49 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of sexual content, bullying, cursing, and death.
At night in Weatherstone College, Paisley Hallistar runs bleeding down a corridor after a beast attacks her. A spell from fellow student Belle gave her a head start. Desperate, Paisley veers into the Nightrealm Hall, which she has previously avoided, thinking, “To fight a monster, I needed a monster” (2). Leaning on a door marked by a carving of a minotaur, she smears it with her blood.
The door opens before she can knock, revealing Logan Kingston, her enemy and the son of Rafael Kingston. He catches her as she collapses. His face hardens as he calls her by an old nickname and demands to know who hurt her. Paisley loses consciousness, unsure if Logan will save or betray her.
Six months earlier in Spokane, Washington, Paisley Hallistar’s magical abilities emerge on her 22nd birthday, marked by recurring erotic dreams about a warlock. Witches and warlocks attend college after their powers bloom to find their magical specialization, or affinity. Affinities usually align with one of the five elements: fire, water, air, earth, or metal. The rarest affinity is the spellcaster, who can access the energy of the world itself.
Paisley’s mother, Beth, a cautious and formerly powerful witch, brings her an acceptance letter to Weatherstone College, the most prestigious magical university in the US, where Paisley’s father Tom is a professor of fire magic. Paisley is excited but insecure, as her affinity remains unknown. She wonders if there is a crystal affinity, as she obsessively collects crystals, a trait she shares with her maternal grandmother, whom she has never met. Her father and her four older siblings—the twins Jenna and Alice, and the middle siblings Trevor and Jensen—arrive to celebrate her admission.
On her first day at Weatherstone, Paisley and her father arrive on campus through a magical portal. As they walk to the administrative office, Tom shares school history, including its founding by necromancers. Inside, an administrator named Ms. White gives Paisley her welcome packet.
Ms. White mentions that Logan Kingston, a powerful spellcaster and son of community leader Rafael Kingston, is transferring to Weatherstone and will also teach. Alarmed, Tom declares that Paisley cannot attend and immediately tries to take her home.
Outside, Paisley demands an explanation. Tom reveals that he and Rafael Kingston were once best friends. Eighteen years ago, Rafael’s wife, Isabel, died in an accident while with Paisley’s mother, Beth. Rafael blamed Beth, and the two men swore a blood oath. Tom fears Logan will seek revenge on Paisley because of the feud.
Paisley begs to stay, promising to be careful. Tom reluctantly agrees to let her settle in while he consults with Beth. He warns her to avoid Logan and stay away from Nightrealm Hall.
Tom walks Paisley to her dorm in Florence Wing, where her mother once lived. After claiming the room, she explores the simple space, which has a view of the apothecary forest and the graveyard. Before leaving, Tom casts a protective spell on the room. Alone, Paisley examines her school-issued supplies until her four siblings arrive.
Paisley’s siblings crowd into her room, and she explains the Kingston history. Her sister Alice recalls that Paisley and Logan were inseparable as children and that he was fiercely protective of her. Her brothers vow to confront Logan if necessary.
They agree to attend the welcome ceremony together. Walking through the residences, they pass a curtained-off corridor leading toward Nightrealm Hall. Two warlocks emerge from it; when Trevor confronts one, Paisley finds herself face-to-face with Logan.
Logan ignores her brothers, speaking directly to Paisley, calling her “best friend” (38) and referencing an old bond she does not remember. The encounter unsettles Paisley and infuriates her brothers. The siblings continue to the welcome assembly, where Headmaster Gregor, a powerful necromancer, emphasizes that the school will not tolerate magical attacks between students. Afterward, they attend the welcome feast before Jensen walks a tired Paisley back to her dorm.
At two o’clock in the morning, Paisley wakes from another erotic dream, this time with Logan’s face vivid in her mind. Restless, she goes to the communal bathroom and discovers a witch named Annabeth magically attacking another witch, Belle.
Paisley intervenes, punching Annabeth, who flees. Paisley helps Belle, a water elemental whose father serves on the High Council of Magic. Belle explains that the assault was retaliation for her father’s political decisions. Grateful, Belle offers to walk with Paisley to class, marking the beginning of their friendship.
In the morning, Paisley meets Belle, who guides her to a breakfast cart. They run into Trevor, whom Belle recognizes as a famously popular warlock. They continue to Elemental 101, where their professor, an air elemental named Professor Damone, seals the doors with magic and begins the first-year session on testing for elemental affinities.
Professor Damone directs students with known affinities to designated groups, and Belle eagerly joins the water elementals. Paisley and other unaffiliated students receive trays of items to test their connection to earth, water, fire, metal, and air. Paisley feels nothing from earth or water and only an uncontrollable flicker from fire and metal. Professor Damone’s personal test for an air affinity also yields no response. The professor reassures Paisley that her affinity will emerge when she is ready.
After class, Paisley and Belle discuss her lack of elemental results on their way to the History of Necromancy lecture. In the hall, they see Marcus Lofting, a fellow first-year and powerful student, just as Logan arrives. Paisley briefly explains the dangerous history between their families to Belle. The instructor for this class, Professor Jones, lectures on Weatherstone’s necromancer founders, two witches who were chased out of England. After class, Marcus approaches Paisley, remarking on her undeclared affinity. With Belle’s encouragement, Paisley considers him as a possible romantic interest.
The Prologue opens in medias res, creating suspense by immersing the reader in the central conflict without context. The Prologue establishes a tone of crisis, foreshadows events to come, and foregrounds Logan's introduction as the antagonist of the narrative. The subsequent flashback to “six months earlier” reframes the narrative as an exploration of the events leading to this confrontation and increases anticipation for the outcome of the opening scene. At the same time, the Prologue establishes the point of view of the story, told from Paisley's perspective in first-person narration. This confines the reader to Paisley’s limited knowledge and ensures that the reader experiences world-building and plot revelations simultaneously with the protagonist, allowing her biased perceptions of her family, Logan's behavior, and her own inadequacy to impact the reader's understanding of the world and the story.
A central component of both the external and internal conflicts, arises from the “blood oath” (20) between the Hallistar and Kingston families. This blood oath sworn between Tom and Rafael is an important plot device in the novel, dictating relationships between characters before they can be personally formed. Tom’s panic at the mention of the Kingston name underscores the sense of impending danger and positions Logan as a threat in Paisley’s and her siblings’ eyes before they have even met him. Beth Hallistar’s refusal to use her magic, a tangible consequence of the tragedy that occurred 18 years prior, further emphasizes the degree to which past trauma shapes her life in the present. The family blood oath is invoked throughout the novel, forming a central motif that contributes to the theme of The Conflict Between Family Legacy and Personal Choice. Through the influence of the blood oath, the novel demonstrates that legacies passed down by families can shape the attitudes of younger generations for good or ill.
Logan thrives on this inherited tension. The animosity he has inherited from his father places him in conflict with the Hallistar siblings from their first meeting. However, his cryptic language, particularly his invocation of their childhood bond, challenges the Hallistar family’s view of him as an enemy. When he demands to know, “[w]here is my best friend, Paisley Hallistar?” (38), the phrase is both a claim and a threat, hinting at a shared history between Logan and Paisley that conflicts with the blood oath. The intimate nicknames he uses for her can be interpreted as either mocking threats or terms of endearment from a forgotten past. Deepening this ambiguity, Alice remembers Logan as a protective childhood friend, suggesting that he may not be the monster Paul makes him out to be. Logan’s apparent kindness and Paisley’s erotic dreams suggest that each harbors desires that do not align with the familial vendetta in which they are caught up.
The world of Weatherstone College, with its gothic architecture and rigid social hierarchies, aligns with the aesthetic and narrative tropes of the dark academia genre. Here, power, lineage, and magical classification dictate an individual’s value, positioning Social Status as a Determinant of Self-Worth. The school is a microcosm of a wider society in which the primary goal in many people’s lives is to secure a position in a powerful coven. This fictional society, in turn, serves as an allegory for status-seeking in the real world, where many people attend prestigious schools in the hope of entering the upper echelons of business, law, and politics. Paisley’s anxiety over her undeclared affinity manifests her fear of being powerless in a society that expects categorization. She is therefore less concerned with what kind of affinity she might develop as she is with not finding one at all. However, some abilities have more value than others, based on their power and usefulness to society. Paisley’s search for an affinity is not simply a journey of self-discovery, but an anxious search for her place in society.
Paisley’s crystals, particularly the necklace inherited from her grandmother, represent an untapped, potentially crucial source of power, but they also place her at odds with the rigid social structure of her world. Paisley’s childhood nickname from her father, “Little Gem” (9), like her connection to these objects, foreshadows that her true power may lie outside established elemental affinities. Moreover, because her love for crystals is similar to her grandmother’s, despite never knowing her, Paisley’s magic may be rooted in a matriarchal lineage that connects her search for self-worth with her family legacy. Just as she has inherited the blood oath in a legacy passed down by her parents, she may also have inherited a unique and unclassified form of magical affinity from her ancestors as well.



Unlock all 49 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.