61 pages • 2-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of sexual violence, rape, child abuse, child sexual abuse, animal death, graphic violence, illness, death, physical abuse, and emotional abuse.
Nobody knows when Sister Jenny’s remains will arrive. The protagonist wonders if Simone’s reputation will make the transfer more difficult. Not only did a guest once complain that Simone does not follow the rules strictly, but others question her allowing the protagonist to stay permanently without becoming a sister.
Later that night, the protagonist looks up at the stars and feels happy with her life at the abbey. She cannot find the words to describe her longing for a new place to feel at home.
In the morning, the protagonist finds that mice have chewed their way to her baby lettuces, leaving only three untouched. She begins repairing and improving her defenses and thinks of how her mother once reveled in working with dirt.
The protagonist hears the piano playing in the night; the next day, she wants to ask others about it but is interrupted by Simone, who announces that Sister Jenny’s bones will arrive soon. She warns that there is still much work to be done before she can be buried, though she does not explain. The protagonist finds that she is accustomed to waiting, comfortable with not having answers.
They hear the piano again at night, and the protagonist listens as Simone leaves her room, makes her way into the sitting room, and opens and closes the keyboard lid.
Simone announces that Sister Jenny’s remains will arrive in eight days and that they will sit vigil for her until the burial permission is granted by the local authorities. The protagonist feels uneasy about this. Simone explains that the remains will be accompanied by Sister Helen Parry.
More mice begin to appear across the abbey, becoming a problem. The sisters find it morally wrong to kill them, but with warmer weather patterns driving the mice south and east, the problem will grow worse. When Simone and the protagonist open the piano and find a mouse nest, the sisters decide they must kill the mice. Richard Gittens, who lives near the abbey and often comes to help, brings them traps, and Simone warns everyone not to tell him of Sister Jenny’s bones, not wanting their arrival to cause a disturbance. Richard Gittens warns the protagonist that the mice will become a plague. Despite the mice being relatively harmless to her, she fears them.
The sisters begin placing traps around the abbey, with the protagonist focusing on the kitchen. There are mouse droppings everywhere, but she is surprised that only one bag of flour is ruined. The protagonist is the only member of the abbey who leaves for errands, and Simone sends her into town for new glass and metal containers for the kitchen’s ingredients.
On her way back to the abbey from this errand, the protagonist remembers that when she was a child, a piano instructor would visit houses to teach, and when it became clear that he was a child predator, parents warned him to leave town. She thinks the sight of the filthy mouse nest in the piano incited this memory.
The protagonist remembers how awful she and her classmates at St Ursula’s Catholic High School were to teachers. Now, as an adult, the protagonist feels guilty, though she felt no guilt at the time. Back at the abbey, as she fills her new bins with grains and spices, the protagonist finds that this simple work brings her a sense of peace she cannot explain.
As the date of Sister Jenny’s return grows closer, the protagonist remembers her childhood admiration for Saint Maria Goretti. Maria was 11 when a “not-quite-cousin” stabbed and murdered her for resisting his sexual advances. Maria died later in the hospital, after forgiving her attacker, the 20-year-old Alessandro. After serving his prison sentence, Alessandro claimed to love Maria, calling her, “my little saint” (88). Maria’s mother forgave Alessandro, and he joined an abbey. As a child, the protagonist was attracted to the drama of the story; now, she reflects on how the story sparked her confusion over what it means to forgive.
The mice begin to overwhelm the abbey, traps springing constantly. The sisters find them in every room except the “good room,” where Sister Jenny will rest until her burial. When the protagonist was a child, she had a friend whose father managed a car showroom. She would visit on weekends, her friend’s father sitting in his underwear, drinking beer, not caring what his daughter did. The friend owned mice, which the protagonist refused to hold. When the mice began multiplying, the friend released them behind her house. Even now, the smell of mice reminds the protagonist of that friend and her father.
Dolores cannot stop sneezing because of her allergies. It annoys the protagonist, who cannot stand the drama of each sneeze. The protagonist feels guilty for these feelings and tries to be nice to Dolores. She realizes she wants to tell the young woman to leave and go live her life.
When the protagonist was in high school, there was a girl who everyone hated. She lived in an ugly, isolated house, with a mother who beat her and had to take the school bus to get groceries. The girl was rude, attractive, confident, and hated by everyone. Her nonchalance and indifference to other people’s opinions inflamed the protagonist and her classmates. They hated her poverty, her acne, and the way she did not want to fit in with them. The girl’s name was Helen Parry.
Many of the girls took a sewing class with Mrs. Bird, whom everyone loved. One day, when Mrs. Bird stepped out, the whole class, including the protagonist, physically attacked Helen. When Mrs. Bird returned, she broke up the fight, condemned the class for attacking Helen, and escorted her out, returning with the headmaster. Mrs. Bird then left, and the headmaster sided with the protagonist and the other attackers, warning them not to let Helen rile them up. After this, neither Mrs. Bird nor Helen Parry return to the school.
At lunch, Sister Sissy tries to start a conversation about how God answers prayers, even if it does not seem like it. No one engages, and the protagonist thinks of how she dislikes Sissy’s need to be right. She feels that Sissy acts out because of anxiety over Helen’s return. Meanwhile, Simone is stressed and avoids the sisters, as the preparations for Jenny’s return and burial are intensive and complicated.
Though the protagonist’s mother was Catholic, she believed in mystical practices from other religious traditions. She once brought the protagonist to a reiki specialist when the protagonist complained of tight legs. As the reiki specialist began his work, waving his hands over the protagonist, the protagonist’s mother announced she would step out to grab some milk. The protagonist did not want her to leave and locked eyes with her mother. Her mother stayed instead. Now, as an adult, the protagonist realizes that this deep trust between a mother and daughter is rare, and she wishes she had a way to tell her mother this before she died. The protagonist thinks that her thoughts stray to her mother and never her father, because she knew her father completely, while her mother remains a mystery.
The tension and anxiety in the abbey rise, and everyone believes it is Helen’s approach. Helen is an intimidating figure, and her influence is severe. Sister Bonaventure is upset that Helen is returning, calling her “that celebrity nun” (113). The protagonist believes Bonaventure’s connection to Jenny is deeper than she suspects.
The protagonist met Sister Helen Parry for the first time after high school at a protest. At first, Helen did not recognize the protagonist, but haunted by guilt, the protagonist decided to speak with her. She pulled Helen aside and reminded her of the fight in Mrs. Bird’s class. After a brief flash of pain in her eyes, Helen smiled at the protagonist and says, “I can see why that might have been a big…incident…for you” and walked away (116).
Ever since, the protagonist follows Helen across the world from afar. Helen stands up to dictators, protests for sex workers’ rights, and exposes environmental crimes. Beneath all of this, the protagonist recognizes all the qualities she hated in Helen in high school. She still remembers meeting Helen in the forest, and how Helen refused to accept an apology, leaving the protagonist with her guilt.
Bonaventure sweeps the cabin Helen will stay in, knocking over a statuette of the Virgin Mary. She is agitated about the arrival of the bones, and the protagonist offers to take over from her. She finishes sweeping and hides the broken statue in her room. Later, she sits in the library, and as Simone walks by, she teases the protagonist for reading Stories of the Saints, saying there are better options. The protagonist reads these childish stories, about Saint Brigid and Saint Julia, and they remind her of Ten Thousand Dreams Interpreted, a book she found and kept for its ridiculous interpretations of dreams, whose meanings were different if a woman dreamed them.
The protagonist and the sisters throw dead mice over the back fence. However, after finding 13 corpses in one day, they realize they must bury them. The oven stops working, and Richard Gittens suggests that the mice ate the insulation. They pull the oven out and find his theory to be true. The protagonist remembers Richard Gittens as a shy and quiet boy in high school. He lives near the abbey and often comes to help, though he did not recognize the protagonist when she first arrived. Now that they work on projects together, she wonders if he is a friend.
The mice continue to overwhelm the abbey, and Sister Josephine is horrified when she sees a chicken eat one. The protagonist suggests this is better than their usual problem of a rat or lizard eating chicks or eggs. The protagonist begins looking around the abbey to see what Helen Parry will see when she arrives. There is the old horse-riding school, a paintball course, the Gittenses’ property, and a solar farm. Among all this is an abandoned hall, reflecting the run-down appearance of the area.
The protagonist’s new life at the abbey is largely defined by her new responsibilities. She now longer works professionally, instead devoting her time and energy to the upkeep of the abbey. She essentially puts herself in charge of food, working alongside the sisters to clean the buildings and preserve the land. As she thinks of those she left behind to begin this new life, she realizes that not only are they unable to understand her reasons for coming but she cannot explain these reasons. She seeks peace and reflection at the abbey, and she finds it in the simple work: “It would be impossible to explain to anyone from my old life why or how this—whatever it is; servitude—fills me with such peace” (84). That the rewards of such work defy explanation is central to their appeal for the protagonist: This life is not about performing success to impress others; its benefits are interior. The influence this daily work has on the protagonist reflects Isolation as a Catalyst for Self-Discovery. By coming to the abbey, and leaving her life and work behind, the protagonist sees the chance to discover what truly brings her peace. She finds that peace in an unlikely place and revels in it. She learns about what she values at the abbey, and through her work, she finds a daily purpose.
There are multiple instances in the novel in which the protagonist remembers her early years in Catholic education. Like other children attending Catholic schools, she studied the lives of saints, and she particularly remembers the story of Maria Goretti. As an adolescent, she was fascinated by the darkness and desire with which Maria’s attacker, Alessandro, approached her. However, as she grows older, she begins to question such stories. The Catholic canon is full of female saints who died resisting men’s sexual violence, and the protagonist begins to see the veneration of these women—emphasizing their chastity—as a way to avoid reckoning with the prevalence of rape and sexual assault: “As I grew older I was confused as to why martyrdom was never just called ‘murder’. But it was at ten years old I first became confused about the nature of forgiveness, and of atonement and the conditions under which they could take place” (88-89). Both the dying Maria and her mother forgive Alessandro, and the protagonist wonders why they do this, rather than react with violence or hatred. She understands how Alessandro undertakes The Pursuit of Redemption, but she finds it unjust that he is forgiven and allowed to become a respected monk while his victim dies. The protagonist knows that forgiveness is not often granted lightly, and she cannot fathom how a murderer can be given forgiveness so easily. This is a question that the protagonist continues to meditate on throughout the novel, especially as she considers her own past wrongdoing.
As the protagonist thinks about her mother more and more throughout the novel, she comes to understand that she did not know her mother as well as she thought. Now, with more maturity, she finds moments in which she wishes she had spoken to her mother more and done more to acknowledge that her mother was a complicated individual with her own struggles. She is beginning to understand The Importance of Empathy in Parent-Child Relationships, and she now realizes that not all mothers and daughters have the mutual trust that she and her mother shared. As a child, the protagonist did not have a strong enough grasp on their relationship to share this with her mother, but she now wishes she could: “I wished again that I had been able to say any of this to her when she lived. Yet I doubt I would ever have said it. There was a quiet but potent aura of unknowability around my mother” (110). This “aura of unknowability” is something the protagonist now wishes to cultivate in herself. Part of her purpose in joining the abbey is to develop the self-sufficiency her mother had—the ability to derive satisfaction from work that brings no recognition and no advancement. As a younger woman, the protagonist found it hard to share her feelings with her mother, given how little she knew about her. In the present, the protagonist as she finds herself in a similar situation with those around her. She has a similar “aura of unknowability,” unable to explain her actions to her friends. More importantly, the unknowability of her mother begins to fade as the protagonist’s new experiences later in life help her gain a deeper appreciation of who her mother was.



Unlock all 61 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.