Sycamore Row

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of racism, graphic violence, and illness or death.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. How did Sycamore Row compare to your expectations, especially if you’ve read Grisham’s companion novel, A Time to Kill? Did the shift from life-or-death criminal defense to probate law feel like a natural progression for Jake’s character, or did you miss the higher stakes of the original novel?

2. Seth Hubbard remains largely a mystery throughout most of the novel, revealed primarily through other characters’ memories and opinions. What was your impression of Seth as a person? Did learning his true motive for changing the will shift how you viewed his earlier actions and relationships?

3. Grisham balances procedural legal details with family drama and historical revelations. Which aspect of the story engaged you most effectively? What made the combination of courtroom scenes, character development, and historical mystery work or not work for you as a reader?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. Jake takes on mentoring Portia despite the personal and professional risks it poses during the trial. Think about a time when someone took a chance on you professionally or academically. How did that experience shape your career path or personal development, and what similarities do you see with Jake and Portia’s relationship?

2. The Rostons’ decision to forgive Simeon after their sons’ deaths demonstrates remarkable grace under devastating circumstances. Have you ever faced a situation where extending forgiveness felt both necessary and nearly impossible? What helped you work through those conflicting emotions?

3. Portia’s search into her family’s history uncovers painful truths that have been hidden for generations. Have you discovered surprising or difficult information about your own family’s past? How did learning these details change your understanding of yourself or your family’s story?

4. Jake struggles with whether pursuing justice is worth the personal cost, given the threats and financial hardship his family has endured. When have you had to decide between doing what you believed was right and protecting your own interests or safety? What factors influenced your decision?

5. Throughout the novel, characters face pressure from their communities to conform to expected attitudes and behaviors. Describe a time when you felt caught between your personal beliefs and your community’s expectations. How did you navigate that tension?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The novel depicts a legal system where public opinion heavily influences jury selection and trial outcomes. How do you see this dynamic playing out in high-profile legal cases today? What parallels can you draw between the media coverage of Seth’s will and contemporary legal controversies?

2. Ford County in 1988 shows the persistence of informal segregation despite legal desegregation decades earlier. Where do you observe similar patterns of de facto segregation in housing, education, or social settings in your community or region? What factors seem to perpetuate these divisions?

3. Seth’s bequest to Lettie represents a form of individual reparations for historical injustice. How does this personal approach to addressing generational harm compare to contemporary discussions about institutional reparations? What are the advantages and limitations of an individual versus systemic approach to rectifying historical wrongs?

4. Lettie’s relationship with Simeon shows the complex dynamics of staying in a harmful situation due to financial dependence and family obligations. How do you think economic pressures influence people’s ability to leave unhealthy relationships or situations? What does Lettie’s story suggest about the connection between financial independence and personal freedom?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. Grisham reveals Seth’s character almost entirely through posthumous means—other characters’ memories, business records, and final communications. How effective is this technique for developing a character who dies in the opening scene? What does this approach allow Grisham to explore about legacy and how we’re remembered after death?

2. Ford County serves as both a setting and a character representing the entrenched attitudes and biases of the American South. How does Grisham use specific locations like the Coffee Shop, Tea Shoppe, and the old Burley school building to reinforce the novel’s themes about racial division and social hierarchy?

3. The sycamore tree transforms from a symbol of racist violence to one of atonement when Seth chooses it for his final act. How does this symbolic evolution reflect the novel’s larger themes about confronting the past and seeking redemption? What other symbols in the story undergo similar transformations?

4. Procedural elements dominate much of the novel’s middle section, with detailed descriptions of depositions, jury selection, and courtroom strategy. How do these technical aspects serve the story’s themes of justice and legal ethics? Do the procedural details enhance or detract from the emotional impact of the characters’ journeys?

5. Wade Lanier functions as Jake’s primary antagonist, representing everything Jake opposes about trial law. How does their conflict illuminate the novel’s critique of legal ethics? What makes Lanier an effective foil for highlighting Jake’s moral principles?

6. The novel’s structure builds toward Ancil’s videotaped deposition as the climactic revelation that solves the central mystery. How does Grisham balance withholding this crucial information while still providing enough clues for readers to follow the investigation? What techniques does he use to maintain suspense without frustrating readers?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. The novel ends with a settlement that divides Seth’s estate among multiple parties rather than honoring his original intent completely. Write an alternative resolution that might better serve both Seth’s wishes and the principles of justice. How would your ending address the competing claims and historical grievances?

2. Several characters mention that Mississippi leads the nation in lynchings. Design a museum exhibit or educational program that would help visitors understand this history and its ongoing impact on communities like Ford County. What artifacts, stories, or interactive elements would you include?

3. The story reveals how legal strategies and public opinion intersect in ways that can either serve or subvert justice. Choose a contemporary legal case or social issue and write a story illustrating how the tactics used by Jake, Lanier, or Sistrunk might apply today. Which of their approaches would be most effective in our current media environment, and why?

Need more conversation starters? Inspire your group with our Discussion Questions tool.