Swamplandia

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of racism and mental illness.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. Russell adapted this novel from her short story “Ava Wrestles the Alligator” from St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves. How did Russell expand this story, and how does the longer format enhance your understanding of the Bigtree family’s struggles?

2. Which aspect of Swamplandia! resonated most powerfully with you—the magical realism elements, the environmental destruction themes, or the coming-of-age journeys of the three siblings?

3. The Ten Thousand Islands setting functions as both a character and a backdrop in this novel. How did Russell’s vivid portrayal of this threatened landscape shape your emotional connection to the story?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Each Bigtree sibling processes their mother’s death differently: Ava through memories and action, Osceola through spiritualism, and Kiwi through education and work. Which approach to handling significant loss feels most familiar or meaningful to you?

2. Have you ever found yourself in a situation like Kiwi’s, where your background, interests, or way of speaking made it challenging to fit into a new environment or group?

3. What role has a specific place played in shaping your family’s identity? The Bigtree family creates their entire sense of self around Swamplandia!, but eventually must learn to rebuild their identity elsewhere.

4. Ava struggles to recognize the Bird Man’s true intentions despite several warning signs. What experiences or instincts do you rely on when trying to determine whether someone is trustworthy?

5. Environmental destruction looms over the novel through invasive Melaleuca trees and encroaching development. Have you witnessed environmental changes in places that hold personal significance for you, and how did those changes affect your relationship with those spaces?

6. Ava realizes that many of her cherished recollections are actually family legends rather than personal experiences. Do you have family stories that have been told so often they feel like your own memories?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. How does Russell’s portrayal of environmental destruction in the Ten Thousand Islands connect to contemporary debates about conservation, invasive species, and climate change impacts on vulnerable ecosystems?

2. The Bigtree family adopts fake-Indigenous personas for their tourist attraction, but the novel references authentic Calusa and Seminole history. What does this contrast reveal about the commodification of Indigenous cultures versus genuine respect for their heritage and contributions?

3. Osceola’s journey from depression and ghostly obsessions to therapy and healing reflects different approaches to mental health care. How does the novel’s treatment of adolescent grief and psychological support resonate with current conversations about youth mental health?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Magical realism permeates the novel, particularly through Osceola’s ghost encounters and Ava’s surreal journey through the swamp. What evidence supports reading these supernatural elements as literal versus psychological manifestations of grief?

2. Why does Russell choose to alternate between Ava’s first-person narration and third-person chapters focused on Kiwi? How does this dual perspective deepen your understanding of both characters’ development?

3. The invasive Melaleuca trees require constant clearing as they continue spreading through the Ten Thousand Islands. What do these trees symbolize beyond their more literal role as an environmental threat?

4. How do the various ghostly encounters throughout the novel—from family seances to Ava’s final understanding of her mother’s continuing presence—trace the emotional evolution of the Bigtree family?

5. Russell consistently stages crucial scenes in liminal spaces like the Eye of the Needle passage and the boundary between mangroves and open water. What makes these threshold locations particularly powerful settings for a coming-of-age narrative?

6. Both the Chief’s “Carnival Darwinism” and Osceola’s devotion to The Spiritist’s Telegraph represent escapes into fantasy rather than facing difficult realities. How do these parallel obsessions illuminate the various ways people respond to loss and unwanted change, and how does this compare to works like Where the Crawdads Sing by Delia Owens that also explore isolation and family trauma?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. The novel concludes with the family starting fresh on the mainland, but we don’t witness their adjustment period. What specific challenges and discoveries might each family member encounter as they build new lives away from their island home?

2. Design a museum exhibit honoring the cultural and environmental history of the Ten Thousand Islands. What artifacts, stories, and perspectives would you include to showcase both the Indigenous heritage and ecological significance of this landscape?

3. Ava’s red alligator serves as her secret companion and ultimately helps her escape danger. If you could introduce one symbolic creature or object into a pivotal moment of your own life story, what would you choose and what role would it play?

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.