The Bell Jar

Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussion of mental illness, sexual content, and death by suicide.

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

1. What aspects of The Bell Jar’s portrayal of mental illness resonated most strongly with you? How effectively did Plath’s central metaphor of mental illness as a bell jar help you understand Esther’s experience of depression?

2. The novel balances moments of dark humor with despair throughout Esther’s journey. Did this tonal contrast make her story more accessible or more unsettling to you? If you’re familiar with Plath’s other work, how did her voice differ in The Bell Jar and Ariel (her second poetry collection)?

3. Readers often debate whether the novel’s conclusion offers hope or uncertainty for Esther’s future. Were you satisfied with the ambiguous ending? What do you imagine happens to Esther after the final page?

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

1. The fig tree represents Esther’s sense of emotional paralysis when facing too many life options. Think about a time when you felt overwhelmed by possibilities. What helped you move forward when you faced difficult choices?

2. Which character in the novel did you find yourself most drawn to or repelled by? What does reaction reflect about your values and self-perception?

3. The relationship between Esther and her mother reveals how difficult it can be for parents to understand their children’s struggles with mental health. Have you witnessed similar communication gaps in relationships around you? What helps bridge these divides?

4. Dr. Nolan provides Esther with understanding and guidance when she most needs it. Who has fulfilled such a mentorship role for you during difficult times? What qualities made their support particularly meaningful?

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

1. The novel captures women’s limited options during the conservative postwar period before second-wave feminism. What aspects of Esther’s experience would be different for a young woman today? Which struggles remain surprisingly similar?

2. Throughout the novel, Plath links public events and private suffering. She begins the novel by referring to the Rosenbergs’ execution, connecting the political climate to personal crisis. How did this historical backdrop influence your reading of Esther’s experience?

3. Medical professionals in The Bell Jar often mishandle women’s mental health concerns, as Dr. Gordon’s dismissive treatment exemplifies. What commentary does the novel offer about gender bias in healthcare in the 1950s setting? Have approaches to mental health treatment evolved since then?

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

1. What narrative techniques does Plath use to illustrate Esther’s fragmenting sense of self? How does the writing style itself reflect her deteriorating mental state?

2. Joan Gilling functions as Esther’s double, or mirror, throughout the novel. In what ways are the two women similar and different? How does Joan’s trajectory, culminating in her death by suicide, contribute to Esther’s journey toward recovery?

3. In addition to the novel’s central symbol, the bell jar, and the fig tree, what other symbolic elements recur throughout the text, and what do they represent? Consider Esther’s clothing choices and the motifs of birth and death.

4. Esther’s virginity becomes increasingly significant as the novel progresses. What does her sexual experience with Irwin represent in her developmental journey? How does Plath use this experience to challenge 1950s double standards regarding sexuality?

5. Critics debate whether The Bell Jar should be read as a feminist text. What elements of the novel support or challenge this classification? Plath’s portrayal of female characters like Dr. Nolan, Mrs. Willard, and Doreen adds complexity to this discussion.

6. The novel is semi-autobiographical, drawing heavily on Plath’s own experiences with depression. What effect did the novel’s use of first-person narration, a perspective that provides intimate access to Esther’s thoughts but may limit other viewpoints, have on your understanding of Esther’s mental illness?

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

1. Esther describes her experience of depression as a bell jar that descends and cuts her off from the world. If you were to create your own metaphor for feeling isolated or disconnected, what image would you choose and why?

2. Imagine Esther Greenwood’s life five years after the events of the novel. What might she be doing professionally and personally? Would she have found sustainable ways to manage her mental health?

3. If you were adapting The Bell Jar for a contemporary film or television series, what modern elements would you incorporate? Consider how social media, current psychiatric treatments, and today’s gender expectations might transform Esther’s story.

4. Esther attempts to pen a novel during her summer at home but abandons the project. If you were writing a contemporary version of The Bell Jar, what themes would you explore? How would your protagonist differ from or resemble Esther?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.