Such Quiet Girls

Noelle W. Ihli

58 pages 1-hour read

Noelle W. Ihli

Such Quiet Girls

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2025

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

The Red Hoodie

The red hoodie symbolizes the value of taking dangerous risks and never giving up, even in the face of overwhelming odds. After delivering all the ransom money, Sheena is left wondering what to do. She has a flashback to witnessing a mother dive into the ocean to rescue her toddler, who was being swept out to sea. Sheena vividly recalls the red hoodie the child was wearing, revealing how this moment is viscerally anchored in her memory.


After reflecting on the memory, Sheena decides to call the police and reveal the ransom plot. She is empowered by the courage she witnessed the mother displaying, and reflects that, “[onlookers] thought she’d nearly just signed her own death certificate. But sometimes, there was no other way” (305). The red hoodie is a particularly significant symbol because earlier in the novel, Sheena found hooded sweatshirts belonging to her daughters on the backseat of her car. The pink one belonged to Bonnie, the red one to Sage. This textual echo deepens the symbolism by reflecting how (unbeknownst to Sheena), Sage is also embodying immense courage as she carries out the escape plan. Although Sage is a child and not a mother, she inherits the legacy of courage and resilience.

The Watch

Sheena’s father is very proud of a watch that he believes to be an expensive Rolex. It is, however, a knockoff containing a tracking device. The watch plays an important role in the plot when Sheena uses it to secretly track Ted and Andy after including the watch in the bag of cash. The watch symbolizes how creative problem-solving and protectiveness can resolve a crisis. Sheena initially purchases the watch because she knows that her father’s health is declining and he may wander away and become disoriented or lost. She wants to have the option to track him if necessary, but she also doesn’t want to rob him of his dignity.


By introducing a measure that protects her father under the guise of a luxury object he can feel proud of, Sheena shows her ability to effectively nurture others. Later, she displays the same protective instinct and innovative problem-solving by seemingly gifting the watch to Ted and Andy. While seemingly complying with their demands, Sheena finds a discreet way to gain the upper hand and protect her children. Her decision proves extremely important for allowing the police to locate the children in a timely fashion. The central conflict of the novel ends up being resolved in part because Sheena makes use of a device that originated with her caregiving responsibilities.


Since the watch is also a way of telling time, it symbolizes the urgent and time-sensitive nature of Sheena’s mission. She must carry out a challenging series of tasks in a highly efficient and organized manner while under extreme emotional duress. Sheena’s experiences as a caregiver and single mother prepare her to execute the ransom mission efficiently and effectively.

Deer

As Sheena is rushing to get home and complete the virtual transfer of the ransom funds, she nearly hits a deer standing on the road. Sheena becomes impatient with the deer causing a delay, until she realizes that the deer is accompanied by two young fawns and is cautiously guiding them across the road. The deer symbolizes the power of nurturing the vulnerable. The deer is a mother caring for two offspring, just like Sheena herself; the deer’s protective instinct to block the road until the fawns safely cross reveals the common nature of a parental instinct, shared by Jessa, Sheena, and Sheena’s father.


However, the mother deer is herself in danger when she steps onto the road. The deer—just like Sheena, Jessa, and the mother who dives into the ocean to rescue her toddler—takes risks to protect her offspring but is ultimately successful. Since the deer is able to safeguard her fawns, she symbolizes how there is power in protecting the vulnerable: She forces Sheena’s car to stop, not through power but because Sheena recognizes their shared bond and wants to safeguard the animals.


The symbolism of the deer is heightened by a number of similes and metaphors comparing Sage to a gangly fawn. Like the baby deer, Sage is slender, with long legs. She is able to run extremely fast, but she must do so because she is pursued. Sage is likened to a hunted animal when she is pursued by an adult man with a gun. These comparisons heighten the associations between women or girls and animals: Within the world of the novel, both are often threatened by men and have to rely on their instincts and drive to care for others. Jessa’s instinct to protect the vulnerable also kicks in despite her resistance and leads her to care for the children of others as if they were her own.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif

See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.

  • Explore how the author builds meaning through symbolism
  • Understand what symbols & motifs represent in the text
  • Connect recurring ideas to themes, characters, and events