosperous boom in the Emerald City. This portrayal also serves to justify Shell’s wish for further expansion, for by this logic, if his morals and faith can transform the Emerald City, then the city and its government have the duty to impose their will on others. Thus, despite his own lack of faith in a higher power, Shell cynically uses religion as a form of psychological manipulation in his quest to create an empire.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock every key theme and why it matters

Get in-depth breakdowns of the book’s main ideas and how they connect and evolve.

  • Explore how themes develop throughout the text
  • Connect themes to characters, events, and symbols
  • Support essays and discussions with thematic evidence