49 pages • 1-hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Light is one of the most consistent motifs in the novel; both in the literal paintings and as a metaphor for truth and perception. Claire studies how Degas captured light on skin and fabric, and she uses that same attention to detail in her forgery. She is also obsessed with light in her personal work, capturing how it reflects through windows. She uses old-fashioned oil techniques primarily for their ability to show light from within. Claire often notes the weather and how the light shines through her studio. The light at any given moment often mirrors Claire’s internal conflict; she seeks clarity and truth in her art, even as she participates in deceit.
Degas’s After the Bath, along with the two forgeries, functions as a central symbol of authenticity and obsession. At first, the painting represents both opportunity and temptation to Claire; it is a chance to prove her technical brilliance, but it also puts her in an ethically questionable position. Within the novel, the painting’s uncertain provenance embodies the instability of truth in the art world: Just because experts have “proven” a painting genuine does not mean it is. This raises the question of what it means for art to be genuine in the first place.
Fire imagery runs through the novel, most vividly in the scenes where Claire “bakes” her forged painting to simulate the aging of oil and varnish. The heat symbolizes transformation, her process turns her forgery into something that appears genuine, even to experts. Fire-related language also appears in the novel’s erotic scenes, symbolizing that lust can cause people to make dangerous choices they wouldn’t otherwise make, such as Belle posing for the nude painting. The fire symbolism reflects the pressure Claire feels: She is driven by a burning desire to succeed, even if her entire world might burn in the process.
Claire’s studio serves as a symbolic space of isolation, creativity, and secrecy. It’s where she lives and works, blurring boundaries between her art and her life. This is mirrored in the descriptions of Degas’s studio, which is similarly cluttered. Claire sees the studio as part of her artistic identity, as shown through scenes like the first meeting with Markel, in which she intentionally keeps her studio messy to show him her paintings in their element.
The motif of forging versus reproducing runs throughout the novel; from Claire’s online reproduction business, to 4D, to the forged Degas. These works function as plot devices and raise philosophical questions about the distinction between a reproduction and a forgery. Shapiro uses the technical details of Claire’s work and the art world’s flawed process of authentication to explore how technology and commerce blur the line between art and product. At the end of the novel, these questions become relevant to the criminal case. The true provenance of After the Bath, and the question of who knew what about the painting, become the key deciding factors in whether a crime was committed. However, despite the real After the Bath never being involved in the forgery at all, both the buyer and Markel remain in jail at the end of the book.



Unlock the meaning behind every key symbol & motif
See how recurring imagery, objects, and ideas shape the narrative.