49 pages • 1-hour read
Elin HilderbrandA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide includes discussion of substance use, illness, pregnancy loss, child death, and sexual content.
A week later, Bill writes again to S. B. T. demanding some answers regarding their identity. Mack has been living in Lacey’s cottage since his break-up with Maribel. Howard “How-Baby” Comatis, the president of the Texas Rangers, arrives with his wife and some baseball friends. They’re all fond of Mack, and How-Baby offers him a position with the Rangers at triple his salary. Not realizing Mack and Maribel have split, How-Baby encourages Mack to talk to her about the future. When Mack reveals that they’re not together, How-Baby makes Mack shout his love for her to the water louder and louder until he’s convincing.
Mack teaches James to shave, and James tells Mack that he loves him. Mack tells Andrea that he may not come back to the hotel next year. Mack then goes to see Maribel, who is with Jem. Jem quickly exits, and Mack tells Maribel about How-Baby’s offer, saying that he wants her to come with him to Texas. She declines, but then he asks her to marry him, and she happily agrees. When Mack tells Lacey, she is glad to see him happy but sad that he’ll be leaving. In contrast, Cecily doesn’t react to the news well, surprising herself. Her jealousy makes her wonder whether she might be in love with Mack or Maribel—or whether she just wants to get married to Gabriel. She counts the money she’s been saving to go to Brazil. Bill resigns himself to Mack’s departure. He tells Mack that he’ll give him a raise, but Mack notes that Bill has made it clear that the hotel is for Cecily—as it should be. When Mack tells Therese about his plans to go to Texas, she feels like he’s throwing her dreams for him and Cecily away. Meanwhile, Maribel calls Jem to tell him the news; he is broken-hearted, as he’s now in love with Maribel. Though she feels guilty about this, she and Mack celebrate his accepting the job with How-Baby and his wife.
S. B. T. writes to say that he knows there’s been a shake-up in hotel personnel; he suggests that Bill sell, upping his offer. Meanwhile, Love and Vance’s relationship has become intimate; they enjoy their time together and have developed a routine. Reading a short story that Vance wrote, Love wonders how much of it is based on reality and is surprised and worried about his vulnerability. However, her feelings sour when Vance reveals that he may want children and says that he’d do anything she asked. She is disconcerted, having thought the relationship was casual. Panicking, she kicks Vance out, which he interprets as her hating his writing. Love takes a taxi to work, and the cabbie advises her to tell Vance that she may have conceived. Eventually, Love and Vance talk, and she says she just wants a summer fling. He accepts this, and they embrace. However, Love’s conscience urges her to tell him she may be pregnant.
Jem is eager for summer to end so that he can leave Nantucket and stop pining for Maribel. He befriends a wealthy guest named Neil Rosenblum, who is 42, and they pal around together getting drunk and smoking pot. Like Lacey earlier, Neil advises Jem not to worry so much about his parents being upset that he’s going to California. Neil eventually confesses that he’s not sure he should marry his girlfriend, although he hopes to be a good father to their little girl. He urges Jem to go after Maribel since he truly loves her. Neil also tells Jem that he’s dying of cancer. Jem starts to cry as he thinks of everyone he knows eventually dying, but he also urges Neil to propose to his girlfriend for his daughter’s sake. Later, Neil compliments Jem in front of Maribel and then takes Jem’s advice and proposes to his girlfriend.
The next day, Jem thinks about Neil as he admires the world while walking to work. Neil passes in a cab, waving goodbye. At the hotel, Neil has left a letter for Jem, which he initially throws away. However, when Maribel notes that Neil seemed to believe in Jem, he goes back for the envelope. Inside, he finds a check for $15,000 with two tickets to California and a note telling him to go after Maribel.
Nantucket is in the middle of an August heat wave. Lacey is having a difficult time sleeping and remembers a conversation with Max where she asked if he regretted not having children; he didn’t answer. Now, Mack comes over to chat with her and brings her a cool drink. She wonders who will take care of her after Mack leaves.
Mack and Maribel are also distressed. They’ve been fighting due to the heat and Mack’s stress at work. Maribel is annoyed that they haven’t made any wedding plans. She feels she is his second choice and demands to know if he still loves Andrea. Mack says that she’s being ridiculous but won’t say he doesn’t love Andrea. When she asks if he wants to marry Andrea, Mack blurts out that he doesn’t want to get married at all. He hastens to amend this, but Maribel knows he’s spoken the truth.
Bill accidentally double-books a room, so one of the guests must stay in the main house with Bill and his wife. The guest turns out to be Mrs. Jane Hassiter, a custodian who’s just retired from Cecily’s boarding school. Once, she walked in on Cecily and her boyfriend having sex but didn’t report Cecily. At the time, Cecily screamed at Jane, who meekly retreated. In hindsight, Cecily feels horrible and apologizes, arranging it so that Jane won’t need to pay for her room. However, Jane insists on doing so. She also gives Cecily the money from her last paycheck so that she can follow Gabriel to Brazil. Cecily writes a letter to her parents and leaves the hotel to go to Rio de Janeiro.
Finding out that their daughter is missing makes Bill furious; he lashes out at Therese, accusing her of knowing Cecily’s plans. Therese, having seen a picture of Gabriel, thinks of Cecily as seizing the day but assures Bill that she will return. When Mrs. Hassiter confesses that she gave Cecily the money, Bill flies off the handle, but Therese understands. Therese takes Bill to their son’s grave, where they mourn together. Love finds out she’s pregnant as everyone reacts to Cecily leaving.
The Fourth of July holiday marks a symbolic turning point in several characters’ arcs thanks to its associations with independence. However, where Cecily asserted her right to make her own decisions in her argument with her parents, other characters are more ambivalent. Mack, for example, finds himself at a crossroads and newly “free” to determine his own course: His relationships with Andrea and Maribel have both ended, and with Bill’s rejection of profit-sharing, he no longer sees a future at the hotel. In an example of The Importance of Chance Encounters, the arrival of Howard “How-Baby” Comatis leads Mack to realize that he has boxed himself into believing he only had two choices in life: to reside in Iowa or Nantucket. He decides to imagine a new life in Texas. A parting with Andrea solidifies his confidence when she notes, “You aren’t beholden to me or anyone else, Mack. You’re your own person” (186). These new beginnings allow him to reconsider his options with new authority, and when he proposes to Maribel, she says yes.
However, several factors complicate the renewed relationship, including Maribel’s growing feelings for Jem. Like Mack, Jem embraces agency in this section thanks to a relationship he forms with a hotel guest: Neil Rosenblum, who urges Jem to believe in himself both professionally and romantically. Jem’s character growth is evident in his response to learning that Neil is dying of cancer, as Jem gives him good advice about his future. The fact of Neil’s illness also makes Jem appreciate the intensity and depth of life: “[L]ife felt good—even though Jem was miserable about Maribel, it felt good to hurt, to yearn, to want” (246). As Jem becomes a stronger, more self-sufficient person, the novel increasingly positions him as a potential partner for Maribel.
Moreover, Mack and Maribel remain at odds over their vision for the future, primarily due to something Mack has yet to admit to himself: He doesn’t really want to leave the place he has made home for 12 years, and he “[doesn’t] want to marry anybody” (268), as he inadvertently blurts out during a fight. This exacerbates Maribel’s fears that he doesn’t love her and cannot fill up her emptiness. The stability she thought she had achieved suddenly becomes tenuous at best, calling the relationship into question once more and underscoring The Long-Term Impact of Emotional Voids. The heat wave that arrives in the middle of August, just as Mack prepares to leave, creates an oppressive atmosphere that echoes the renewed interpersonal tensions (Bill and Lacey, who serve as Mack’s surrogate parents, are also somewhat at odds with him as they struggle to accept his departure).
Vance, too, undergoes character growth in this sequence as he embarks on a relationship with Love. After years of rivalry with Mack, “[Love] [makes] him want to lighten up. She [makes] him want to laugh. So, he would have his own summer romance for once. And who [knows], maybe someday he’d be the one getting married” (209). The passage suggests that love can be a way of Finding One’s Way Through Grief and Anger. Love’s own character arc also progresses as a result of the relationship, as she has started to feel more than she expected: “[T]he more [she] discovered about Vance, the more he impressed her” (216). However, Love panics after Vance talks about having children one day. Married to her plan of being alone, she rejects him, and while Vance reassures her that he doesn’t expect commitment, Love starts to feel guilty about keeping her pregnancy from him. This shows that she feels far more connected to him than she wants to admit.
Meanwhile, Cecily’s storyline reaches a crisis that prompts her to take decisive action. She reacts with jealousy to Mack and Maribel’s engagement because she envies the fact that they’re moving forward while she is stuck in the role of her parents’ child. In determining to get the money she needs to get to Brazil, she finds support from a chance encounter with Jane, who gives Cecily both the confidence and funds to travel to Brazil and make a stab at independence. This action marks her growing self-assertion but also has spillover effects, catalyzing Bill’s own emotional crisis. Bill sees his daughter’s departure as abandonment: To him, her actions undermine the devotion he has shown his family and the efforts he has made to recover from the loss of W. T. With Mack leaving, too, Bill falls into a depression, thinking that his family has broken apart. Therese understands Bill’s grief, expressing confidence that Cecily will return but secretly wondering, “[W]ould Cecily be back? Or would they be left to cry in graveyards? Nobody’s parents” (278). Her hope that it will soon rain shows how deeply she would like some outward force to change their circumstances and lead to renewal at a time when their future seems increasingly uncertain.



Unlock all 49 pages of this Study Guide
Get in-depth, chapter-by-chapter summaries and analysis from our literary experts.